This is a rush transcript from "The Story," May 8, 2018. This copy may not be in its final form and may be updated.
MARTHA MACCALLUM, FOX NEWS CHANNEL HOST: Hi there, Bret, what a gorgeous shot in front of the White House, and a lot of excitement tonight as the polls have now closed in Indiana. So, any minute now, we're going to get to our first look at where American voters stand out there on the GOP, on Democrats, on the anti-establishment fervor that we have watched by President Trump.
Good evening everybody, I Martha MacCallum and this is 'The Story' tonight. The first big primary day of 2018. You've got, ten states in the United States of America where Democratic senators are up for reelection in states that were handily won by President Trump. And you've got three of those that have primaries this evening. As we await the first numbers out of Indiana, where Republicans are battling for the chance to challenge one of the most vulnerable Senate Democrats in the whole country, if not the most in November.
It is too early to project a winner in tonight's race in Indiana. There is a live look at Mike Braun's headquarters. He's sort of the outsider businessman candidate. In this race, he's poured millions of his own money into the campaign. He is enjoying an early lead; it is too soon to say who's going to win here. The winner of this race will face off against Democratic Senator Joe Donnelly in November.
Minutes from now, also polls will close in West Virginia and this one has been a barn burner and a lot of fun to watch. Republicans hope that the winner of this wild GOP primary could perhaps defeat Joe Manchin, the Democrat in West Virginia. The wild card in that race, former coal baron and ex-con whose probation ends this evening, a minute after midnight, Don Blankenship. What did he do today when others were campaigning? He went shopping for a new suit.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
UNIDENTIFIED MALE: What is the time there?
DON BLANKENSHIP, WEST VIRGINIA REPUBLICAN SENATE CANDIDATE: I think the people have made up their minds so we can get a few things done and get ready for the general.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MACCALLUM: Very confident Don Blankenship in the suit store there. We're watching the polls close in just minutes from now, also is in key places in Ohio and North Carolina. So, we've got great folks here tonight with lots of expertise on what to watch. David Bossie, former Trump Deputy Campaign Manager, Fox News Contributor, and he's also the President of Citizens United, which is backing Republican A.G. Patrick Morrisey in the West Virginia race, and Republican Jim Renacci in the Ohio Senate Race; Chris Stirewalt is with me as well, native West Virginian and Fox News politics editor; Mo Elleithee, Executive Director of Georgetown University Institute for Politics, he's also a Fox News Contributor; and Capri Cafaro, former Ohio State Senate Minority Leader. Welcome to all of you. The excitement is building tonight as we watch this and we're going to get some indications and some people are going to feel really happy at the end of tonight, and some are going to feel like their dreams have been sunk. Chris Stirewalt, let me start with you as you look across the map here, what stands out to you? What you watching?
CHRIS STIREWALT, FOX NEWS POLITICS EDITOR: The first thing is I want to give a shout out to my former tailor, Tony Paranzino.
MACCALLUM: You know Tony?
STIREWALT: That's my former tailor.
MACCALLUM: Of course, it is.
STIREWALT: Of course, it's a small state. But Don Blankenship with the plug, you got to love it. Look, I just came up from the decision desk and I can tell you that anybody who tells you that they know how this West Virginia race is going to turn out doesn't know what they are talking about because we have never seen a contest like this in West Virginia, ever, ever. There's going to be bigger turnout, there's more interest. They've never had a Fox News debate there. They've never had a Republican primary with $10 million in it. Nobody knows what it's going to be and that's why we play the game, it's awesome.
MACCALLUM: David Bossie, your guy there, Patrick Morrisey, and as Chris said, we really don't know how this is going to turn out. But this race has gotten a whole lot of attention and Don Blankenship, who was trailing - - you know, the polls are so tricky in these kind of races, it's hard to know how reflective they really were. But he was trailing and then it looked like he picked up a bit of momentum, your thoughts?
DAVID BOSSIE, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR AND FORMER TRUMP CAMPAIGN MANAGER: Well, I think that the West Virginia race is an incredibly interesting one for the country as a whole, but I'm hopeful that Patrick Morrisey, the two- time attorney general of West Virginia wins. I think he will be the best candidate in a general election. However, if Morrisey loses to Jenkins, I think we have a terrific chance if either of those of the nominees to beat the incumbent Democrat senator. The president won that state overwhelmingly by about 34 points. It is a place that Donald Trump can really help us defeat an incumbent U.S. senator that we need to beat. So, it is going to be a long road if Blankenship unfortunately wins that race.
MACCALLUM: All right. We'll have a lot to talk about in either case there when we get some more information on that. Capri, let me go to you. Let's talk Ohio, what are you watching there?
CAPRI CAFARO, FORMER SENATOR OF OHIO: Absolutely. A number of things. First and foremost, the Democratic primary for governor, we have a matchup of four individuals; the two leading folks in this race, Rich Cordray, the former Attorney General of Ohio, former Treasurer, and most notably the former Head of the Consumer Protection Finance Bureau for the last eight years, versus Dennis Kucinich. Dennis, the menace, who was a member of congress for a number of years and famously bankrupt the city of Cleveland --even though the Cleveland plain dealer actually endorsed Dennis Kucinich for this race. We have two other individuals -- I actually voted for Joe Schiavoni, my former colleague in the Ohio Senate, who's also a former Senate Minority Leader, because he's a guy whose common sense and can actually, can I think bring the Trump voters back into the fold since he's from the Mahoning Valley like I am. But it will be interesting to see because this is really a matchup between sort of the progressive wing, and Dennis Kucinich and the establishment wing, and Rich Cordray. Rich Cordray that he finally has the endorsement of the AFL, CIA. So, we will see how this plays out.
MACCALLUM: The establishment wing with Rich Cordray?
CAFARO: I mean, look, compared to Dennis Kucinich, the establishment wing is OK.
MACCALLUM: Well, that just pretty much says it all, doesn't it?
CAFARO: And guns will be playing a big role in this race. The two other things to watch in Ohio are two Congressional races: one, which is the vacant seat being left by Jim Renacci who's running for United States Senate, endorsed by Donald Trump and I think the favorite, certainly, in the senate primary here to challenge Sherrod Brown. In that open seat, it's predominantly the 16th congressional district in northeastern Ohio. These are Republican leaning seats. On the Republican side, you have two main contenders in Gonzalez and Hagan. Hagan is a young woman, current state representative; Gonzalez is a former football star raising a lot of money. So, I think that's going to be a close race. Then finally, the race down for the special election in the house race vacated by Pat Tiberi, that's, you know, basically, the Tea Party, Freedom Caucus versus the establishment down there. So, you know, anybody's guess. That's a free- for-all.
MACCALLUM: That was impressive.
BOSSIE: She's exactly right.
MACCALLUM: Exactly! Get that woman a whiteboard. Thank you, Capri. Mo, your thoughts on the establishment candidate, Rich Cordray versus Dennis Kucinich in Ohio? An interesting race to be sure to see who's going to take the spot of Governor Kasich, who is term limited and vacating his spot, he has presidential aspirations of his own at this point as he did once in the past as well. What do you think, Mo?
MO ELLEITHEE, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR AND EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY INSTITUTE FOR POLITICS: I think there are people out there that are trying to turn this Ohio Democratic primary into some sort of rehash of establishment versus progressive or center left versus left, and I don't think that's what this is at all, right? I think Cordray seems to be the guy who's walking into this primary with momentum to say he is not a progressive -- the guy headed up the CFPB for five years. He was the guy picking on Wall Street, which is what progressives say they want.
MACCALLUM: He's closely aligned with Elizabeth Warren. Just to give folks at home, you know, a feel for where he's coming from. You know, that's his base.
ELLEITHEE: And Kucinich -- I mean, you know, there was a time when the guy may be represented sort of the left of the party, I don't know that that's this time. I don't know if that's what he has. He kind of represents more like a hand grenade throwing wing of the party. He's being supported by our revolution, which is the Bernie Sanders-backed Super PAC, but those guys aren't really Democrats, right? They're the sort of the hand-grenade wing of the base. And so, you know, this is more kind of like the disruptors versus the progressives and it just kind of just shows how much, you know, sort of the shift in the -- in sort of the power dynamic.
MACCALLUM: I got to leave it there because we're going to have a lot of numbers coming out. We're going to bring you guys back, and we're going to be following this throughout the evening. There's a lot of characters out there, right? I mean, just looking at that whole list, there are some very interesting characters out there in these races tonight. So, we're going to cover it all. Thank you, guys. We'll be back in a little bit.
Coming up the night, new documents raising fresh questions about torture. U.S. enhanced interrogation methods as others prefer to call them, and Gina Haspel, President Trump's pick to lead the CIA, all on the eve of her senate confirmation hearing. Plus, strong words from President Trump today on why he has decided that he's giving it a chance and it is time to pull the United States out of the Iran nuclear agreement. Staff Sergeant Robert Bartlett, a retired U.S. soldier injured by an Iranian bomb in Iraq, shares his deeply personal reaction straight ahead.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
DONALD TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES: If the regime continues its nuclear aspirations, it will have bigger problems than it has ever had before.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MACCALLUM: Breaking tonight, if there was ever any doubt about how President Trump felt about the Iran deal that was laid to rest today. A stunning and really very forceful statement by the president today essentially saying the deal is done. He laid it out in no uncertain terms this way.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
TRUMP: Iran's bloody ambitions have grown only more brazen. The Iran deal is defective at its core. If we do nothing, we know exactly what will happen. In just a short period of time, the world's leading state sponsor of terror will be on the cusp of acquiring the world's most dangerous weapons. I made clear that if the deal could not be fixed, the United States would no longer be a party to the agreement. I am announcing today that the United States will withdraw from the Iran nuclear deal. We will be instituting the highest level of economic sanctions. America will not be held hostage to nuclear blackmail. We will not allow American cities to be threatened with destruction and we will not allow a regime that chance death to America to gain access to the most-deadly weapons on Earth. The United States no longer makes empty threats. When I make promises, I keep them. In fact, at this very moment, Secretary Pompeo is on his way to North Korea in preparation for my upcoming meeting with Kim Jong Un. Finally, I want to deliver a message to the long-suffering people of Iran. The future of Iran belongs to its people. They are the rightful heirs to a rich culture and an ancient land and they deserve a nation that does justice to their dreams, honor to their history and glory to god. There has been enough suffering, death and destruction. Let it end now.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MACCALLUM: Iran immediately threatened to start the wheels turning on their nuclear weapons plan unless the European partners can keep this deal afloat. Also, right after the president's statement, report that Israel carried out strikes near the Syrian capital of Damascus, a reinforcement of the bond between the United States and Israel after the announcement of the exit from this deal. Joining me now, someone who has been waiting for this decision and working towards this decision on the Hill for a very long time, Retired Staff Sergeant Robert Bartlett, who has joined us several times over the last year, an Advisor to United Against Nuclear Iran. He was personally injured by an Iranian roadside bomb while he was serving our country in Iraq. There's a look at the vehicle that he was driving at the time that was back in 2005. Long outspoken as I said against this deal. Sergeant Bartlett, thank you so much for being with us tonight. Your thoughts as you watch the president speak those words today?
ROBERT BARTLETT, RETIRE STAFF SERGEANT: Thank you, Mr. President, I really appreciate it. It's a great anniversary for me. I mean, 13 years ago, last Thursday, we got blown up. I was cut in half from the left corner of my temple down to jaw. My gunner, Todd Bishop, lost his legs. My truck commander, god rest his soul, Sergeant Brooks, William Brooks, was killed instantly, and this new adventure of mine started, you know, to do the right thing, to continue to try to protect the country.
MACCALLUM: I know that you were horrified by the lines of this deal. $180 billion in cash was flown to Iran and, you know, into the pockets essentially of Qasem Soleimani, the head of the Iranian Republican Guard. Talk to me about what you believe he did with that money and why you think this deal was such a mess from the beginning?
BARTLETT: Oh, we know what he did with the money -- he began spreading more terror. That's exactly what he did. It went right to his military. It increased their GDP by five, tenfold that same year. And then, all of a sudden you saw, more things happening in Yemen and other countries out there spreading their terrorism. We know exactly what they did with the money because the people are starving. That's why there was an uprising, because the money wasn't going to them. And try to spend some money to try to fix something, you know, to buy them off, you know, so they wouldn't build a weapon. It doesn't make sense. It's a Chicago politics.
MACCALLUM: So, you know, as you know, President Obama, John Kerry, everybody really reacted very strongly to this. Here's President Obama: "the consistent flouting of agreements that our country is a party to risks eroding America's credibility, and puts us at odds with the world's major powers, the decision to put the JCPOA at risk without any Iranian violation of the deal is a serious mistake.
BARTLETT: Yes. You know what, diplomats got killed under his office and Ambassador Stevens, and so -- these are all policies that his State Department has people stood by, you know, and put this thing together. They just got more people killed and that was going to get -- continue to get more people killed by the spread of terrorism. So, how can giving billions of dollars to a country who hasn't stopped spreading terrorism first and saying, you know, we'll give you billions if you just don't build nuclear weapons, how about no? You're already terrorist, you're already spreading terrorism; we're not giving you any money. We'll just going to put more sanctions on and clean them up just like we did with North Korea. You know, it just didn't make sense to give them billions of dollars in the middle of the night, come on. What are we doing? You know, what are you doing for those people who died for this country like my friends?
MACCALLUM: I know you named your son after your friend William.
BARTLETT: That's right.
MACCALLUM: And he was born a few years back. Sergeant Robert Bartlett, thank you very much. We wanted to hear from you because we knew that you were going to be very moved and very happy about what happened. Because you've been working on it for a long time so we thank you for being here tonight. Good to see you as always, sir. Thank you for your service.
BARTLETT: Thank you, I appreciate it very much. I appreciate it. Thank you.
MACCALLUM: So, President Trump's decision today drawing some criticism as we've said at home and some abroad. European leaders called it regrettable. You know that they have put together a statement to try to hold United States into this agreement, President Obama and John Kerry, his former secretary of state, has been working behind the scenes to try to convince Zarif, the foreign minister of Iran to, you know, find a way to stay in this deal. Joining me now, Democratic Senator Chris Coons of Delaware, he's also a member of the Foreign Relations Committee. Good to see you, Senator Coons, thank you for being with us tonight.
SEN. CHRIS COONS, D—DELAWARE, MEMBER OF THE FOREIGN RELATIONS COMMITTEE: Thanks for a chance to be on again, Martha. And I just -- I want to convey to Sergeant Bartlett, his story was very powerful and a reminder that all of us who see Iran clearly as a terrorist threat in the region, Democrats and Republicans need to continue to work together to make sure that we find a way to successfully constrain Iran's ongoing bad and threatening behavior.
MACCALLUM: So, Sergeant Bartlett, I think, would ask why would we ever sign an agreement that entailed sending $180 billion in cash to Iran that was then used on things like their effort to, you know, to kill people in the civil war in Syria. How was that ever a good idea?
COONS: Well, first because we didn't. $180 billion in cash did not get sent to Iran from the United States. But more important than whether or not the number is right is whether or not the spirit is right. I understand why Sergeant Bartlett would be angry about that agreement, and I understand some of President Trump's criticisms of the Iran agreement. It did not intend to deal with the ballistic missile program. It did not intend to deal with their domestic human rights problems, and it did not deal with their support for terrorist organizations in the region. In fact, the Iran deal specifically allowed us to continue to sanction those activities by Iran. What I wish the president had done instead is to work with our European partners: France, Germany, the U.K., to impose tough sanctions on Iran for the things they are doing in Syria.
MACCALLUM: But senator -- I'm sorry -- don't you think that's what's going to happen now? I mean, the president has a very interesting foreign policy doctrine I think that is emerging. When you look at all of the different areas that he's working in, he basically says let's join all of these ideas together. Let's not do, you know, let's join trade, let's join our trade agreement, let's look at all of these issues across the board and let's hold Iran accountable for its behavior. Let's not strike a deal with Iran that doesn't force any behavior change from this country that is the number one state sponsor of terror. So, it's highly likely that at this point, we're going to start to see a negotiation that gets closer to exactly what you want.
COONS: You know, I hope that is the case. And if it is successful, that would be a good outcome. But Martha, given that we've got right in front of us the challenge of a nuclear capable North Korea, that has developed ballistic missiles and the upcoming negotiation between President Trump and Kim Jong-un, I would have urged -- I did urge him to give the Iran agreement more time and to give our European partners more time because frankly, we now raise questions with them, with the Chinese and the Russians and with the North Koreans about how reliable we could be in any future agreement. And if Iran chooses to walk away from this agreement and resume enrichment, we don't have a clear answer or a strategy from President Trump and the administration over how we're going to deal with a restarted and renewed Iranian program. The only reason that we have the pressure to really get onto the table in the first place was allies like South Korea, India, and others who stopped buying oil from India -- excuse me, from Iran, to reassemble the global powers that will force Iran back to the table will take time.
MACCALLUM: You know, I mean, one of the things that they want now is for all of those deals with Iran between European countries and other countries to start to be unwound as part of this, to make those sanctions very powerful. Condoleezza Rice, you know, was asked about this earlier this week. She said, you know, if we get out of this deal, it's going to be just fine. She said it was rushed into the first place and we gave away a lot of things that we never should have given away. So, we'll see. You know, we'll watch what happens, but there's definitely a lot of people who are unhappy with it as you are tonight. But we'll see. Let's hope for the best. Thank you very much, senator.
COONS: Thank you, Martha.
MACCALLUM: Good to see you tonight. So, as you know, it is election night and we are watching it closely. We've got results coming in from Indiana. Still too early to project the winner given how many boats are in so far, but whoever does win this race, you can see Mike Braun, who was the outsider candidate at 41 percent is enjoying an early lead there. He is the sort of the Trump outsider, we're watching that very closely. Whoever wins there will go up against Joe Donnelly, the current senator. And in less than six minutes, the polls will close in Ohio, in West Virginia, and North Carolina. We're live on the ground in all of those places with the very first results coming up next.
MACCALLUM: So, we are about three minutes away from the polls closing in three battleground states tonight. We've got North Carolina, West Virginia, which we've been watching very closely here, and Ohio, which also has some really interesting races. So, Peter Doocy is live at Don Blankenship's headquarters in West Virginia as the former coal baron and ex-con looks to beat Evan Jenkins and Patrick Morrisey in that GOP Senate Primary, and Ellison Barber is live in Dennis Kucinich's headquarters in Ohio where the former congressman is looking to beat Obama administration official Richard Cordray for the Democratic nomination there. So, let's go first to Peter Doocy in West Virginia. Hi, Peter.
PETER DOOCY, FOX NEWS CHANNEL REPORTER: Martha, Don Blankenship has self- funded his entire three and a half million-dollar campaign with the exception of one donation for $1,000. So, nobody is telling him what to do, and that's why his primary day included a trip to the tailor to get fitted for a new suit and a two-hour nap. His final day radio ad actually repeated establishment Republican attacks against him for being a bigot or mentally ill, but he explains to voters in the ad that even if those things are true, he thinks he'd be a better choice than Congressman Evan Jenkins or Attorney General Patrick Morrisey. But Morrisey and Jenkins have something that Blankenship doesn't, and that is the blessing of President Trump. In a state where Trump beat Clinton by 42 points in 2016. Morrisey's closing argument today was all about electability. He believes that after the Fox News debate last Tuesday, this became a two-man race between himself and Blankenship, and that his resume is the only one conservative enough to flip Democratic Senator Joe Manchin seat. Morrisey watching results tonight in Kernersville, while Congressman Evan Jenkins is down in Barboursville. Remember, he was the front runner in the Fox News poll released two weeks ago tonight. Jenkins told us today there's a little bit of nervousness, but that he's put a lot into an aggressive campaign and he's looking forward to the results here in Charleston. Blankenship, whose probation ends at midnight is set to watch the results with about 100 family and friends, and we're told that soon they're all going to be handed red and white hats with a message to the senate majority leader, they're going to say ditch Mitch. Martha.
MACCALLUM: We've heard a lot of that in that race. Thank you very much, Peter. All right, let's go over to the Democratic senate primary in Ohio where Fox News correspondent Ellison Barber is live at Dennis Kucinich's headquarters tonight in Cleveland. Hi, Ellison.
ELLISON BARBER, FOX NEWS CORRESPONDENT: Hi, Martha. There's been, of course, a lot of concern in places like West Virginia among Republicans concerned that perhaps one candidate might be too far right, and perhaps they won't be very electable come the general election. To some degree, that exact same concern exists here in the Ohio gubernatorial primary, but on the opposite side of the political spectrum. That is the concern in many ways for Democrats here. Richard Cordray is backed by the more establishment side of the Democratic Party. He served as the top consumer watchdog under the Obama administration. Former congressman Dennis Kucinich is backed by the more progressive Bernie Sanders wing of the party. There are other Democrats in this race, but Cordray and Kucinich are very much considered to be the top two candidates at this point.
On the Republican side in both the gubernatorial race as well as the senate primary race, President Trump is a constant theme. Most Republican candidates seem to be trying to prove that they're more like him than their opponents are. Of course, President Trump traveled to Ohio this past weekend and he endorsed Republican senate hopeful Congressman Jim Renacci. That race is all on the Republican side because the incumbent senator, Democrat Sherrod Brown, does not have a primary challenger. The big question is did that visit from President Trump on Saturday help Congressman Renacci, did it help turn out? Did it help convince people to go for him over some of -- over the other Republicans? Of course, it will be a little while before we know that, but the Board of Elections say they expect that about 1.6 million people to show up and vote today. The total number of registered voters here in Ohio, Martha, is about 7.9 million.
MACCALLUM: Seem pretty good turn out so far in some of these races. Ellison, thank you very much. Also, Fox News canal project that -- this is not a big surprise, Senator Joe Manchin will easily defeat the challenger on his primary side, Paula Jean Swearengin, to win the Democratic primary. So, there's one that we can tell you about. And we don't know yet who going to win back on the Republican side and who will go up against Joe Manchin in the fall. Don Blankenship, Evan Jenkins who is the current congressman, and the Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, are all vying for that position. And as soon as we get some numbers rolling in West Virginia, we're all very interested to see how that's going to work out. So, we'll get those up on the board as soon as we have them.
In the meantime, this breaking story. You may remember New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman going after Harvey Weinstein, one of the many people that he has gone after as A.G. in New York, but he really was a champion, we thought, for the Me Too movement.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
ERIC SCHNEIDERMAN, FORMER NEW YORK ATTORNEY GENERAL: Women were coerced into facilitating Harvey Weinstein's misconduct, sometimes they were targets themselves. If they refused, they were threatened.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MACCALLUM: So, he has gone head-to-head with powerful politicians including, at times, President Trump himself, who tweeted back in 2013, quote, Weiner is gone, Spitzer is gone, next will be lightweight A.G. Eric Schneiderman. Is he a crook? Wait and see. Worse the Weiner and Spitzer. That was March of 2013. But now, apparently, what goes around comes around. Four women have spoken out saying, yes, he did it to me too. In this bombshell report, the New Yorker writes about one accuser saying, quote, it's torturous for me to do this, as she puts it, but what do you do if your abuser is the top law enforcement official in the state, which on many occasions he was happy to remind these women of. Hours after the New Yorker was published, Eric Schneiderman had already resigned. Here to react, Kimberly Guilfoyle, cohost of The Five, and former attorney and prosecutor. Kimberly, good to see you. This is quite a story. You know, I mean, obviously, it's a New York-based story, but this is a person who went after President Trump, went after Chris Christie, and champion of women, these stories are unbelievable.
KIMBERLY GUILFOYLE, THE FIVE CO-HOST: It certainly has national implications. And, like you said, working as a former prosecutor in the area of domestic violence and sexual assault, women and children that had been physically and sexually abused, these are some of the most difficult cases to bring forward, and working with them in terms of trying to get them to come forward to tell their story when they've been abused by someone, especially someone like you said, top law enforcement person, someone that used threats and intimidation to keep the women silent. You saw four brave women came forward as it relates to the New Yorker piece. And as some of these executives and produces here at Fox News know I've been working on an investigation into this case as well. I've been working with one of the victims of Eric Schneiderman and her horrific ordeal that she endured at his hands. She too was also very afraid to come forward and to tell her story, which is unbelievably harrowing and compelling, and she is not one of the four that are mentioned in this New Yorker piece.
MACCALLUM: Wow. I mean, we've already know there's more.
GUILFOYLE: That's correct. There's more to come.
MACCALLUM: And did you -- were you speaking with her before this story came out last night. So, you've been talking with her for a while.
MACCALLUM: And she's terrified to come forward?
GUILFOYLE: The past couple of months. But she has now, you know, really made the decision to be able to come forward. She's afraid -- you know, she's a single, you know, mom like myself, and it's very difficult when you think about that type of thing and you think about going up against someone very powerful, but you see these four brave women were able to do it. And I think, you know, it's so compelling and really gives strength to others that have suffered at the hands, you know, physical abuse.
MACCALLUM: This case -- I mean, you look -- these cases are all across the spectrum in terms of what people are accused of. This is beating. I mean, he was -- according to these woman's reports, hitting them so hard in the head, by the eyes, that they had to go to physicians. She was bleeding in her ear. She couldn't hear for weeks.
GUILFOYLE: Yeah. One of the women detailed that, that she was hit and struck so hard on the side of the head and the ear that she had the ringing in the ear, that she had blood in her ear. She saw, in particular that, woman saw Dr. Gwen Corbin, who is an ENT who examined her. So there's medical records, their medical records as well in the case I have been investigating and working with the victim, so something.
MACCALLUM: What's going to happen legally? What's he up against?
GUILFOYLE: Over a long period of time. He's looking at potential misdemeanor felony charges depending on the nature of the abuse and a number of women coming forward. The Manhattan district attorney's office has opened a case. Long Island has also opened an investigation to see the nature of the abuse and what kind of charges could be filed. It's very serious. It's criminal conduct, certainly, assault of conduct, the battery over repeated period of time. He used the phrased role-playing.
GUILFOYLE: It is not role-playing when you physically beat and abuse.
MACCALLUM: One quote from the New Yorker piece by Ronan Farrow, he said these women one after another were adamant. This is not Fifty Shades of Grey.
MACCALLUM: This was not an area of gray at all in their minds. This was assault over and over again.
GUILFOYLE: Yes, it was dark, it was ominous. It was something threatening and name calling abuse, it's very difficult when you even think about and you hear some of these details and the details that I have heard. And people will have no misconception that this wasn't consensual, and that this was criminal in conduct.
MACCALLUM: Kimberly, thank you. And we look forward to hearing more about your investigation as you move forward, thank you so much.
GUILFOYLE: Thank you so much.
MACCALLUM: Great to have you here tonight. So, stick around, we are getting some more numbers in, in the election results from Ohio and West Virginia and Indiana. This is politics across the nation tonight, folks. You see these conference rooms and hotel spaces where people are waiting to flood in, in support of their candidate when we get some winners tonight, and there will be some who have to give concession speeches as well this evening. All of that just hours before something else that's very important, Gina Haspel will be on the hill tomorrow for her confirmation hearing. New documents have surfaced and they are raising questions about her role in the CIA enhanced interrogation technique program. Liz Cheney joins us with some thoughts about Gina Haspel's nomination, next.
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
SEN. ROY BLUNT, R—MISSOURI: She is the most qualified person to ever be nominated to run the CIA. She has the best background, the best preparation. I think she's exactly the right person at exactly the right time.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
MACCALLUM: President Trump's pick spec to lead the CIA, Gina Haspel, who he calls tough on terror back on Capitol Hill today. This is what they do. They get to make the rounds, meet with everybody who is going to be at the hearing. We expect that it's going to be kind of tense in their, potentially, tomorrow as some contentious confirmation hearings get underway. Her nomination reignited a fierce debate over controversial Bush era enhanced interrogation tactics that were used after 9/11. And then, further fanning those claims, BuzzFeed, today, releasing hundreds of CIA documents about the program and the black sites. Here now, Representative Liz Cheney of Wyoming, daughter of former vice president Dick Cheney during that era. Liz, good to see you. Thanks for being here.
REP. LIZ CHENEY, R—WYOMING: Hi, Martha, good to be with you.
MACCALLUM: You know, I do -- I want to ask about that, but first I want to ask you about your reaction to the Iran deal because I know that you have some thoughts on that tonight as well, so let's start there.
CHENEY: I think the president did exactly the right thing today. President Trump's decision to withdraw from the deal is courageous. It's perhaps the worst deal the United States has ever entered into, had no anywhere, anytime inspections. No access to military sites. The Iranians got to continue to enrich. It was actually a pathway to a nuclear weapon. It didn't prevent them from obtaining one. And the president was right. What he's done now is send a very clear message. We're not going to be bound by phony deals. We're not going to be in a situation where we're taken advantage of. And frankly, it sends a terrific message also to the North Koreans. It says, look, we are absolutely committed to making sure that the world's worst sponsor of terror does not get access to a nuclear weapons. It was a brave courageous decision and exactly the right thing to do.
MACCALLUM: Interesting. All right. We'll see where that goes. In terms of Gina Haspel, tomorrow we do expect that there's going to be a lot of questions for her about her oversight of a black site in Thailand for one period during a very long career with the CIA. I guess how would you advise her to handle those questions?
CHENEY: Look, I think that we've got an effort underway right now, which is frankly disgraceful. Gina Haspel is probably the most qualified person who's ever been nominated to head the CIA, the first career official in 52 years nominated for that position, somebody who's got support across the board, Republicans, Democrats, career officials at the agency. She's someone who is known as having integrity, she's known as somebody who is absolutely committed to the security of this nation. And for the Democrats, and for their allies, and the media to be trying to smear her now with these attacks I think is really disgraceful. I'm confident that she'll do well.
MACCALLUM: Let me ask you, you know, some of the specifics, in terms of the interrogation of KSM, this report from BuzzFeed says that he lied while he was being water boarded, while these enhanced interrogation techniques were used on him. -- they say that he gave up the dirty bomb plot before he was water boarded, and that they didn't get useful information out of him afterwards. These are the kinds of questions that she's gonna get.
CHENEY: Yeah. Look, I think, that there are -- number one, I would urge people to go back. There's a 2004 report that was declassified by the CIA. The title of the report is KSM was the source of the vast majority of our knowledge at that point about Al-Qaeda, and it is simply not the case that he gave that information up prior to being water boarded. So, I would urge any of the senators who are going to oppose her, any of the senators who are going to stand up and say we shouldn't have water boarded KSM, for example. They ought to be able to tell the American people how many American lives they're willing to sacrifice so they don't have to water board a terrorist. I wouldn't be willing to sacrifice any American lives for that.
And there's a big effort now to rewrite history. Big effort to try to claim this program, didn't work. But we know the program gave us information that helped save lives. We also know the program led directly, gave us clues that led directly to helping identify the location of Osama Bin Laden, and CIA directors have said that from both parties throughout the period of time since the program was started and also was ended. So, it was a good program and it worked.
MACCALLUM: As always, you know, the benefit of time. You have to really put yourself back in those moments as well. Liz Cheney, thank you so much. It's good to see you, thanks for being here tonight.
CHENEY: You too, Martha. Thanks for having me.
MACCALLUM: So, the polls have now closed in four key battleground states and primary results are starting to stream in. We are starting to get some numbers in West Virginia. Our political power panel coming up next.
MACCALLUM: It is 7:51 on the east coast, and the polls are now closed in Indiana, Ohio, North Carolina and West Virginia. In West Virginia, Fox News can now project that Senator Joe Manchin will easily defeat his challenger, Paula Jean Swearengin from Bob White, West Virginia, right Chris Stirewalt?
CHRIS STIREWALT, FOX NEWS POLITICS EDITOR: I believe that is correct.
MACCALLUM: We think that's where she's from, but not a win tonight for her, and no big surprise that Joe Manchin easily moves on to face one of these three gentlemen, although we don't know which one yet. A very hot race in West Virginia that we have watched, Don Blankenship, of course, is the coal baron who used to be the CEO of Massey Energy in West Virginia. He spent a year in prison after the explosion at UBB mine, lost 29 people, and he's up against Evan Jenkins and Patrick Morrisey. So, let's bring in our friends who are with us tonight to cover this, Charlie Hurt, Chris Stirewalt, Mo Elleithee and Capri Cafaro. Welcome to all of you. Charlie just joining us, welcome.
CHARLIE HURT, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR: Good to be with you.
MACCALLUM: When you look at all this, what's strikes you tonight? What are you looking at?
HURT: Well, I think that what we're still seeing is -- especially in Republican parts of the country, you're seeing an electorate that is very much in the throes of antiestablishment fervor, and it's a probe Trump fervor. And so a guy like Don Blankenship, while he may give the vapors to everybody here in Washington, he's got a real shot at winning the nomination now in West Virginia.
STIREWALT: When the plane Virginians are talking about getting the vapors you know that they've been spending too much time.
STIREWALT: Yeah. They've been spending too much time with the West Virginians. I think Charles is 150 percent right. I think that not just in West Virginia, but in Indiana there is a mold here to whatever degree that the president wants to stop this, he was the accelerant for this fire, and telling Republicans that they can't have what they want after Trump demonstrated that they could, right? It was possible to pick who they told you not to and still win anyway. It's pretty hard then to turn around and say but stop here.
MACCALLUM: Yeah. I mean, Mo, we know that, obviously, Mitch McConnell is no big fan of Don Blankenship, and this has been a really fascinating debate to watch between these two. They've been sniping at each other throughout the whole course of this thing. And, you know, word is that Mitch McConnell and President Trump spoke about this, and President Trump decided to come right out and say do not vote for Don Blankenship, he cannot win. But he could win tonight, potentially, we'll see.
MO ELLEITHEE, FOX NEWS CONTRIBUTOR: He could. And if he does, it's because he's trying to say that he's Trumpier than Trump, right? If Blankenship pulls this out, you know, I think it will show that, at least right now with the Republican base, Trumpism -- that Republican voters are more loyal to Trumpism then they are to Trump. And that's a really interesting dynamic. Though the president will be 0 for 2 in sort of these races between Alabama and West Virginia. And, you know, you look at -- compare that to the Democrats in that West Virginia congressional seat to replace Jenkins where you've got this really interesting Democrat, Richard Ojeda, if he pulls it off tonight is running as a populist Democrat, pro- gun, pro-labor, really made a name for himself as a -- fighting -- standing with the teachers. You're seeing the debate between antiestablishment and economic populism.
MACCALLUM: Capri, quick thought of what you're watching at this moment?
CAPRI CAFARO, FORMER OHIO STATE SENATE MINORITY LEADER: Look, I mean, I think at this point the big thing in West Virginia, if that's what we're talking about, I've talked too much about Ohio before.
MACCALLUM: We didn't get to the school board though, Capri.
CAFARO: Look, I could tell you. Here's the thing that I would say about West Virginia right now. In all seriousness is that Trump said don't vote for Blankenship, they didn't pick one of the other two. So, the establishment can split the vote, we'll see what happens. I think that's good for Blankenship.
MACCALLUM: All right. Quick break. Thank you guys. We'll be right back with more.
MACCALLUM: Breaking news just in, and prepared remarks ahead of her hearing tomorrow, Gina Haspel will tell the senate intel committee I offer you my personal commitment clearly and without reservation that under my leadership, CIA will not restart such a detention and interrogation program. So, we'll have to watch tomorrow and lots of incoming political news tonight. I'll be here all night as the decision desk. Tucker is up next.
Copy: Content and Programming Copyright 2018 Fox News Network, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Copyright 2018 ASC Services II Media, LLC. All materials herein are protected by United States copyright law and may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, displayed, published or broadcast without the prior written permission of ASC Services II Media, LLC. You may not alter or remove any trademark, copyright or other notice from copies of the content.