Benjamin Dillon, 37, entered the home in Lebanon, a city roughly 30 miles northwest of Indianapolis, on June 3 and allegedly said the girl inside was his daughter.
"I was sound asleep in my bedroom and this guy came kicking in and said, 'You have my daughter,'” Patty Roth, the girl's grandmother, told WXIN. “I was nervous, very nervous. I was shaking so bad."
Roth and the child were sleeping in a back bedroom when the incident unfolded. She said police were called as her husband tried to get Dillon out of the apartment.
Dillon allegedly became aggressive and threatened police officers when they arrived. Responding cops reportedly tased Dillon "multiple times."
"I don't understand why he picked our apartment. I'll never figure that one out," Roth said.
The Lebanon Police Department did not immediately return Fox News' request for comment. According to online records from the Boone County Sheriff's Office, Dillion faces a slew of charges including counts of burglary, intimidation and resisting law enforcement.