Would team of big guys beat little guys in NBA?

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

Could you settle a debate between a couple of knuckleheads? Hypothetically, let's say 10 NBA players get together for an unofficial "game" (NBA court, NBA rules and 3 NBA refs). But one team consists of only centers/power forwards and the other team consists of only point guards. For instance: Tim Duncan, Dwight Howard, Amar'e Stoudemire, Kevin Garnett and Andrew Bynum vs. Steve Nash, Deron Williams, Chris Paul, Tony Parker and Chauncey Billups. I believe the point guards would run circles around the big guys, especially in a 48-minute game. My friend thinks the guards wouldn't make every jump shot they took, but the bigs would make every dunk.

We both realize it's a ridiculous hypothesis, but in your opinion, who would win? -- Gary

Since I happen to be 6-9, I'd vote for the big men.

For sure, the smalls are quicker and could run the bigs ragged unless certain adjustments were made. For example, the big guys would play a zone defense to keep the smalls away from the basket, slow the game down, and force them to shoot jumpers. The bigs would grab virtually every rebound and, instead of advancing the ball into the attack zone by dribbling, they would simply make high passes from station to station until one of them was in position to dunk. In fact, any dribble would probably be swiped by the smalls.

Once the bigs passed the ball to someone in dunking position, two of their quickest players (Stoudemire and Bynum?) would immediately run downcourt to protect against the inevitable fast break.

The smalls' offensive strategy would be to launch 3-pointers at every opportunity in hopes that any misses will result in long rebounds that they could snatch. On defense, they'd have to swarm the ball, play the passing lanes and hope for the best.

The bigs by at least 20 points.

Why isn't Lamar Odom ever considered for Sixth Man of the Year? He just about averages a double-double, plus 4 assists, 1 steal and 1 block. -- T from Tucson

Just look at the last few winners of this award: Jason Terry, Manu Ginobili, Leandro Barbosa, Mike Miller (with Memphis), Ben Gordon and Antawn Jamison (with Dallas). With the exception of Barbosa, whenever these guys entered a game their respective teams ran plays to get them shots. Isos, weak-side screens, high screen/rolls, handoffs, whatever. In other words, they immediately became the focus of the offense.

Barbosa is a special case in that Mike D'Antoni's Suns always looked to run and gun -- and since "The Blur" was usually the fastest player on the court, he'd wind up taking lots of shots.

Odom, however, is never the Lakers' No. 1 option on offense. Since he'll usually be on the court with Kobe and/or Pau Gasol, at best he's the secondary scorer, but most often in any given game only has a couple of plays designed for him -- so his scoring opportunities are normally limited.

It's all about numbers, specifically points scored. The several other ways in which a sixth man can dramatically impact a game are either ignored or not comprehended by the writers and broadcasters who do the voting.

And that's why this award, like every other postseason award, is bogus.

I've noticed that NBA players rarely use the backboard on their jump shots and wonder why that is. - John, Oklahoma City

Shooting banked jumpers requires a more forceful release that is the antithesis of "normal" shots. Also, if the rim never moves, a bank-shooter always needs to target a different spot on the backboard depending upon where he is when he shoots. A flexible knowledge of angles and vectors is therefore essential.

Most rim-oriented jump-shooters, however, seek to utilize the same essential mechanics on every shot.

There are several advantages to bank-shooting: A soft touch is not necessary for success, which means that even subpar shooters can be successful. The slightly altered point of release can more easily avoid the outstretched shot-challenging hand of the defender. And Sam Jones deposited 10 championship rings in his own personal bank account with it.

Could you identify and comment on top college stars who never had meaningful careers in the NBA? Who were the most notable, and why did they fail? -- Steve Suarez, Toronto

OK, let's look at some 1-7 lottery picks who couldn't make the grade over the past 10 years.

In 2000: Darius Miles (drafted by LAC) was too soft and too immature. Marcus Fizer (Chicago) was selfish, an erratic shooter, a poor rebounder/defender, and had very limited lateral movement.

In 2001: Kwame Brown (Washington) has bad hands. Tyson Chandler (LAC) can't score, lacks strength, and is injury prone. Eddy Curry (Chicago) can't defend, rebound, pass, move laterally or stay healthy.

In 2002: Nikoloz Tskitishvili (Denver) was physically too weak and couldn't move his feet quickly enough to play acceptable defense. Dajuan Wagner (Cleveland) couldn't defend or pass, took too many bad shots, and had health issues.

In 2003: Darko Milicic (Detroit) gained too much weight, lost his quickness and lacks a sufficient competitive drive.

In 2004: Josh Childress (Atlanta) couldn't shoot and had too much hair.

In 2005: Marvin Williams (Atlanta) is a streaky shooter who still relies too much on his athleticism; and Martell Webster (Portland) is an indifferent shooter and inept passer who has been plagued with injuries, but neither of these guys should be deemed abject failures. For that we have to descend to Ike Diogu (Golden State, 9th pick overall), who at 6-8, 250 is only effective with the ball in the low-post and can do little else.

In 2006: Adam Morrison (Charlotte) is slow, soft, defenseless and has a bum leg. Shelden Williams (Atlanta) can't pass, lacks a jumper and has no discernible offensive moves. Tyrus Thomas (Portland) has no idea.

In 2007: Greg Oden (Portland) is slow, clumsy and perpetually injured. Yi Jianlian (Milwaukee) is weak, plays poor defense and always comes back to his right hand. Corey Brewer (Minnesota) can't finish and can't shoot.

In 2008: The jury is still out on Russell Westbrook (Seattle), who is still learning how to run an offense; Kevin Love (Minnesota), who can't finish, handle or defend; and Danilo Gallinari (NY), who needs to improve his handle and his defense.

In 2009: Neither Ricky Rubio (Minnesota) nor Blake Griffin (LAC) have yet to play in the NBA -- the former because of his understandable trepidations that he lacks the strength and shooting ability, the latter because of injury. Hasheem Thabeet (Memphis) is awkward, has no offensive game, can do nothing except block an occasional shot and is a long-term project with an extremely doubtful future.

Do Don Nelson and Mike D'Antoni really believe that their respective systems can win championships? Or are they really just nuts? -- Marc, Ft. Lauderdale, FL

Nellie used to be a totally laissez-faire coach who basically gave his players free license to shoot at will. He's become increasingly grouchy, stubborn and manipulative as he ages. However, it's doubtful that he truly believes his shoot-first-and-never-ask-questions philosophy can win a ring. In fact, his best teams were in Milwaukee where the late John Killilea was an excellent defensive coach. It's quite evident that Nellie is just interested in cashing humongous checks and hoarding his power for as long as he can.

D'Antoni, on the other hand, is seriously delusional. He only understands that whichever team scores the most points always wins and his subsequent philosophy is that whichever teams takes the most shots will score the most points.

D'Antoni also believes that obtaining excellent offensive players is fundamental because defense can be taught and because the current rules favor offense. But guys who are paid to score are usually reluctant to jeopardize their minutes and their offensive numbers by playing aggressive defense -- and therefore picking up too many fouls. Besides, playing offense is more fun, is easier and is much more lucrative then playing defense.

D'Antoni simply has a backward view of the game, which is why his Phoenix teams always disappointed in the playoffs, where the intensive scouting and focused practice sessions always lead to a slow, grind-it-out pace.