Updated July 23, 2009
Abortion Dispute Threatens to Derail Effort to Overhaul Health Care System
FOXNews.com
Catholic leaders who say they are for health care reform are worried that some provisions in the health care legislation big footing its way through Congress could put them out of business by mandating abortion services.
Catholic leaders who say they are for health care reform are worried that some provisions in the health care legislation making its way through Congress could put them out of business by mandating abortion services.
"If abortion becomes a basic benefit, if it gets mandated, then that means anyone who doesn't provide abortions becomes a second-class citizen at the very least in the health care system,"said Richard Doerflinger, associate director of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops Secretariat of Pro-Life Activities.
He and other Catholic leaders say they could be forced out of networks and referral systems they need in order to survive financially.
Last year alone, the nearly 1,000 Catholic hospitals and health care centers in the U.S. served 92 million patients.
The abortion controversy is the latest to strike the health care overhaul debates in a week that has seen Republicans sharpen their attacks and some Democrats start to waver on Obama's top domestic priority.
Rep. Bart Stupak, D-Mich., who opposes abortion, is sponsoring an amendment that would specifically exclude abortion from any government-run health insurance plan. He says courts have ruled that when health care legislation is silent on abortion, it's considered included.
"If we do not put the specific prohibition against abortion and allow a conscience clause for religious and Catholic hospitals and these workers, it would be part of the bill, it would be understood there is no longer a conscience clause, that we can use public funds for abortion, something that we do not want.
Rep. Tim Ryan, an Ohio Democrat who opposes abortion, has joined the effort as well.
"There needs to be a conscience clause in there, and I don't believe there should be any federal funding for abortions either. So we're quite clear on where we stand on that," he said.
Most lawmakers who support abortion rights also support the idea of protecting a medical professional's right to refuse to perform abortions. But some also are open to some federal funding for abortions in the final version of the law.
On Thursday, Rep. Rosa DeLauro, D-Conn., acknowledged that after the bill is passed, it's likely an advisory panel then will decide exactly what benefits will be included.
"I have been a proponent of low-income women being able to access funds for services and my hope is that we move in that direction,"she said. "I know that others are opposed to that. That's why there hasn't been any language put into the bill. It will be when the bill is passed and when we take a look at what benefit levels are."
Although House Speaker Nancy Pelosi continues to say she has the votes to get a health care measure passed in the House, Stupak says unless the abortion issue is resolved, Pelosi will never get enough Democrats on board, and he claims he's got the votes to bring the House debate to a grinding halt.
Latest Politics Video
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
Kucinich Says He'll Vote for Health Care Bill
March 17, 2010 1,182 comments
-
Obama: 'Procedural' Spat Over Health Bill Vote Doesn't Worry Me
March 17, 2010 1,255 comments
-
Republicans Battle Pelosi Over Plan to Pass Health Bill Without Traditional Vote
March 16, 2010 1,164 comments
-
Despite Obama's Threat to Ditch Bipartisan Health Talks, Lawmakers Remain Divided
February 25, 2010 1,160 comments
-
Obama Writing Health Bill to Skirt GOP Filibuster
February 19, 2010 1,090 comments
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 48.4% | 46.4% | +2.0% |
| Congress | 18.7% | 76.2% | -57.5% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 33.8% | 60.5% | -26.7% |

-
Democrats Hunt Votes for Health Deal
March 18, 2010
-
Senate Clears Jobs Bill
March 17, 2010
-
Levy Defects to GOP in New York Race
March 18, 2010
-
The White House and Fox News: Spring Thaw?
March 17, 2010
-
Clinton to Discuss Arms Reduction in Moscow
March 17, 2010


-
Current, Former Fed Chiefs Oppose Stripping Fed Duties
March 17, 2010
-
Bernanke Defends Fed's Small Bank Supervision Role
March 17, 2010
-
Bank Cop Says Jury Still Out on Overdraft Fees
March 17, 2010
-
First of Several Job-Creation Bills Clears Congress
March 17, 2010

-
After You Believe 5
March 17, 2010
-
USA: Broke and in dangerous decline
March 17, 2010
-
Bring me the cheese head of Steve Jobs!
March 17, 2010
-
Hiding from Hyde
March 17, 2010
-
"It always begins with a whisper in the hallway..."
March 17, 2010

-
Weatherproofing Your Business
March 16, 2010
-
In Focus: Making Money Off Sunshine
March 15, 2010
-
Insurance Tax Breaks for Self-Employed Individuals
March 11, 2010
-
Tax Tips: A Tip for Small-Business Owners
March 10, 2010
-
In Focus: Recycling Pays Off for an Entrepreneur
March 09, 2010

-
The Accounting Trick That Inflated the Bubble
March 15, 2010 13 comments
-
Greece's Problem? The New York Times
March 09, 2010 4 comments
-
Tired of Bailout Nation?
March 05, 2010 46 comments
-
The Case for Medical Malpractice Reform
March 03, 2010 32 comments
-
Another AIG Magical Mystery Tour
March 01, 2010 3 comments

-
Politicians Smother Cities
March 17, 2010
-
Delusional
March 16, 2010 4 comments
-
Reform Does Not Mean More Rules
March 16, 2010 12 comments
-
Pelosi's Pampered Artists
March 15, 2010 48 comments
-
Chump Change
March 14, 2010 29 comments



recommend

Subscribe to Comments







