Updated November 12, 2009
Abortion Access in House Bill Drives Massachusetts Race to Replace Kennedy
- FOXNews.com
Two of the leading Democratic candidates to replace Massachusetts Sen. Ted Kennedy, who died of brain cancer in August, are battling over who is better suited to wear his mantle.
What would Teddy do?
Few U.S. senators took stronger positions on universal health care and a woman's right to have an abortion than the late Sen. Edward Kennedy.
Now two of the leading Democratic candidates to replace the "Lion of the Senate," who died of brain cancer in August, are battling over who is better suited to wear his mantle. And they are cherry-picking his platform to suit themselves as they battle for their party's nomination to run for senator from Massachusetts.
State Attorney General Martha Coakley says she would not support a bill that excludes federal funding for abortion -- even if her vote were the pivotal 60th needed to pass the Senate version of the bill. Her opponent, Rep. Michael Capuano, says he voted for the the House bill, which restricts abortion funding, in order to see it pass -- although he acknowledges he could vote against it if the final legislation includes such a provision.
Coakley says Capuano is sacrificing one constitutional right for another, while Capuano says Coakley's position undermines the sweeping legislation to which Kennedy devoted his career.
"Martha is firmly in support of health care reform and believes in a strong public option," Coakley Communications Director Alex Zaroulis told FoxNews.com. "However, she was very disturbed that the House adopted the Stupak-Pitts Amendment that would deny millions of women access to reproductive services.
"The inclusion of this amendment violates the very intent of health care reform, which is meant to guarantee quality affordable health care coverage for everyone," Zaroulis added.
But Capuano says that it's easy for Coakley to make such grandiose statements, because she will never have to eat her words.
"If she had her way, health care reform would be dead," Capuano told FoxNews.com.
One week ago, in an effort to appease party conservatives, Democrats included an amendment authored by Rep. Bart Stupak, D-Mich., and Rep. Joe Pitts, R-Pa., that would toughen restrictions on federal funding for abortions. Stupak's measure would prohibit women who opt for the government-sponsored insurance exchange from using coverage for abortion services.
Capuano said he opposes any limits on coverage for women's reproductive services, but he voted for the overall bill that passed the House 220-215 because to do otherwise would undermine the legislation Kennedy spent his life trying to enact.
The six-term congressman told FoxNews.com that he will do everything he can to remove the provision before it reaches President Obama's desk, but he did not indicate how he would vote if the measure remains in a House-Senate compromise.
"We'll see what the bill says," he said. "I would tend to vote against it" if it restricted abortion funding.
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said in a statement Thursday that she will throw her support behind Capuano, saying he has a "proven record of standing up for progressive values and what he believes is right." She called Capuano's vote on the House health care bill "courageous."
Coakley, Capuano, Boston Celtics co-owner Steve Pagliuca and City Year co-founder Alan Khazei are all vying for the Democratic nomination to run in next year's special election to replace Kennedy, a nomination that most expect will lead to a November victory in dark blue Massachusetts.
Capuano noted that every pro-choice member of the House voted in favor of the bill, including Kennedy's son, Rep. Patrick Kennedy, D-R.I.
"I would like to think Senator Kennedy would have voted the same way," he said. "I don't think Patrick Kennedy would have voted any other way than his father would have."
Capuano told supporters at a rally on Monday that no legislation is perfect, and that striking down a bill that provides coverage for 36 million uninsured over one issue is not pragmatic.
"I have never once, or almost never, voted on a major piece of legislation that was all good or all bad,'' he told supporters. "Do you think that when they voted on Medicare that it was a perfect bill? Or Social Security? Or the Civil Rights Act? Every one of those bills was major progress with flaws in the bill." The primary will be held on Dec. 8.
Seizing upon the friction between his opponents, Pagliuca released a television ad late Wednesday, criticizing both Coakley and Capuano for indicating they would not support the bill if it includes the House's ban on funding abortion.
"Two of my opponents for the U.S. Senate are putting this landmark legislation at risk," Pagliuca says in the ad. "The next senator from Massachusetts represents a vital 60th vote to provide health care to over 30 million Americans who don't have it, and to help lower spiraling health care costs."
Elections analyst Stuart Rothenberg said "it's easier for Coakley to draw a line in the sand" because she does not have to cast an actual vote.
"Tactically, she has the easier case, while Capuano is in a more difficult position because he has to explain" his vote, he said.
But, Rothenberg added, "People for whom (abortion funding) is a symbolic issue, it probably will devalue some of Capuano's explanation."
Rothenberg said he doesn't believe the abortion provision will become the defining issue for voters on Dec. 8. "It is the topic du jour because abortion and health care is the topic de jour nationally," he said.
Passing topic or not, it may not hurt Coakley to bring it up. A Suffolk University poll released Thursday found that 44 percent of people polled believe Coakley will win the Democratic primary.
Seventeen percent said they believe Pagliuca will win, 16 percent bet on Capuano and 3 percent favored City Year co-founder Alan Khazei. Twenty percent were undecided.
In the Republican race, 45 percent said they believe state Sen. Scott Brown will win, while 7 percent are betting on businessman Jack E. Robinson and 47 percent are undecided.
The survey, conducted Nov. 4-8, polled 600 Massachusetts residents and has a margin of error of plus or minus 4 percentage points.
Latest Politics Video
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
Tell Us What You Think About the Health Care Package
March 18, 2010 2,616 comments
-
Obama: 'Procedural' Spat Over Health Bill Vote Doesn't Worry Me
March 17, 2010 1,842 comments
-
House OKs Key Step Toward Health Insurance Overhaul
March 21, 2010 1,560 comments
-
Kucinich Says He'll Vote for Health Care Bill
March 17, 2010 1,192 comments
-
Republicans Battle Pelosi Over Plan to Pass Health Bill Without Traditional Vote
March 16, 2010 1,170 comments
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 47.0% | 47.0% | % |
| Congress | 19.0% | 75.8% | -56.8% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 33.8% | 60.5% | -26.7% |

-
Historic Health Bill Passes
March 21, 2010
-
Obama, Netanyahu to Meet in Washington
March 21, 2010
-
Pawlenty Less Popular in Minnesota
March 21, 2010
-
Big Push to Alter Finance Rules
March 21, 2010
-
Bernanke Assails Giant Firms
March 20, 2010


-
U.S. Healthcare Bill Clears First Hurdle in House
March 21, 2010
-
READ: Obama’s Planned Executive Order on Abortion
March 21, 2010
-
Anti-Abortion Democrats Reach Deal with White House
March 21, 2010
-
It's Here: Democrats Pass Sweeping Health-Care Reform
March 21, 2010

-
The Pope writes to the Irish church
March 21, 2010
-
Recent Commentaries
March 21, 2010
-
Stupak: "We have an agreement"
March 21, 2010
-
Now Brewing: Ruta Maya
March 21, 2010
-
Not yet, God, I'm reading about you
March 21, 2010

-
How Safe Is Your Computer Network From Hackers?
March 19, 2010
-
Young Guns: Sing This Well and Learn How to Spell
March 18, 2010
-
New Law Doesn't Help Business Credit Cards
March 17, 2010
-
Olympic Star Johnny Weir on How to Sell 'You'
March 16, 2010
-
'Chemistry' Keeps Music Store Alive in Web Age
March 11, 2010

-
Main Street Fights Wall Street Over Muni Derivatives
March 18, 2010
-
The Accounting Trick That Inflated the Bubble
March 15, 2010 21 comments
-
Greece's Problem? The New York Times
March 09, 2010 4 comments
-
Tired of Bailout Nation?
March 05, 2010 46 comments
-
The Case for Medical Malpractice Reform
March 03, 2010 32 comments

-
Good News: Obamacare to Create 16,500 New Jobs!
March 21, 2010 21 comments
-
Evil Insurance Companies?
March 20, 2010 59 comments
-
Bottled Water Hysteria (II)
March 19, 2010 90 comments
-
Hollywood Gets It Wrong
March 19, 2010 23 comments
-
CBO: Confusing Budget Obfuscation?
March 19, 2010 26 comments



recommend

Subscribe to Comments







