The Lake Geneva Police Department said in a news release posted to Facebook that 37-year-old Keith Alan Comfort walked into the police department at 1:35 p.m. on Sunday, and "implicated himself" in the death of Megan Nicole Shultz.
Shultz was 24 years old when she was reported missing in Boone County, Mo., to the Columbia Police Department on Aug. 5, 2006.
"The circumstances where you have someone come into a police station and accept responsibility 13 years later, yes, that is a long time in a different state," Boone County prosecutor Dan Knight told FOX6. "That is unusual."
Sunday was the 13th anniversary of Shultz’s disappearance when she was last seen, on Aug. 4, 2006, leaving the couple’s Columbia apartment.
At the time of her disappearance, Comfort told police that Shultz left on foot, officials said in a news release. Less than three weeks after she went missing, Comfort filed for divorce.
In court documents obtained by FOX6, Comfort told authorities in Wisconsin that Shultz was "frantic," "yelling" and "swinging her arms at him" after the couple got into a fight about an alleged drug deal. Comfort told police in a probable cause statement he grabbed Shultz and "took her to the ground, and strangled her" before placing her body in a garbage bag that he tossed in a dumpster.
He later told officers that he only filed a missing person’s report the next day after his mother-in-law, Debra Shultz, asked him about her daughter's whereabouts.
“Keith had it down to an art of lying and smiling," she told WKOW on Monday.
Debra Shultz said in the years after her daughter went missing, she remained suspicious about Comfort.
“Keith could smile and put on the charm, but he was a very troubled young man,” she told the television station.
After filing for divorce, Comfort eventually remarried and moved to Wisconsin before divorcing again a year ago, according to FOX6. He was living in a long-stay motel in Lake Geneva before walking into the police station on Sunday.
After Comfort made his confession, detectives from the Columbia Police Department traveled to Wisconsin. He was being held in the Walworth County Jail, pending extradition to Missouri on the murder charge with a cash bond set at $1 million, according to police.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.