Phillip Phillips took home the "Idol" title on Wednesday’s season finale, while Season 3 winner Fantasia Barrino had people talking when she hit the stage in a skin-tight, sequin catsuit.

Channeling Jennifer Lopez à la her 2011 American Music Awards performance, Fantasia, 27, showed off her curves in a black bodysuit as she covered Elton John‘s “Take Me To the Pilot” with this season’s second place runner-up, Joshua Ledet.

While we’re all for celebs taking fashion risks, we’re unsure if Fantasia’s figure-hugging garb was the right choice for the “I Believe” songstress. Did Fantasia rock this look?

Click through the gallery for a closer look, then tell us what you think of her saucy ensemble in the poll.

More On This...