• Video
  • Radio
  • Mobile
  • U-Report
  • iMag
FOX News.com
            
  • What's Hot
  • Iceberg Spotted Off Australia
  • Girl Sneezes 12,000 Times a Day
  • H1N1 Vaccine Map

  • Watch Live
  • STRATEGY ROOM
  • Bloomberg Wash. Summit
  • State Department Briefing
Breaking News CDC: 22 Million H1N1 Cases in U.S. From April to October

SciTech

  • SciTech Home
    • How Green?
    • Tech Tuesday
    • Archaeology
    • Cybersecurity
    • Evolution and Paleontology
    • Natural Science
    • Patents and Innovation
    • Personal Technology
    • Space
    • Video Gaming
    • NEWS ARCHIVE
    • HOT TOPICS
      • H1N1
      • Small Business
      • Health Care
    • SECTION MAP
FOXNEWS.COM HOME > SCITECH

NSA Call-Record Data Mining No Surprise to Security Experts

Friday, May 12, 2006

  • E-Mail
  • Print
  • Share:
    • Digg
    • Facebook
    • StumbleUpon
    • MySpace

BOSTON —  If the National Security Agency is indeed amassing a colossal database of Americans' phone records, one way to use all that information is in "social network analysis," a data-mining method that aims to expose previously invisible connections among people.

Social network analysis has gained prominence in business and intelligence circles under the belief that it can yield extraordinary insights, such as the fact that people in disparate organizations have common acquaintances. Companies can buy social networking software to help determine who has the best connections for a particular sales pitch.

So it did not surprise many security analysts to learn Thursday from USA Today that the NSA is applying the technology to billions of phone records.

• Click here to read the USA Today article.

"Who you're talking to often matters much more than what you're saying," said Bruce Schneier, a computer security expert and author of "Beyond Fear: Thinking Sensibly About Security in an Uncertain World."

Related

  • Stories

    • Bush: Government Is Within Law in Protecting Americans
    • Raw Data: President Bush on NSA Program
    • NSA Wiretapping Probe Halted Over Security Clearance
    • Judge: U.S. Rules Enabling Internet Wiretaps 'Gobbledygook'
    • Skype Calls May Be Impossible to Wiretap
    • Web Anonymizers Suddenly Get Very Popular
    • Gov't Cyber-Sleuths Focusing on Linux, iPod, Xbox
    • White House Web Site Uses Forbidden Cookies Too
    • NSA Caught Placing Cookies on Web Visitors' Computers
    • Self-Destructing Text Messages Debut in Britain

    Video

    • Debate Over Data
    • NSA Fallout
    • President Bush's Remarks
    • Massive Phone Database

The NSA declined to comment. But several experts said it seemed likely the agency would want to assemble a picture from more than just landline phone records. Other forms of communication, including cell phone calls, e-mails and instant messages, likely are trackable targets as well, at least on international networks if not inside the U.S.

To be sure, monitoring newer communications services is probably harder than getting billing records from landline phones. USA Today reported that the NSA has collected call logs from the three largest U.S. phone companies, BellSouth Corp. (BLS), AT&T Inc. (T) and Verizon Communications Inc. (VZ).

That level of cooperation confirmed the fears of many privacy analysts, who pointed out that AT&T is already being sued in federal court in San Francisco for allegedly giving the NSA access to contents of its phone and Internet networks. The charges are based on documents from a former AT&T technician.

It remains unclear whether other communications providers have been asked for their call logs or billing records.

Verizon Wireless spokesman Jeffrey Nelson definitively said his company — a joint venture between Verizon and Britain's Vodafone (VOD) — was "not involved in this situation." His counterparts at Cingular — an AT&T/BellSouth joint venture — and Sprint Nextel Corp. (S) were less explicit and did not deny any participation.

Even without cell phone carriers' help, of course, calls between wireless subscribers and Verizon, AT&T and BellSouth landlines presumably would be captured.

Among Internet service providers, representatives for AOL LLC, a division of Time Warner Inc. (TWX), said the company complies with individual government subpoenas and court orders but does not have a blanket program for broader sharing of customer data.

In a statement, Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) said it had "never engaged in the type of activity referenced in these articles." Google Inc. (GOOG) spokesman Steve Langdon said his company does not participate, either.

Yahoo Inc. (YHOO) officials say they comply with subpoenas, but refused to elaborate, saying they cannot comment on specific government interactions.

Even without full inside help, the NSA has proven itself adept at capturing communications or at least analyzing traffic information. The Echelon program, for example, is known to have tapped into satellite, microwave and fiber-optic phone links and even undersea cables in order to gain insights into what the rest of the world was talking about.

The Internet does present new challenges for snoops, which has led federal authorities to seek an expansion of a key surveillance law so that it applies to new kinds of Web services.

But even now authorities can tap into data feeds. There is a relatively small number of major Internet backbones and data junctions where networks hand information off to each other.

And while e-mail, Internet calls and other data packets splinter and take varying routes across networks, each packet has a header identifying its source and destination. It's not obvious what the packet is part of — whether an e-mail, a Web page or an Internet phone call — but it still contains the equivalent of a phone billing record: who's talking to whom.

"It's not trivial to analyze all the material, but it's trivial to get to the material," said Barry Steinhardt, director of the technology and liberty program at the American Civil Liberties Union.

Even Skype, the popular Internet phone service, owned by eBay (EBAY), that encrypts its calls — which presumably prevents sweeping monitoring of their content — is believed to be vulnerable to who's-calling-whom traffic analysis.

Still, while the government clearly can parlay industry cooperation and technical firepower to grab lots of communications, there's bound to be a limit.

For example, tiny, free voice-over-Internet services likely don't bother to maintain the kinds of call logs that Verizon, BellSouth and AT&T apparently handed over, said Jeff Pulver, an authority on the technology.

Also, social network analysis would appear to be powerless against criminals and terrorists who rely on a multitude of cell phones, payphones, calling cards and Internet cafes.

Then there are more creative ways of getting off the grid. The Madrid train bombings case has revealed that the plotters communicated by sharing one e-mail account and saving messages to each other as drafts that, since they were never sent, didn't traverse the Internet as regular e-mail messages would.

Privacy activists worry that the government is likely to try to overcome these surveillance gaps by making more use of the information it does have — by cross-referencing phone or other records with commercially harvested data.

One effort in that direction, the Pentagon's infamous Total Information Awareness program, was technically shuttered by Congress, but the government still can access copious data from the private sector.

Even if the NSA's surveillance went no further than the NSA's access to phone billing records, it clearly would raise hackles.

The time and destination of dialed phone calls has long been available to authorities through "pen registers" and "trap and trace" devices — but with a court order.

USA Today noted that concerns about the legality of the NSA's phone-call database led Qwest Communications International Inc. (Q), which operates in a large part of the Rockies and the Pacific Northwest, to refuse to participate.

"A court order couldn't be obtained to just wholesale surveil," said Kurt Opsahl, staff attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which is suing AT&T in San Francisco. "The legal standard requires something more specific. You can't get everybody's data unless you have some suspicion."

  • See Next Story in SciTech
  • E-Mail
  • Print
  • Share:
    • Digg
    • Facebook
    • StumbleUpon
    • MySpace

FOX NEWS VIDEOS



TOP VIDEOS

Earth narrowly misses asteroid strike

Raise kids vs. training killer whales

Winner in 'space elevator' contest

SciTech

  • Your online life after death
  • Military's reaction to Fort Hood
  • Threat of satellite collisions grows
  • How search engine changed our lives
ADVERTISEMENT

most active

Articles

  • Most Read
  • Most Emailed
  • More News
  • 1

    Maclaren Recalls One Million Strollers After Kids Lose Fingertips in Hinges

    »

  • 2

    Framed for Child Porn by a PC Virus

    »

  • 3

    Cord Blood Reverses Cerebral Palsy in Colorado Girl

    »

  • 4

    Tequila: 5 Things You Didn't Know

    »

  • 5

    Legendary Lost Persian Army Found in Sahara

    »

  • 6

    Fort Hood Suspect Warned of Muslim Threat Within Military

    »

  • 7

    Massachusetts Man Says He Was Fired for Telling Colleague Her Gay Marriage Is Wrong

    »

  • 8

    Muggers Return Wallet After Seeing Army ID

    »

  • 9

    New York-Based Radical Muslim Hails Fort Hood Massacre

    »

  • 10

    Vatican Seeks Signs of Alien Life

    »

  • More News
  • Japan to Beam Solar Power from Space on Lasers
    Monday, November 09, 2009 | 04:32 PM

  • Powerful Ideas: Turning Winery Waste into Fuel
    Tuesday, November 03, 2009 | 07:33 PM

  • Navy Ships Repel Bacteria, Thanks to Shark Skin
    Friday, October 30, 2009 | 06:48 PM

  • Smart Grid Not Smart Enough
    Tuesday, October 27, 2009 | 08:40 PM

  • Micromidas Wants to Turn Sewage to Plastic
    Monday, October 26, 2009 | 07:17 PM

More How Green in the News @ GREEN.FOXNEWS.COM


ADVERTISEMENT

GOOF-PROOF GADGET GUIDE

  • Holiday Shopping Guide: HDTVs Explained

    Thinking about an HDTV for the holidays? We tell you what to watch for
  • How Green Are Airplanes?

    Carbon fiber may replace steel in next-gen planes, and improve fuel efficiency
  • Just Add Water

    Super-tough laptop survives soakings, drops and kicks in FOXNews.com's stress test

ONLY ON FOX

  • Space Tourism a Reality by 2012

    The latest trend in tourism is out of this world ... and around the corner
  • 'Weird Creatures' Host Nick Baker Meets a Mole Lizard

    If you're not watching Weird Creatures, you're missing out on nature's oddities
  • Military Links Drones into Unmanned Squadrons

    Whole armies of robotic drones may be just around the corner
  • X-Prize Race Gets Exciting

    With a $1 million grand prize up for grabs, amateurs and pros launch rockets
  • 8 Tech Trends for 2010

    The strangest tech trends of 2010
  • Ares 1-X Rocket Launch a Soaring Success

    NASA's new experimental rocket launched with nary a hitch
  • 'Brain Blueprinting' Might Have Helped Ted Kennedy

    Scientists devise genetic blueprints, or roadmaps, of the human brain
  • Meet the REAL Young Indiana Jones

    Step aside, Harrison Ford!
  • Big in Japan: Burger King Sells Windows 7 Whopper

    With seven all-beef patties, the Windows 7 Whopper is quite a mouthful

Marketplace

  • Autos
  • Mortgages
Find a Car
Find a Mortgage
Get Voicemail
See Your Score $0
Fox News Shop
Celebrity News
Lifestyle Magazine
Nationwide Insurance Save up to $500
iPhone FOX Business Download the App

  • Home
  • U.S.
  • World
  • Politics
  • Health
  • Business
  • SciTech
  • Entertainment
  • Video
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • Leisure
  • Careers
  • Internships - FNCU
  • Fox Around the World
  • RSS Feeds

  • Advertise With Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Email FOXNews.com Newsroom

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. © 2009 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. All market data delayed 20 minutes.