Penn State to issue 'report cards' to frats after student's hazing death

Following the death of a 19-year-old engineering student at a fraternity house in February, Pennsylvania State University plans to publish a “report card” on fraternities and sororities that have been in trouble for hazing pledges, alcohol violations and other infractions.

The school is still working on the details, but the Philadelphia Inquirer reported on Monday that officials at Penn State will revive the idea of report cards that it instituted as part of a task force on Greek life back in 2015. The task force was created after school officials suspended the Kappa Delta Rho fraternity for three years amid accusations of hazing, underage drinking and sexual harassment.

“The objective was to provide a ‘buyer’s guide’ to help students avoid groups that had poor records and be attracted to groups with good records,” Penn State President Eric Barron said in a statement last month. “The thinking was, that perhaps a ‘buyer’s guide’ would affect the economic status of the house. At the same time it could reveal any negative trend in behavior over time, allowing us to intervene earlier by putting a house on notice.”

More on this...

The plan has not been finalized, but school officials announced Monday that administrators and the board of trustees will hold a meeting in early June to consider a number of actions on top of measures Penn State has already implemented following the death of Tim Piazza at the Beta Theta Pi frat house. These measures include deferring pledging to both fraternities and sororities from the fall to spring semester during the next academic year, banning beer kegs from parties and putting a heavier emphasis on a no-tolerance policy for hazing.

A grand jury report said security camera footage captured events inside the house that night, including pledges being ordered to guzzle alcohol after the ceremony. Piazza appeared to become inebriated and fell face-first down a flight of basement steps.

Fraternity brothers made half-hearted and even counterproductive efforts to help him, and when one member strongly advocated for summoning help he was shoved into a wall and told to leave, the report said.

Piazza apparently fell down the steps again early the next morning but was not discovered until about 10 a.m. Someone called 911 some 40 minutes later. Piazza later died as a result of severe head injuries.

Eight of Piazza’s fraternity brothers face charges of aggravated assault, a felony that carries a sentence of 10 to 20 years in prison upon conviction. Penn State has also permanently banned the Beta Theta Pi fraternity.

Penn State campus photo

A Penn State student walks in the rain past Old Main on the Penn State main campus in State College, Pa., Wednesday, Oct. 28, 2015. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

A spokesperson for Penn State told Fox News that while it’s premature to discuss specific recommendations or plans prior to the board meeting, the university is considering a number of options that will depart drastically from measures commonly employed at institutions nationwide.

“The safety of our students and campus community is of paramount importance, and we are resolved to take decisive action,” Barron said in a statement. “There are no easy solutions, but we will leave no stone unturned as we search for the most effective ways to achieve change.”

Despite being far from universal, the idea of a “report card” for fraternities and sororities is not unique to Penn State. Leigh University publishes a report of all the infractions incurred by Greek-letter organizations, while schools ranging from Rutgers University in New Jersey to Texas A&M have lists on their websites noting the conduct status and sanctions currently placed on any fraternity and sorority.

While Penn State’s plan drew praise from national Greek-letter organizations, there is concern that fraternities and sororities may be unfairly targeted by school officials.

“The [North-American Interfraternity Conference] supports transparent reporting of organizational conduct violations and adjudication. Sunlight is the best disinfectant,” Heather Kirk, the chief communication officer at the NIC, said in a statement to Fox News. “For university reporting to be effective, it must include ALL student organizations and athletic teams. Issues like hazing and alcohol misuse are problems across a range of student activities on campus, from fraternities to the marching band.”