With Panama about 90 seconds from reaching a playoff against New Zealand for a World Cup berth, Graham Zusi and Aron Johannsson scored in second-half stoppage time four years ago to give the already qualified United States a 3-2 win and eliminate the hosts.
"You felt this place dip," Jozy Altidore recalled Monday. "You heard people crying."
The U.S. will be back Tuesday night in a match that matters for both teams. The Americans routed Honduras 6-0 Friday at home and are looking for a second straight win in World Cup qualifying under coach Bruce Arena, who replaced Jurgen Klinsmann after an 0-2 start in the final round of the North and Central American and Caribbean region.
Before a light workout at Estadio Rommel Fernández, American players thought the Panamanians might still have that 2013 match on their minds. Panama needed a win, but the late U.S. goals kept Mexico alive and El Tri went on to reach the 2014 tournament in Brazil. Panama has never advanced to the World Cup.
"If we were smart enough, we wouldn't have broken their hearts. Pretty stupid, if you ask me," Arena said humorously. "You think Mexico would have scored a goal at the end of that game?"
Panama opened the hexagonal, as the final round is called, with a 1-0 win at Honduras and a 0-0 tie at home against Mexico, and then lost 1-0 at Trinidad and Tobago. Five players from that 2013 loss to the U.S. were in the starting lineup for Friday's defeat.
"It was obviously probably pretty devastating for the players," said American midfielder Sacha Kljestan, also among those on the field that night. "I'm sure it still means a lot to them."
Mexico leads the hexagonal with seven points, followed by Costa Rica with six, Panama with four and the U.S., Trinidad and Tobago, and Honduras with three each. The top three nations qualify for next year's tournament in Russia, and the fourth-place team again goes to a playoff, this time against Asia's No. 5 nation.
"The reality of the situation that we're in and the reality of the start that we had is we're not playing with house money," U.S. captain Michael Bradley said. "We're not in a situation where we can just say, great, we took our three points at home, whatever we get on the road is extra. No, we have to come here and take points. We want three. We're going to play in a way that gives us a chance, a big chance to get three."
Arena predicted as many as four or five changes to his starting lineup. There will be at least two.
John Brooks will miss the match because of a sinus infection and Sebastian Lletget is out with a foot injury. The players who replaced them against Honduras could start, Tim Ream for Brooks in central defense and Alejandro Bedoya in place of Lletget in right midfield.
Jermaine Jones, back from a one-game suspension for yellow-card accumulation, could enter in a central midfield role, which would push Christian Pulisic to the left flank in place of Darlington Nagbe.
APPROACHING A RECORD
After scoring his second international hat trick Friday, Clint Dempsey has 55 goals, two shy of Landon Donovan's American record.
"Yeah, it's on your mind," the 34-year-old Dempsey said. "But if it comes, it comes. If it don't, it don't."
Panama goalkeeper Jaime Penedo, a holdover from the 2013 game, played for Arena on the LA Galaxy from 2013-15.
"Jaime Pinedo is one of the finest people I've ever met in the game," Arena said. "We enjoyed him very much. Our fans loved him."
After playing on a cool, damp night in the San Francisco Bay Area last weekend, the U.S. will deal with far different conditions. The game-time temperature is forecast to be 80 degrees with high humidity.
Panama's players also may not be used to the heat, given some play in New York, Seattle, Toronto, Switzerland, Romania and other cool climates.