Maine judge rules school board committee discriminated against church over lease argument
Hermon school committee members questioned Pines Church of Bangor on same-sex marriage, abortion and transgender issues
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}A district judge ruled that a Maine school committee religiously discriminated against The Pines Church. (Screenshot/Google Maps)
A federal judge in Maine ruled Friday that the Hermon School Committee discriminated against The Pines Church of Bangor after its pastor requested a yearlong lease to hold Sunday services at Hermon High School, finding that religious bias influenced the committee's decision.
In 2022, the church's lead pastor, Matt Gioia, reached out to the Hermon School Department to discuss renting out space in the high school for Sunday worship services, requesting a yearlong lease rather than a month-to-month rental arrangement.
After Gioia presented his proposal to the school committee, committee member Christopher McLaughlin sent questions through then-Superintendent Micah Grant, seeking clarification about how the church approached "issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion around their messaging around some key issues relevant to marginalized communities."
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}The questions also addressed its views on same-sex marriage, abortion and transgender issues.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker ruled that members of the Hermon School Committee discriminated against The Pines Church in considering its request for a yearlong lease. (Brian A. Jackson/South Florida Sun Sentinell via Getty Images)
Then-Superintendent Micah Grant also forwarded McLaughlin's questions to Gioia.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Although Gioia received an apology from Grant regarding these questions, Grant and school committee Chair Jesse Keith later sought legal guidance on whether allowing the church to use school facilities would constitute "an unlawful establishment of religion" and whether denying the request would violate the First Amendment.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker of the District of Maine wrote in his decision that while he did not believe Grant exhibited bias against the church, noting that Grant repeatedly worked to help Gioia through the application process, he found that at least three school committee members — McLaughlin, Stephanie Oiler and Karen Shorey — were improperly influenced by the church's religious identity or beliefs.
"It appears that he based his decision directly on the Plaintiffs’ religious beliefs and its associated political and culture ethics that flow from those beliefs, and the religious nature of the proposed use," Walker wrote. "McLaughlin would have approached a lease request differently had it been presented by an organization that shared his personal beliefs."
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}"I conclude that this qualifies as a sufficient ‘bad motive’ for First Amendment purposes as it has been interpreted and applied by the Supreme Court," the judge wrote while discussing Oiler's conduct.
SUPREME COURT OFFERS SUPPORT FOR CATHOLIC PRESCHOOLS CHALLENGING STATE FUNDING REQUIREMENTS
Advocates for Faith & Freedom praised a federal judge's ruling that the Hermon School Department violated a church's First Amendment rights. (iStock)
Walker determined that the Hermon School Department's treatment and denial of the church's yearlong lease application violated its First Amendment rights and Maine's public accommodations law.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}However, the judge denied the church's request for a court order to block future lease denials. He noted that while the committee members had violated the church's rights, the church's attorneys had not established that the school's written rental policy was itself unconstitutional or adequately addressed the legal requirements for an injunction, including irreparable harm.
In a statement to Fox News Digital, Hermon School Superintendent Barbara Sargent said the department was reviewing the decision and would consider whether to adjust its procedures.
"While this legal matter has concluded, the Hermon School Department’s dedication to its students remains unchanged," she said. "The Department is committed to ensuring that this resolution does not distract from our essential work. We remain focused on providing an exceptional educational experience, supporting our professional staff, and maintaining a school environment where student success is the highest priority."
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}Fox News Digital reached out to The Pines Church and Advocates for Faith & Freedom, who represented the church, for comment but did not immediately receive a response.
SWING STATE MAYOR SUED AS CITY’S MUSLIM HOLIDAY DISPLAYS IGNITE RELIGIOUS-FAVORITISM FIGHT
The Pines Church was denied a yearlong lease to hold Sunday services at Hermon High School in 2022, although the school committee offered a month-to-month arrangement. (Godong/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)
In a press release, Advocates for Faith & Freedom praised the ruling as a victory for religious freedom.
{{#rendered}} {{/rendered}}CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
"This ruling affirms a fundamental principle: when public schools open their facilities to community groups such as sports teams, scouts, and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith," Advocates for Faith & Freedom President Bob Tyler said. "The court saw through pretextual concerns about staffing, capacity, and logistics and correctly identified the real motive — hostility to the Church’s religious viewpoint. The Constitution demands neutrality, and today the court enforced it."