Dr. Siegel: Doctors were 'cut out of the equation' on vaccine mandate decisions
Fox News contributor Dr. Marc Siegel discusses the impact of COVID vaccine mandates after Republicans claimed they violated individual freedoms and the White House's handling of the Biden family dog's attacks.
Getting the COVID and flu vaccines simultaneously could be safe and even beneficial, according to study findings presented at the Vaccines Summit Boston this week.
In a study, researchers found that people who got both shots at the same time showed higher levels of antibodies against COVID than those who got the two vaccines on different occasions.
Among 42 health care workers in Massachusetts, 12 of them received a bivalent COVID booster and a seasonal influenza shot on the same day last fall.
Another group of 30 got the two shots on two separate days within that same month.
Three to four weeks later, those who had gotten both vaccinations simultaneously were found to have higher levels of COVID-fighting antibodies than those who received the shots separately.
Researchers found that people who got both the COVID and flu shots at the same time showed higher levels of antibodies against COVID than those who got the two vaccines on different occasions. (iStock)
That higher level of protection was detected for as long as six months, the researchers found.
"We showed that the COVID antibody responses were higher and more durable if the COVID and flu vaccines were given on the same day," said Susanna Barouch, the study’s lead author and an intern at the Ragon Institute's Systems Serology Lab in Cambridge, Massachusetts, at the conference.
COVID VACCINE POLL FINDS MORE THAN HALF OF ADULTS ARE LIKELY TO SAY 'NO THANKS' TO THE VAX
The study findings have been published to the preprint server BioRxiv, but they're currently in the peer review process and have not yet been published in a scientific journal.
The new study 'sfindings have been published to the preprint server BioRxiv, but they're currently in the peer review process and have not yet been published in a scientific journal. (iStock)
"We thought that these findings were very important for immediate public health decision-making," said Ryan McNamara, the lab's director and senior author on the study, in explaining the early release of the data.
"I would have to see more data before I would say that combining them is a better strategy."
As far as why the human body produces a higher immunity response after a double vaccination, McNamara hypothesized that the simultaneous doses could stimulate the immune system more than a single shot.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) states on its website that "getting a flu vaccine and COVID-19 vaccine at the same visit is recommended if you are eligible and the timing for each vaccine is right."
A general view of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) headquarters in Atlanta, Georgia. The CDC states on its website that "getting a flu vaccine and COVID-19 vaccine at the same visit is recommended if you are eligible and the timing for each vaccine is right." (REUTERS/Tami Chappell/File Photo)
Some studies have shown, however, that getting both vaccines together could increase the intensity of side effects.
In a 2022 study published in JAMA Network Open, participants who got both shots at the same time experienced up to 11% more side effects, including headache, muscle pain and fatigue.
COLD, FLU, COVID-19 AND RSV: HOW TO IDENTIFY THE DIFFERING SYMPTOMS AND STAY SAFE
Other research has suggested that receiving dual shots could slightly increase the risk of stroke among the elderly.
Dr. Marc Siegel, clinical professor of medicine at NYU Langone Medical Center and a Fox News medical contributor, commented to Fox News Digital that the size of the study was very small, consisting of only 42 health workers.
Fox News medical contributor Dr. Marc Siegel said the new study's results do not warrant "changing clinical practice." (Fox News)
"I wouldn't change clinical practice as a result," said Siegel, who was not involved in the research.
"It makes some sense that priming the immune system with exposure to two antigens (flu and SARS COV-2) at the same time could cause a more robust overall immune response," the doctor went on.
"But the downside is that if you experience side effects, you won't know which vaccine caused them, since the most common side effects are somewhat similar — such as muscle aches, headaches and sore arm."
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER
Dr. Shana Johnson, a physical medicine and rehabilitation physician in Scottsdale, Arizona, was not involved in the study but reviewed the findings.
"These are interesting preliminary findings, but they need to be replicated in a larger, higher-quality study to see if the results hold true," she told Fox News Digital.
"For the elderly, I would be more hesitant to take the two vaccines together given the October 2023 report of a safety signal finding an elevated stroke risk in those 85 years and older," one doctor noted. (iStock)
"Also, we don’t want to make health care recommendations based solely on lab data."
The downside of taking the two vaccines together, according to Johnson, is the increased risk of side effects.
"For the elderly, I would be more hesitant to take the two vaccines together given the October 2023 report of a safety signal finding an elevated stroke risk in those 85 years and older," she added.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Siegel said that in his own practice, he tends to space out vaccinations unless the patient wants the shots to be given at the same time.
Added the doctor, "I would have to see more data before I would say that combining them is a better strategy."
Stay up-to-date on the biggest health and wellness news with our weekly recap.