'Botched' execution of Alabama inmate was so 'excruciating' he wanted to die, lawyer says

The lawyer representing an Alabama death-row inmate argued in court filings on Monday his client should not appear for a second time in a death chamber because the first “botched" execution was an "excruciating experience."

Attorney Bernard Harcourt wrote in state and federal court filings that another attempt to execute 61-year-old Doyle Lee Hamm would violate the U.S. Constitution's ban on cruel and unusual punishment.

"What was inflicted on Doyle Hamm was a form of torture," Hartcourt wrote in his filing.

Hamm, who has battled lymphoma, was set to be executed Feb. 22 for the 1987 killing of motel clerk Patrick Cunningham. State officials called off the execution shortly after 11 p.m. because of problems getting the intravenous line connected.

Doyle Lee Hamm2

Photos entered in court records show Doyle Lee Hamm's veins, and contend the veins in his lower extremities are more accessible.  (Court Records)

Harcourt, a Columbia University law professor, has argued in court filings since July that lethal injection would be difficult and painful because Hamm's veins have been severely compromised by lymphoma, hepatitis and prior drug use.

A doctor hired by Hamm's legal team, Dr. Mark Heath, wrote in a report included with the court filing that Hamm had 11 puncture sites, bled heavily from his groin, and sustained injuries including a possible punctured bladder during the attempts to connect the line.


The doctor said that Hamm had to be carried back to his cell by correctional officers after the execution was called off for the night.

Photos submitted to the court showed Hamm's feet were bruised and blackened, presumably from pooling blood.

Doyle Lee Hamm6

Injuries to Doyle Lee Hamm after his "botched" execution last month.  (Court Records)

The graphic photos also showed bruising from what the doctor said was a groin injury.

Doyle Lee Hamm5

Injuries to Doyle Lee Hamm's groin area after his "botched" execution last month.  (Court Records)

The filing Monday included Hamm's recounting of the event to Heath. Hamm indicated he had begun bleeding heavily from his groin, enough to soak through a pad or drape, during the attempt to connect the line, Heath wrote.

He added that Hamm said a man who had been on a cellphone watching the attempts announced to the team that the execution was over.


In his filing, Harcourt wrote the "excruciating experience," exceeds what the U.S. Constitution tolerates as permissible punishment, and that his client had "unbearable physical and psychological pain."

"Physically, as he was strapped down to the lethal injection gurney in the execution chamber knowing that he was about to die. Doyle Hamm was jabbed multiple times with needles and catheters in his ankles, shin and right groin," Harcourt wrote.

Doyle Lee Hamm2

Injuries to Doyle Lee Hamm after his "botched" execution last month.  (Court Records)

"Psychologically, once again strapped to his death gurney, Doyle Hamm was so injured that he hoped the execution team would succeed so that it would be over with and he would be dead," Harcourt continued. "Doyle Hamm watched as the execution team wiped blood off his legs and right groin, even replacing a blood-soaked pad covering his groin. Doyle Hamm experienced a constitutionally prohibited cruel, unnecessarily painful, slow, and lingering process to death."

Doyle Lee Hamm1

Injuries to Doyle Lee Hamm after his "botched" execution last month.  (Court Records)

Corrections Commissioner Jeff Dunn has said the execution was stopped because of a "time issue" and concerns of getting the line connected before the midnight deadline.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Travis Fedschun is a reporter for FoxNews.com. Follow him on Twitter @travfed