Updated February 20, 2009
Supreme Court Considers Hearing 'Wardrobe Malfunction' Case
, FOXNews.com
The supposedly obscene flash of R&B singer Janet Jackson's right breast during her half time performance led to what the Federal Communications Commission called an "unprecedented number" of complaints about the broadcast.
It lasted 0.5625 seconds, was seen by 143 million people and cost CBS $550,000.
Now the Supreme Court is meeting Friday to decide whether it should hear a case upholding the fine the broadcaster paid for the "wardrobe malfunction" that titillated 2004 Super Bowl viewers.
The supposedly obscene flash of R&B singer Janet Jackson's right breast during her half time performance led to what the Federal Communications Commission called an "unprecedented number" of complaints about the broadcast.
After reviewing the tape, the FCC fined CBS $550,000 for broadcasting material it found to be graphic and explicit. The FCC concluded that the incident "was shocking to the viewing audience...during a prime time broadcast of a sporting event that was marketed as family entertainment and contained no warning that it would include nudity."
CBS was let off the hook by the Philadelphia-based Third Circuit Court of Appeals. It ruled that the FCC fine was counter to the agency's past practices and considered the penalty against CBS to be "arbitrary and capricious."
It also took the FCC to task for its conclusion that CBS was directly liable for the actions taken by Jackson and fellow performer Justin Timberlake. The Third Circuit ruled the "First Amendment precludes the FCC from sanctioning CBS for the indecent expressive conduct of its independent contractors..."
In its brief to the high court, the FCC argues the Third Circuit "erroneously construed" its reasoning for the fines and is asking the Supreme Court to reinstate the penalty. Interestingly, the commission is also asking the court to delay its decision in granting the case until the "fleeting expletive" case is resolved.
That case involved the use of several swear words by Cher and Nicole Ritchie during live awards shows. The fleeting expletive case was heard on Nov. 4. The court has already returned its rulings from the other two non-related cases it heard that day.
CBS has filed its own brief and not surprisingly is asking the court to not take the case. The television network contends the legal issues presented by the FCC do not sufficiently rise to the level that merit further review.
It is likely the court's ruling in the fleeting expletive case will control its decision about the wardrobe malfunction lawsuit.
Latest Politics Videos
-
-
Dr. Congress
-
Nov 22, 2009
Bill would mandate H1N1 sick days
-
-
-
Chris Chocola on 'FNS'
-
Nov 22, 2009
One of the generals in GOP's civil war
-
-
-
Panel Plus: 11/22
-
Nov 22, 2009
'FNS' panel on health care, rationing
-
-
-
On This Day: 11/22
-
Nov 22, 2009
The assassination of JFK
-
-
-
Eventful Trip?
-
Nov 21, 2009
Did Obama make any news in Asia?
-
-
-
Bogus Numbers
-
Nov 21, 2009
Media cracks down on 'saved jobs' numbers
-
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 50.6% | 43.4% | +7.2% |
| Congress | 27.0% | 64.3% | -37.3% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 38.0% | 57.2% | -19.2% |
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
House Passes Health Care Bill
November 08, 2009 1,132 comments
-
Health Care Bill Moves Toward Senate Debate
November 22, 2009 975 comments
-
Comment Box: Send Us Your Findings on Health Care Reform
November 19, 2009 860 comments
-
AP Turns Heads for Devoting 11 Reporters to Palin Book 'Fact Check'
November 18, 2009 856 comments
-
Obama: 'Dont' Jump to Conclusions' on Fort Hood Shooting
November 06, 2009 615 comments
-
White House Weighs Jobs, Deficit
November 23, 2009
-
Mayor Newsom Committed to Politics
November 23, 2009
-
Strains in Party Threatens Democrats
November 23, 2009
-
U.S. Enlists Allies in New Surge
November 23, 2009
-
Obama Seeks to Boost U.S. Exports
November 23, 2009
-
Alas, it’s the end of the road for petrolheads
November 22, 2009
-
A gross insult to the people of Europe
November 22, 2009
-
Rule the waves? Not any more we don’t
November 22, 2009
-
They’re still wriggling to avoid the flak on Iraq
November 22, 2009
-
Copenhagen will fail – and quite right too
November 22, 2009



recommend

Subscribe to Comments






