Killer dubbed 'Hannibal Lecter' pleads guilty, gets 25 years

After Casey Pigge was taken into custody last year for using a brick to kill his cellmate by repeatedly smashing his head, he made one thing clear to investigators.

"Pigge denied any desire to be a serial killer, but could not promise that he wouldn't kill again," a prison social worker said after interviewing him.

Less than a year later, Pigge used a chain meant to restrain him around the stomach to strangle a fellow inmate in a prison transport van as it traveled through Pickaway County in central Ohio. On Wednesday, Pigge pleaded guilty to killing that prisoner, David Johnson, and was immediately sentenced to 25 years in prison.

"I guess you never seen that on a bus before," Pigge boasted to the surviving inmates after Johnson's killing, according to highway patrol records. Johnson was serving an eight-year sentence for sexual battery.

Pigge apparently did not want to be around a sex offender, Pickaway County Prosecutor Judy Wolford said Wednesday.

"Whether the gentleman that was killed was incarcerated or not, he was still a human being, and we still have a victim in this particular case," she said. "I'm pleased that justice has been served for him."

Pigge's attorney, Steve Larson, said he didn't discuss motives with his client.

"My position is, can they prove this case beyond a reasonable doubt. Obviously they could, he made statements against himself," Larson said.

Larson said Pigge was pleasant around him, although security was always tight. The inmate likes to read westerns, he said.

Any time in prison for Johnson's death is moot: Pigge already is serving a life sentence for killing his cellmate Luther Wade and 30 years to life for fatally slitting the throat of his girlfriend's mother in 2008. He gave himself the nickname "box cutter" after the weapon he used to kill her.

The state prisons system has not said why Pigge, with his record, was placed in a van with the ability to carry out the killing of Johnson. The state updated its prison transportation policies afterward but won't release details.

"They definitely was not doing their job and monitoring us even with a known Hannibal Lecter with us," according to a letter from an inmate on the bus that day that was sent afterward to prisons director Gary Mohr, as reported by the Dayton Daily News.

Officers with the prisons' department SWAT unit transported Pigge Wednesday from the maximum Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in Lucasville. Three SWAT members were positioned in the courtroom and a fourth was just outside in the hall. Pigge wore hand and ankle chains in the courtroom during the hearing, which lasted only a few minutes.

Pigge, 29, feared Wade was a member of the Aryan Brotherhood who planned to kill him, records show. He'd been Wade's cellmate at Lebanon Correctional Facility for one day when he talked him into being blindfolded as part of a card trick, then took a brick and brought it down again and again on Wade's head.

Even before Wade's killing, Pigge's prison misconduct record ran nearly 30 pages. Over the years, he repeatedly refused to enter his cell, was found with homemade alcohol, collected contraband like razor blades, electric cords and a TV converter box and fought other inmates.

Records show Pigge was born to a 14-year-old girl who used drugs and alcohol while pregnant with him. Child protection authorities first intervened when he was just 7 days old, according to a 2009 evaluation after Pigge killed his girlfriend's mother.

Pigge was burned with cigarettes as a toddler, forced as a child to urinate in a heating grate when his mother and stepfather locked him in a room, was possibly sexually abused, and was repeatedly abandoned, according to the report by psychologist Dennis Eshbaugh.

"I feel nobody ever liked me," Pigge told the psychologist.

Pigge was placed in dozens of foster homes and hospitals over the years, and diagnosed with a mild mental disability. "In effect, the defendant is functionally a child in an adult body," Eshbaugh said.


Andrew Welsh-Huggins can be reached on Twitter at