Martha Stewart's $97 baked potato is so good one diner at her restaurant ordered it twice

By Teresa Mull

Published June 04, 2026

Martha Stewart's high-end baked potato gets rave review from food content creator

A side dish at Martha Stewart's new restaurant costs $97, and one content creator said it was so good that he went back and ordered two.

The Bedford by Martha Stewart opened at Foxwoods Resort Casino in Mashantucket, Connecticut, in March. Among its most talked-about menu items: "Martha's Smashed Baked Potato, smashed tableside, crème fraiche, chives, bacon." The potato costs $17 on its own, but diners can add a one-ounce serving of caviar for an additional $80.

"When we looked at the menu and saw a $97 baked potato, I don't know where else you can get one of those," Wisconsin-based YouTube content creator Jason Boehlke told Fox News Digital. "We just had to give it a try."

MARTHA STEWART'S 6-INGREDIENT 'BEST POTATO SALAD' RECIPE DIVIDES SOCIAL MEDIA: 'LOOKS HORRIBLE'

Boehlke said he was impressed by the potato's tableside presentation. The server brought it out on a cart before mixing in the standard toppings.

"And then they finish it off with an entire little jar of caviar," Boehlke said. "I would not usually be into something like that, but [the caviar] brought something different to that baked potato that I've never had before, and I loved it so much that I went back there again and got two."

A baked potato topped with caviar sits on a white plate.

The $97 smashed baked potato at Martha Stewart's new restaurant in Connecticut is "phenomenal," said one YouTuber who tried it. (Jason Boehlke)

Boehlke called it "phenomenal."

"And I ate every bit of it, skin and all," he said. "It was so good."

MARTHA STEWART'S BAGEL HABIT SPARKS FIERCE DEBATE ACROSS SOCIAL MEDIA: 'PUT HER BACK IN JAIL'

Boehlke creates content for two YouTube channels. One is Mr. Hand Pay, a gambling-focused channel where, he said, "People watch me win and lose hundreds of thousands of dollars every day."

Through his work with casinos, he had learned that Stewart was opening the first Bedford by Martha Stewart restaurant outside Las Vegas.

"This is definitely a treat."

"We were all very excited," Boehlke said.

"I knew they would just blow this one out of the park, and they really did. It's absolutely beautiful in there."

CLICK HERE FOR MORE LIFESTYLE STORIES

On her website, Martha Stewart announced in March that the Foxwoods location is a "10,000-square-foot, 204-seat dining destination thoughtfully decorated much like my Bedford, New York, farm."

The Bedford restaurant kitchen is shown with dozens of copper pans.

The new restaurant at Foxwoods Resort Casino in Connecticut, pictured here, is designed to look like Martha Stewart's home. (Jason Boehlke)

Boehlke's other YouTube channel, JasonWasTHERE, focuses on foods that are "really expensive, a really good value, really large or highly rated."

Martha's Smashed Baked Potato checked several of those boxes, Boehlke said.

TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ

"This is definitely a treat," he said. "It's an experience. It's very good. And I'm going to tell you — Martha does everything right. Everything Martha does is first class, and that's exactly what you're getting from those [potatoes]."

Boehlke recalled eating across the table from Stewart a couple of years ago while attending a culinary festival in Kohler, Wisconsin.

Martha Stewart poses in front of the bar and bartenders at The Bedford in Las Vegas.

The Bedford by Martha Stewart opened its first location in Las Vegas. (Denise Truscello/Getty Images for Caesars Entertainment)

"They had the room set up like Bedford, like her house," he said. "And we had it all. We had the pumpkin soup inside of the pumpkin. But the coolest thing is when you get the basket of bread at the beginning — I was very excited for that, and it's so good."

The Foxwoods location also serves the oversized bread basket, Boehlke said.

"When I started eating the bread, I couldn't stop," he added.

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER

Another notable menu item is Big Martha's Pierogies, a $17 appetizer featuring potato filling and brown butter.

Diners can also add caviar, bringing the price of the five-piece dish to $102.

Boehlke and his fiancée, Kristy, ordered one of everything on the Bedford menu, including the upscale pierogies. It was "way too much food," he said.

A woman and a man sit at a restaurant and hold menus showing they are at The Bedford by Martha Stewart.

YouTube content creator Jason Boehlke and his fiancée, Kristy, recently tried one of everything on the menu at Martha Stewart's new restaurant, The Bedford at Foxwoods Resort Casino. (Jason Boehlke)

Over the past several years, Boehlke has lost a significant amount of weight, dropping from about 400 pounds to 285.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Even so, he said the smashed baked potato — loaded with toppings and caviar — is large enough to serve as a meal on its own for most diners.

Fox News Digital reached out to the restaurant for comment.

Teresa Mull is a freelance writer with the Lifestyle team at Fox News Digital.

URL

https://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/martha-stewarts-97-baked-potato-so-good-one-diner-her-restaurant-ordered-twice