Pope to oil execs: Energy needs should not destroy civilization

Pope Francis had a stern warning for global oil executives on Saturday: satisfying the world's growing energy needs "must not destroy civilization."

During the two-day conference, which was a follow-up to his encyclical three years ago that called on people to save the planet from climate change and other environmental ills, the leader of the world's Catholics said the transition to less-polluting energy sources is "a challenge of epochal proportions."

Participants included the CEOs of Italian oil giant ENI, British Petroleum, ExxonMobil and Norway's Statoil as well as scientists and managers of major investment funds. Their remarks on the first day of the closed-door conference were not released by the Vatican.

"Civilization requires energy, but energy must not destroy civilization," he implored the assembled executives.


While Francis lauded the oil executives for embedding an assessment of climate change risks into their planning strategies, he also put them on notice for their "continued search for fossil fuel reserves," two and a half years after the Paris climate accord "clearly urged keeping most fossil fuels underground."

Energy experts and those who advocate fighting climate change expressed doubts before the conference that it would amount to anything other than a PR opportunity for the companies to burnish their image without making meaningful changes.

In his remarks, the pope said he hoped the meeting gave participants the chance to "re-examine old assumptions and gain new perspectives."

Francis said that modern society with its "massive movement of information, persons and things requires an immense supply of energy." And still, he said, as many as one billion people still lack electricity.

In this June 4, 2018 photo, buildings under construction and finished buildings line Seaport Boulevard in Boston's Seaport District. While some new Seaport developers are building with climate change in mind - especially after 2012’s Superstorm Sandy slammed New York and showed what a bad storm could do on the East Coast - many office towers and high-rise condos erected earlier simply didn’t. And environmental activists and some researchers complain the city isn’t moving quickly or aggressively enough to change development patterns. (AP Photo/Steven Senne)

Pope Francis told oil executives that they need to do more to mitigate the impact of climate change. In this June 4, 2018 photo, buildings under construction and finished buildings are seen in Boston's Seaport District. Some Seaport developers are building with climate change in mind, but others are not.  (AP)

The pope said meeting the energy needs of everyone on the planet must be done in ways "that avoid creating environmental imbalances, resulting in deterioration and pollution that is gravely harmful to our human family, both now and in the future."

Frances also recalled his own appeal in the "Laudato Si" encyclical for an energy policy "aimed at averting disastrous climate changes that could compromise the well-being and future of the human family, and our common home." That includes transitioning to efficient, clean energy sources.

"This is a challenge of epochal proportions," he said Saturday. "At the same time it is an immense opportunity to encourage efforts to ensure fuller access to energy by less developed countries ... as well as diversifying energy sources and promoting the sustainable development of renewable forms of energy."

The pope called for specific commitments to combat climate change and provide energy security.

He said it was "disturbing and a cause for real concern" that the levels of carbon dioxide emissions and the concentrations of greenhouse gases remain high despite commitments taken in the 2015 Paris accord to fight global warming.


He urged the executives to use their "demonstrated aptitude for innovation" to address "two of the great needs in today's world: the care of the poor and the environment."  He noted that the poor pay the highest price for climate change, often being forced to migrate due to water insecurity, severe weather and an accompanying collapse in agriculture.

"The transition to accessible and clean energy is a duty that we owe toward millions of our brothers and sisters around the world, poor countries and generations yet to come," the pope said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.