Print Print    Close Close

CFP selection committee 'explains' its lack of transparency: isn't really 'feasible' | Ian Miller

By Ian Miller

Published November 20, 2026

Fox News
Jake Butt x Dan Dakich | Don't @ Me w/ Dan Dakich Video

The move from the BCS to a College Football Playoff selection committee was supposed to limit controversy and disagreement about the teams chosen to play for a championship.

Instead? It's been the exact opposite. As the selection committee's rankings thus far in the 2026-2027 season have demonstrated, the controversy has only deepened. There's been clear favoritism, bias, subjectivity and inconsistency. Best exemplified by the disastrous release of week three of the committee's top-25 poll, which revealed that they have no intention of maintaining their standards when they apply to teams in the SEC. Nor will they listen to criticism and adjust their thinking.

The Indiana Hoosiers in week two of the poll dropped five spots on a bye week, because the Big Ten opponents they'd beaten this season all lost in the same week. The exact same thing happened to the Alabama Crimson Tide, but worse, and the committee not only didn't drop them, committee chair Hunter Yurachek praised them.

CFP HANGOVER: INDIANA CAN’T ESCAPE SCHEDULE DEBATE, BUT ALABAMA GETS TO SKIP THE CONVERSATION ONCE AGAIN

Kalen DeBoer reacts during the first half at Neyland Stadium.

Alabama Crimson Tide head coach Kalen DeBoer reacts during the first half against the Tennessee Volunteers at Neyland Stadium in Knoxville, Tenn., on Oct. 17, 2026. (IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect)

Why? Because of their resilient road performance against ... Vanderbilt. In a stadium that was roughly 60% Alabama fans, the Tide had one of the worst games of the season. The Commodores actually drove into the Alabama red zone more frequently throughout the game, three to two. The vaunted Alabama offense had just 309 total yards with an anemic 4.5 yards per play. Their rushing "attack" was even worse, averaging just 2.6 yards per attempt.

This came against a team that is now 1-6 in the SEC and should be 3-7 overall, if not for one of the most bizarre, fluky finishes in recent college football memory against NC State. Vanderbilt is bad! The game was effectively a home one, thanks to the enormous road game crowd advantage. And the Tide still played poorly, while all their other Patented SEC Quality Wins™ lost. Sounds like a recipe for a team to fall in the rankings, right?

CFP SELECTION COMMITTEE HAS OFFICIALLY DISCREDITED ITSELF WITH LATEST RANKINGS | IAN MILLER

Wrong. The Tide are under the committee's protection, and the comments from Yurachek afterward explained it beautifully.

"Alabama faced a similar circumstance where five of their SEC opponents all lost, but it didn't have the same impact on their strength of schedule that it had on Indiana's strength of schedule," he said. "Actually, it is very minimal for Alabama because of the quality and the strength of schedule of those five teams that lost."

South Carolina firmly established that it is not good by losing to an atrocious Arkansas team by 28 points. Texas A&M is still treated as a Quality Win™ because it plays in the SEC, despite falling to 4-6 and 1-6 in conference. Mississippi State has lost five games in a row, allowing an average of 35 points per game. It is still counted as a Quality Win™ because of a quarterback injury, since defense doesn't matter. Kentucky has lost two games in a row and scored just 20 combined points, demonstrating that, as the computer metrics always suggested, it was wildly overrated to begin with. Oh, and LSU lost yet again at home, falling to 3-4 in the SEC and 6-4 overall.

No serious person would argue that Alabama's resume or strength of schedule or record looks better this week than it did last week. But there are no serious people on the College Football Playoff selection committee.

Kalen DeBoer looks on during a football game at Bryant-Denny Stadium.

Alabama Crimson Tide head coach Kalen DeBoer looks on during the second quarter against the Georgia Bulldogs at Saban Field at Bryant-Denny Stadium in Tuscaloosa, Ala., on Oct. 10, 2026. (David Leong/Imagn Images)

What makes this nonsense even more frustrating is the lack of transparency around the process. Yurachek frequently mentions things like "pods" and "metrics" and "strength of schedule" in his absurdist interviews, yet never explains what those pods are, how they're created, what metrics they use, how they calculate strength of schedule, or what goes into their thought process other than "SEC GOOD ME LIKE SEC RANKED WINS."

This week, he credited Bama for avoiding an emotional letdown after beating LSU. What? Are we measuring emotions now? How does this work? Do they have, like, a Whoop that they use to track the heart rate of players and coaches in the SEC, and if it's elevated, they get special pod points? Or is there a color wheel that the committee uses to track emotions and make decisions on? Do they measure emotions in other conferences or just the SEC? Shouldn't Utah move up to No. 1 because they followed up an emotional win over BYU with a road win over a ranked team?

He also said something about Alabama's margin of victory in SEC games, which is so beyond dumb it beggars belief. The margins of victory can be extremely misleading, which is why advanced metric systems look at more important factors like game efficiency, scoring outside of garbage time, and success rate on offense, success rate allowed on defense, and special teams advantages.

Sarcasm and Yurachek's nonsensical statements aside, though, this has raised a more salient and important question: what metrics do they actually use? How do they determine strength of schedule?

ESPN's Heather Dinich gave an explanation so ridiculous that even her colleagues at the network made fun of her for it. But what's actually happening here?

CLICK HERE FOR MORE OUTKICK SPORTS COVERAGE

Per a source, the committee uses 30 "metrics" to come up with their strength of schedule and strength of record ratings. It'd be great if fans could see what those metrics are, as that would allow more qualified, experienced, and competent fans and analysts to look at them and evaluate them.

Thankfully, reporter Chris Vannini asked them about this week. And their answer was, well, as usual, awful.

Hunter Yurachek speaks at a podium during a public celebration at the Walker Indoor Pavilion.

Arkansas Razorbacks vice chancellor and director of athletics Hunter Yurachek speaks at a public celebration introducing head football coach Ryan Silverfield at the Walker Indoor Pavilion in Fayetteville, Ark., on Dec. 1, 2025. (IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect)

Yurachek responded first, saying that it's "something that we've talked about," then added, "But right now that's kind of been the guidelines that those aren't shared publicly."

Why not? Why are they not shared publicly? Is it because they know that they'd be humiliated ... again ... and the public would see how slanted they are towards the SEC? Things like "ranked wins" and "ranked conference wins," which lead to circular reasoning with SEC teams starting the preseason overrated and providing those benefits to their opponents?

ZERO BS. JUST DAKICH. TAKE THE DON'T @ ME PODCAST ON THE ROAD. DOWNLOAD NOW!

Rich Clark, the committee's executive director, chimed in, saying, "Just to let you know, we have not provided those publicly. Basically, there's so many metrics, to really give that out publicly with an explanation of them isn't really feasible now.

"It is something that we're considering. We're looking at this in the off-season to see what metrics and how we would present those potentially in the coming seasons."

SIGN UP FOR THE DAILY OUTKICK NEWSLETTER

Why is it not feasible? Do they not have internet connections? Is it too tough for them to create a PDF? We have AI now, run it through ChatGPT or Gemini or Claude or Grok and give us a one-page summary and description. This isn't hard! It's extremely easy! And feasible!

OUTKICK IS NOW AVAILABLE ON THE FOX NEWS APP: CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD

The problem is, of course, that the committee does not want people to see how bad their "metrics" are. How ridiculous it is to make decisions with tens of millions of dollars on the line based on things that informed fans and analysts knew weren't important decades ago. How their inconsistent "logic" and incoherent "reasoning" creates hypocrisy, double standards, no standards, bias, and ultimately, controversy.

Yes, it's all well and good that we have athletic directors and former players and coaches on the committee. What do we actually need? Well, should this system continue, which it shouldn't, are people with an analytical background. Who create metrics and understand efficiency and success rate.

Not, "Those Bama boys sure were emotionally drained after that game, see look at their mood rings, we have to reward them for playing like garbage." That's nonsense. Not, "Alabama's margin of victory is the second best in the SEC, so we need to rank them No. 3 despite other more deserving teams being behind them." Because that's insane and meaningless. Not, "we invented Missouri and South Carolina and Florida and Oklahoma as good teams, then based our rankings off that false assumption." Because that's insulting.

Transparency should be the bare minimum, and they can't even do that. They'll "consider" doling out some information to the peasants, next year, if we behave and don't criticize them too much. They learn nothing, they change nothing, they say nothing of value. It's a joke, and it's why the whole thing needs to be torn down.

Ian Miller is a writer at OutKick. 

Print Print    Close Close

URL

https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/cfp-selection-committee-explains-lack-transparency-isnt-really-feasible-ian-miller

  • Home
  • Video
  • Politics
  • U.S.
  • Opinion
  • Entertainment
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Health
  • Travel
  • Lifestyle
  • World
  • Sports
  • Weather
  • Privacy
  • Terms

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. © FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Factset. Powered and implemented by FactSet Digital Solutions. Legal Statement. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by LSEG. Do Not Sell my Personal Information - New Terms of Use - FAQ