Kara DioGuardi Joins 'Idol' Judges for NYC Tryouts

NEW YORK – It was only her first day as an "American Idol" judge, but already Kara DioGuardi seemed part of the dysfunctional family.

DioGuardi, the freshly-installed fourth "Idol" critic, joined Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson in a public show of solidarity Tuesday afternoon as the quartet entered a Chelsea Piers building on Manhattan's west side for a round of season eight auditions.

They walked a red carpet amid a media circus aimed at getting the first photo opportunity of DioGuardi with her new co-workers. Cowell summed up the thinking behind adding the 37-year-old singer-songwriter to the panel.

On the Scene: Click here for Jill Dobson's blog from the New York 'Idol' auditions

"It's like, you know, having dinner with three people for seven years, and getting quite bored of each other," Cowell told reporters. "So it's having a fourth person, new opinion, I think it's gonna be interesting."

"I think it's gonna make it sexier," said Jackson, chiming in.

DioGuardi's songs have been recorded by Kelly Clarkson, Christina Aguilera, Gwen Stefani, Celine Dion, Faith Hill, Carrie Underwood and Pink, among others. Her recent Top 40 hits include Stefani's "Rich Girl," Clarkson's "Walk Away" and Dion's "Taking Chances."

Fox announced DioGuardi's new gig Monday morning.

"Kara has a good reputation of A, having hits; and B, having an opinion. And that's a good combination," Cowell said, adding, matter-of-factly: "And she's cute."

"You think I'm cute?" DioGuardi replied (as if she didn't know it already). "Oh, good."

A smiling Abdul said she was excited to have another woman at the judges' table. She had expressed uncertainty about the new format in a radio interview the day before, telling Phoenix's 104.7 KISS-FM that she was "concerned about the audience and acceptance. Time will tell. We'll see."

As it happens, Abdul and DioGuardi are longtime friends. They co-wrote the dance song "Spinning Around" for Kylie Minogue in 2000.

"I know Kara, and she speaks her mind -- so she will be speaking her mind," Abdul said of DioGuardi's judging technique.

"That's a nice way of saying she's bitchy," Cowell sniped, eliciting a "Whooooooooah!" from Jackson.

"Then what are you if I'm bitchy?" DioGuardi said.

"Sincere," Cowell responded.

"I'm sincere too," she said.

Cowell said they hadn't fully decided how ties will be broken in the audition process. In past seasons, two out of three judges had to agree to advance aspiring pop stars to the Hollywood round.

He joked that the foursome held a slumber party to bond with the rookie.

"We had a picnic last night in the bedroom," he said. "I wore pajamas, the girls wore negligees and we kind of broke the ice."

What will be the seating order on the panel?

"I'm gonna sit between the two girls," Cowell said.

"I'm gonna sit between the two girls as well," Jackson replied.

And how will the time-starved show fit in FOUR judges' opinions?

"Paula will have to speak less," said Cowell, unable to resist another swipe at his favorite target.