Barry Carpenter had been convicted on charges of receiving stolen property, theft in office and evidence tampering. During Wednesday's sentencing hearing in eastern Ohio, Carpenter's attorney said he would appeal.
Carpenter resigned two weeks ago as chief in Martins Ferry, where the celebrity couple's surrogate lived.
Carpenter and police Chief Chad Dojack of neighboring Bridgeport were accused of conspiring to steal items from the woman's home to sell to paparazzi.
Dojack's trial is scheduled for next month.