The Reds scored twice off All-Star closer 4, in the game series on Sunday.

Hanrahan, who blew his third save of the season, gave up three singles and two walks before he was pulled.

Ramon Hernandez had an RBI base hit to tie the game and the go-ahead run scored on Brandon Phillips' ground out, which the Pirates couldn't convert into a double play that would have ended the inning.

Joey Votto hit a three-run homer earlier for the Reds, who won two of three in the series.

Jose Tabata signed a six-year contract extension before the game and scored twice for the Pirates, both times on two-run homers by Andrew McCutchen and Garrett Jones.