Trump's Manhattan fraud trial enters day 5
Presiding Judge Arthur Engoron rejected former President Donald Trump’s request to delay a civil trial last week. James sued Trump, his children and the Trump Organization, alleging that Trump "inflated his net worth by billions of dollars" and said his children helped him to do so.
Coverage for this event has ended.
Judge denies Trump request to pause trial, grants stay on business dissolution
Judge Peter Moulton has denied former President Donald Trump's request to pause his civil fraud trial pending an appeal of a previous ruling by Judge Arthur Engoron.
Trump's attorney, Chris Kise, called Engoron's ruling last week that Trump committed fraud while building his real estate empire "an avalanche of eror," and said there was no evidence of wrongdoing.
He added that the decision to dissolve Trump's businesses in New York would have have an irreparable impact on numerous companies, employees, and that it could not be undone.
"We’re not seeking a delay. We’re not seeking anything but a fair trial," Kise said, before calling the trial "chaos."
Attorney Judith Vale, who represented New York Attorney General Letitia James' office, questioned the need for a stay. She said her team was willing to work with the defendants on a stay on some of the injunctive relief while the trial was ongoing.
“I don’t think anyone thinks revoking certificates means lights go off on 40 Wall St. tomorrow," Vale said, adding there was no irreparable harm by continuing to litigate the trial.
Moulton ruled the trial would continue, but ordered an interim stay on the Trump business dissolution.
Fox News' Maria Paronich contributed to this report.
Hearing begins on Trump's request to pause civil fraud trial pending appeal
The hearing has begun regarding former President Donald Trump's request to pause his civil fraud trial.
Judge Arthur Engoron opened the hearing by saying he wasn't 'inclined' to grant the motion, but told Trump's legal team they could spend their time trying to convince him.
Trump requested the stay pending the appeal of Engoran's ruling last week that he had committed fraud while building his real estate empire.
A decision on the stay could come today.
Court breaks until next week, when Allen Weisselberg will take the stand

The fifth day of former President Donald Trump's civil fraud trial in Manhattan wrapped up at 12:45 p.m., with the trial set to resume next week.
Former Trump Organization controller Jeffrey McConney testified about the 2013 valuation of Trump National Golf Club Westchester in Briarcliff Manor, New York. He was questioned by prosecutor Andrew Amer, who said the valuation was based on the addition of 71 midrise housing units.
The Trump Organization said the units would be worth $101 million when completed, however an appraisal had valued them at $43.3 million, Amer said.
McConney testified that he had a conversation with Eric Trump, the president's second son, who instructed him to "leave the value as is" despite the appraisal.
During a discussion about another Trump property at Seven Springs in Westchester County, New York, McConney admitted the property's $261 million valuation in 2013 included seven mansions, estimated to be worth $23 million each, that were not yet built.
McConney also told prosecutors that former Trump Organization chief financial officer Allen Weisselberg was his boss. When asked by Amer whether Weisselberg asked him (McConney) on more than one occasion if Weisselberg asked him to commit fraud, he said no.
However, Amer then pointed to McConney's testimony during the Manhattan district attorney's trial where he responded differently. He read a portion of the transcript where McConney admits to processing a payroll check for Weisselberg’s wife so she can get social security benefits and that he (McConney) knew it was illegal.
McConney then said that he did that because Weisselber was his boss and he was afraid to get fired.
Weisselberg will take the stand when the trial resumes Tuesday at 10:00 a.m. ET.
Fox News' Maria Paronich and Helena Cheng contributed to this report.
New York AG Letitia James says Trump request for stay is meant to 'sow chaos'

New York Attorney General Letitia James accused Donald Trump's legal team of attempting to "sow chaos" by pausing the ongoing civil fraud trial.
In a court filing responding to Trump's request for a stay of the trial, James said that granting Trump's request would lead to a "cascade of delays" that would interrupt the other pending litigation involving the former president.
"A stay is a drastic remedy in all cases, but defendants cannot come close to demonstrating that the equities or the merits favor the truly extraordinary relief of upending an ongoing trial midstream," James wrote in a letter to the court.
The state's top prosecutor argued Trump's request for a stay pending his appeal of Judge Athur Engoron's summary judgement, which found Trump liable of fraud, would upset months of planning for witness testimony and special arrangements to provide the public access to the high-profile trial.
"And tellingly, they waited until after Mr. Trump decided to stop attending the trial," the letter said. "Defendants have thus sought to interrupt trial midcourse in a highly disruptive manner, and this Court should deny an interim stay on that basis alone."
James also accused Trump's team of attempting to "play one court against the other" by invoking the busy schedule of Trump's other pending cases in the request for a stay.
In addition to James' civil fraud case, Trump is due in court for criminal trials the New York hush money case, the Georgia election interference case, Special Counsel Jack Smith's federal election interference case in Washington, D.C. and his classified documents case.
Fox News' Maria Paronich contributed to this update.
Trump defense team files for emergency stay of civil fraud trial

Former President Donald Trump's legal team has filed an emergency stay of his civil fraud trial.
Trump's lawyers are requesting the trial be delayed until an appeal on Judge Arthur Engoron's summary judgment, which found Trump liable of fraud, can be heard. They are also requesting a stay of enforcement on the summary judgement decision and the cancelation of his business licenses. Trump's team believes the judge's order will cause the loss of hundreds of jobs.
The document filed Friday states in part, “Supreme Court’s decision will unquestionably inflict severe and irreparable harm not only to Appellants but to innocent nonparties and employees who depend on the affected entities for their livelihoods. Terminating non-party business licenses without jurisdiction, without process, without statutory authority, without trial, and without reason renders impossible the lawful operation of multiple businesses and threatens termination of hundreds of New York employees without any jurisdiction or due process. Supreme Court clearly does not comprehend the scope of the chaos its decision has wrought.”
Fox News' Maria Paronich contributed to this report.
Trump attorney Alina Habba says defense will appeal judge's order to dissolve Trump companies
Trump attorney Alina Habba said Thursday that former President Donald Trump will appeal an order from Judge Arthur Engoron that cancelled his business certificates.
Habba told FOX Business host Larry Kudlow that "all legal excessive bounds" were being broken in New York Attorney General Letitia James' civil fraud case against Trump, alleging that he exaggerated the value of his properties and defrauded lenders and others.
"I want the American people to understand this judge already ordered that the Trump Organization, all affiliated companies, even his trust, be dissolved. That was ordered before we walked into that courtroom, before an expert took the stand, before anybody took the stand, and before my clients could even take the stand and defend themselves," Habba said. "So he summarily ordered that. That is something that is breaking news. We will be appealing and that'll be filed tomorrow."
Habba said the judge's order set a precedent that should worry the people of New York.
"If we're saying that the attorney general can now leap and dive into private businesses, private enterprises, because they are using a consumer fraud application in a private business. That is a very concerning and very serious issue for businesses in the state of New York that that has never been done before," she said.
Trump withdraws lawsuit against Judge Engoron and NY AG Letitia James

On Thursday night, former President Donald Trump's attorneys withdrew his lawsuit against Judge Arthur Engoron and New York Attorney General Letitia James.
Trump had sued in an attempt to make the judge either issue an order limiting the civil fraud case against him or delay the trial. But last week, an appeals court denied Trump's request to stay the ongoing trial.
The lawsuit was discontinued without prejudice, according to a court filing.
In a lawsuit filed last year, AG James accuses President Trump of inflating the value of his assets in order to obtain favorable loans from banks. James is seeking $250 million in penalties and to ban Trump from doing business in NY.
Last week, the judge in the case, Judge Arthur Engoron, ruled President Trump was liable for fraud and refused to dismiss the lawsuit. He also ordered some of Trump’s business licenses to be rescinded.
The judge will ultimately decide if Trump, his sons, and business is liable in 6 other causes of action. President Trump has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing and referred to the lawsuit as another witch-hunt. He has also attacked both Judge Engoron and AG James on social media multiple times, calling the judge “deranged” and James a “racist.”
Fox News' Maria Paronich contributed to this update.
Legal expert rips New York AG's civil fraud case against Trump as unconstitutional
Fox News legal analyst Gregg Jarrett said Thursday that New York Attorney General Letitia James may have violated former President Trump's constitutional rights with her civil fraud case.
Jarrett joined "The Evening Edit" and told host Elizabeth MacDonald that James was "turning the law on its head" to go after Trump. "This executive law, Liz, was intended for consumer fraud cases impacting the general public. Here, the public wasn't impacted at all. Indeed, no party was harmed, which is normally an element of proof in fraud cases. The banks paid more than $100 million in profits from the loans to Trump," said Jarrett.
"So, you know, this statute, as it's being used by Letitia James, is really turning the law on its head. It gives her unfettered authority to pursue Trump for fraud without actually having to prove the basic elements of fraud demanded by law. And that, as you say, deprives the defendant of a right to fairly defend himself. And it also deprives him of a right to a trial by jury, both of which are due process violations under the fifth, the seventh and the 14th Amendments to the Constitution," he continued.
Jarrett argued that Judge Arthur Engoron's order forcing the dissolution of Trump's companies was unconstitutional as well.
"The judge's order of forced dissolution of any company that Trump has an interest in, well, what's that going to do? It's going to adversely impact every other business partner and entity associated with Trump that are not part of this case. They weren't even sued. They'll be harmed with no notice, no right to defend their interests. How is that consumer protection? It's not. It's consumer punishment. This isn't equitable relief, which the statute calls for. It's a severe penalty where trial by jury rights are utterly abysmal," Jarrett said.
Trump endorses candidate for House Speaker after skipping trial on Thursday
Former President Trump took a break from his legal troubles overnight Thursday to endorse Rep. Jim Jordan, R-Ohio, to be the next speaker of the House.
"Congressman Jim Jordan has been a STAR long before making his very successful journey to Washington, D.C., representing Ohio’s 4th Congressional District.," Trump posted on his TRUTH Social. "Respected by all, he is now Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee."
"As President, I had the honor of presenting Jim with our Country’s highest civilian award, The Presidential Medal of Freedom," Trump continued. "So much is learned from sports, and Jim was a master!"
Trump, praising Jordan’s wrestling record, said that "while attending Graham High School, he won State Championships all four years, a rarity, and compiled an amazing 156-1 record. At the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Jim became a two-time NCAA Division l Wrestling Champion."
"He won his 1985-86 NCAA Championship Matches in his weight class," Trump posted. "Jim has a masters degree in Education from Ohio State University & a Law Degree from Capital University."
He added: "He is STRONG on Crime, Borders, our Military/Vets, & 2nd Amendment. Jim, his wife, Polly, & family are outstanding - He will be a GREAT Speaker of the House, & has my Complete & Total Endorsement!"
Jordan, the chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, announced his bid for speaker of the House on Wednesday after Rep. Kevin McCarthy’s historic ouster, following a successful motion to vacate.
House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, R-La., also announced his bid for speaker of the House.
FLASHBACK: Letitia James denied 'personal vendetta' against Trump but called him 'illegitimate'

New York Attorney General Letitia James once insisted she did not have a "personal vendetta" against former President Trump despite her rhetoric suggesting otherwise.
Trump has waged a war of words with James as she brought a civil lawsuit to trial putting his real estate business empire in legal jeopardy over fraud allegations.
This week James declared, "The Donald Trump show is over. This was nothing more than a political stunt. A fund-raising stop, and now we can continue to go forward with our trial, and we are confident that justice will be served."
Back in August 2019, James dismissed Trump's allegations that her work is part of a "political witch hunt," a "personal vendetta" and that she "campaigned against him," assuring MSNBC's Rachel Maddow, "That is not true."
However, at multiple political rallies, James declared Trump an "illegitimate president."
"His days are numbered!" James shouted to supporters.
At another rally, James told the crowd, "We've got to get ready to mobilize, and we've got to get ready to agitate and irritate until victory is won, but more importantly, until Trump is defeated."
"We will all rise up and resist this man!" James said at a separate event. "We'll bring him down!"
Repeating her "illegitimate" jab against Trump, she once told him, "I'm going to give you the same level of respect that you gave to President Obama, and that is absolutely no respect at all."
In December 2018, after she won her election to attorney general, James said, "We will use every area of the law to investigate President Trump and his business transactions and that of his family as well."
Evidence submitted suggests Trump got final review of financial statements

Trump Organization financial documents suggest that former President Donald Trump had final review over his statements, according to evidence entered into court Thursday.
A copy of the Trump Organization's 2014 statement of financial condition marked-up by former controller Jeffrey McConney included a handwritten note that reads, "DJT TO GET FINAL REVIEW."
The document also contained a list of the 2013 value of Trump's properties, which McConney had edited to reflect 2014 values.
McConney testified in court Thursday that Trump Organization executives boosted the value of the former president's properties based on asking prices for comparable properties rather than sales prices, as appraisals use.
McConney, who worked at the Trump Organization from 1987 until February, also testified at the company's criminal tax fraud trial last year. Granted immunity from prosecution, the ex-controller admitted breaking the law to help fellow executives avoid taxes on company-paid perks, including by filing false tax returns.
The company was convicted. Trump himself wasn’t charged in that case.
McConney acknowledged Thursday that he made the notes on the 2014 financial document but did not elaborate on Trump's involvement.
The Associated Press contributed to this post.
New York AG Letitia James makes unusual statement as Trump fraud trial proceeds

New York Attorney General Letitia James issued a public statement on the ongoing civil fraud trial against former President Donald Trump in an unusual move for a prosecutor.
In a short video posted on X, James commented on testimony given Thursday by Jeffrey McConney, the former controller at the Trump organization.
"Mr. McConney was responsible for collecting the data and valuations that were used to compile the fraudulent statements of financial condition at the center of our case. He testified that he and other defendants, including Allen Weisselberg, used baseless property values to inflate Mr. Trump's net worth," James said.
James' lawsuit against Trump alleges he committed fraud by exaggerating his wealth and property values in order to obtain tax benefits, insurance benefits and favorable loan terms.
"The defendants like to act as though this case is very complicated when, in fact, the fraud they committed is simple," James continued. "Donald Trump often calls his business 'perfect,' and 'beautiful.' But it's clear that when it comes to running a company, he doesn't care about the real numbers or the facts. The reality is, under our system of law, the facts matter. And we will continue to make our case in court."
Liberal Washington Post columnist surprisingly worries Trump is the victim of double standard in NY
Liberal Washington Post columnist and associate editor Ruth Marcus wrote Tuesday that she was worried that former President Donald Trump was getting harsher treatment that "anyone else" in the New York fraud case against him.
"The rule of law means not allowing Trump to evade responsibility, criminal or civil, for his behavior. But it also entails not treating Trump more harshly than anyone else in similar circumstances, and I worry that is what is happening here," she wrote.
Marcus said that while she believes Trump is a "fraudster," the punishment the former president received was "unprecedented."
"But forcing the sale or other disposition of his businesses, as the judge ordered in his opinion last week, seems both unnecessary and unduly punitive, disproportionate to the offenses charged. And I worry that this consequence would not have been meted out to a different defendant who engaged in similar misconduct," Marcus continued.
Marcus cites multiple experts, including one who worked at the New York attorney general's office that said that "legal experts are trying to grapple with this in real time because to the extent that this remedy has been utilized before it hasn’t been utilized for a remedy of this scale and scope."
Trump drops lawsuit against Michael Cohen, vows to re-file after he has 'prevailed' in other cases

Former President Trump is voluntarily dismissing his lawsuit against his former attorney Michael Cohen, but vowed to refile against him once he has "prevailed" in the "witch hunts against him," Fox News Digital has learned.
Trump sued Cohen for $500 million in April, alleging a breach of attorney-client relationship, unjust enrichment, and more.
But Trump attorneys on Thursday night filed a motion "voluntarily dismissing this action without prejudice."
"Given that President Trump is required to sit for deposition in a civil matter on Columbus Day, when he is scheduled to be in the Great State of New Hampshire, and while the President is fighting against the meritless claims that have been lodged against him in New York, Washington D.C., Florida, and Georgia, as well as continuing his winning campaign, where he is leading the Republicans by 60 points and Crooked Joe Biden by 11 points, to serve as our next President of the United States, President Trump has decided to temporarily pause his meritorious claims against Michael Cohen," the Trump spokesperson said.
The lawsuit will be refiled against Cohen at a later date, the spokesperson said.
"Once President Trump has prevailed in dealing with the witch hunts against him, he will continue to pursue his claims against Michael Cohen, who rightfully deserves to, and will be held accountable for his unlawful words and actions just as the Southern District of New York held him accountable for numerous non-Trump related acts and crimes, making Cohen a very ‘proud’ felon," the spokesperson said.
Trump’s legal team in April filed the more-than 30-page federal lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, alleging Cohen breached his attorney-client relationship by "spreading falsehoods" about Trump that were "likely to be embarrassing or detrimental, and partook in other misconduct," while also breaching contractual terms of a confidentiality agreement he signed as a condition of employment with Trump.
The lawsuit alleged that Cohen spread falsehoods about Trump "with malicious intent and to wholly self-serving ends."
Cohen is a witness in New York Attorney General Letitia James' lawsuit against Trump alleging that he fraudulently overvalued his properties and exaggerated his wealth. Cohen has claimed Trump would regularly task him and other lawyers with inflating his net worth and testified that he witnessed this behavior regularly between 2011 and 2015.
Trump attorney Christopher Kise declared that Trump's financial statements contained no false entries, and that prosecutors were relying on a the word of a known liar, Michael Cohen, to establish wrongdoing.
Fox News' Chris Pandolfo and Anders Hagstrom contributed to this update.
'View' co-host says Trump court appearances part of 2024 'strategy'
"The View" co-host Sara Haines said Thursday that Donald Trump's legal problems and appearance in court this week is part of a 2024 campaign strategy to make sure "we're all talking about him."
The panel discussed the former president appearing in a New York courtroom during civil lawsuit proceedings brought against him by the New York Attorney General Letitia James and the judge's decision to impose a gag-order preventing all parties from engaging in any verbal attacks against court staff.
"I think these trials are affecting how much Donald Trump can actually engage in campaigning. Yesterday he was being told he’s broke and dealing with the fraud cases. He was completely tapped out of the Kevin McCarthy drama. He didn’t come to the defense of my Kevin. He didn’t call Matt Gaetz or anything," co-host Alyssa Farah Griffin said.
Haines disagreed as she interrupted and said that it was all part of the Republican presidential front-runner's campaign "strategy."
"He did it in 2016. We’re all talking about him. They had cameras on the courthouse to see if he walks his little buns in there – big buns. Sorry," she said, prompting laughter from the audience.
"But point being, we’re not talking about potential options because we hear these polls all the time. No one else is going to get it, but we're not talking about them. We’re also doing it right now, but every news network is watching Donald Trump. He dominates the air waves and then he uses that as his campaign," Haines said.
Fox News' Hanna Panreck contributed to this report.
Day 4 recap: Trump Organization execs testify Trump's penthouse value boosted by millions

Former Trump Organization controller Jeffrey McConney testified Thursday that company executives once boosted the estimated worth of Trump's Manhattan penthouse by $20 million.
At day four of Trump's civil fraud trial in Manhattan, witnesses were called to present evidence to show that Trump overvalued his properties. New York Attorney General Letitia James in a lawsuit alleges the former president conspired with his top executives to exaggerate his wealth and deceive lenders and others. Trump has denied any wrongdoing.
In pretrial testimony, the former president said that people who did business with him were given ample warning not to trust the statements, and that he never thought that the documents “would be taken very seriously.” He described the financial statements as more a “compilation of properties” than a true representation of their value, saying some numbers were “guesstimates.”
But McConney’s testimony came with evidence that the documents were integral to some of Trump’s loan deals. In letters shown in the court, McConney told a bank that he was providing Trump’s 2015 and 2016 financial statements as required under the conditions of a loan for his Seven Springs estate north of New York City.
McConney testified that Trump executives valued his penthouse by searching through real estate listings and comparing it to only the highest-priced similar apartments. He said a $100 million increase in the penthouse's valuation in 2012 was based on an asking price for a similar triplex in a Trump-owned building elsewhere in Manhattan — an apartment that eventually sold for just 40% of its asking price.
In 2013, McConney added another $20 million, increasing the value of Trump's penthouse to $200 million. He testified that the change was based partly on a suggestion from a Trump real estate executive who said the apartment should be valued higher because Trump was a celebrity.
McConney also said he used his own calculations instead of relying on a bank appraisal to increase the stated worth of Trump's Wall Street office building by $227 million.
Prosecutors say these and other asset valuations were included in Trump's financial statements, which were given to banks, insurers and others in "persistent and repeated fraud."
Trump, who did not attend Thursday's proceedings, has accused James, a Democrat, of leading a "witch hunt" against him to damage his 2024 presidential campaign.
The Associated Press contributed to this update.
Judge presiding over Trump's Manhattan civil trial exclusively donated to Democrats

New York City Judge Arthur Engoron, who is presiding over former President Donald Trump's civil fraud trial, has exclusively donated to Democrats, according to a report.
Engoron wields unique authority over Trump's civil fraud case. It is a jury-free bench trial, with Engoron overseeing it and ultimately determining its outcome and penalties. New York Attorney General Letitia James wants a $250 million penalty imposed on Trump's businesses after accusing him of fraudulent practices.
Engoron, meanwhile, has shown support for Democrats with his checkbook in the past.
Engoron has given more than $5,000 to Democrats over the past 25 years, the Daily Wire first reported. The money has primarily gone to local committees; his most recent donation from 2018 went to Manhattan Democrats.
The money has also gone to Democrat candidates such as former New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, former Gov. David Paterson and other state lawmakers, the publication reported.
Letitia James' 'trophy pledge' against Trump an 'embarrassment' to the NYS bar: Legal expert
New York State Attorney General Letitia James' campaign pledge to sue former President Donald Trump and reportedly be a "real pain in the a--" to him should be considered an embarrassment, said George Washington University Law Professor Jonathan Turley.
Turley told "Hannity" on Wednesday that he previously criticized James while she was running for office in 2018 after she made such boasts and pledges about litigiously pursuing Trump.
Turley said he previously wrote about his reservations that there were "serious ethical problems with a prosecutor really trying to secure office on the pledge to nail one person."
He called James' promises a "trophy pledge" to "bag" her quarry.
Turley noted James never previously described exactly which criminal or civil offenses Trump would be charged with. In a montage of clips played by host Sean Hannity, James previously referenced threats to "fundamental rights," Trump's "abuses" and an interest in finding whether the then-president "laundered money."
"[N]ot mentioning what he might be charged with, [James said] I'm just going to charge him with something," Turley added.
"That should be an embarrassment to the entire New York bar," he said. "I think that [Alvin] Bragg should be an embarrassment. His case is, in my view, just ridiculous. It barely holds together."
Former Manhattan assistant DA says Letitia James made 'tactical error' in blasting Trump over trial
MSNBC legal analyst and former Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Rebecca Roiphe slammed New York Attorney General Letitia James’ recent public condemnation of former President Trump outside of a New York City courtroom.
During a Thursday segment of "MSNBC Reports," Roiphe told host Ana Cabrera that James standing in front of cameras at a New York City courthouse and responding to Trump’s attacks against her and other prosecutors on Wednesday was a "tactical error."
"She should have remained silent and allowed him to open himself up to these sorts of arguments by others," Roiphe said in response to James’ claim that Trump was using the court case for a "political stunt."
James made waves Wednesday when she spoke to the press outside a New York City courtroom following day three of the civil fraud trial against the former president. She blasted him, saying, "Trump's comments were offensive. They were baseless. They were void of any facts and/or any evidence."
"What they were, were comments that unfortunately fomented violence, comments that I would describe as race-baiting, and comments unfortunately, that appeals to the bottom of our humanity," she claimed.
James added that the court is simply investigating Trump for "fraud" and claimed she "will not sit idly by and allow anybody to subvert the law."
Court adjourns after 4th day of Trump civil fraud trial
Court is now adjourned after the fourth day of former President Donald Trump's civil fraud trial in New York City.
Trump, who, along with his co-defendants, is accused of overvaluing his assets, is expected to move for a stay of the trial pending appeal of Judge Arthur Ergoron's decision last week that he committed fraud while building his real estate empire.
His legal team will likely submit the filing Friday morning.
The day closes after Trump also filed motions to dismiss two of his other pending cases: The election interference case in Washington, D.C., and the hush money case involving Stormy Daniels also in New York.
