Sign in to comment!

Menu
Home

A Secret Tax? Old and Young Alike Feeling Betrayed By Health Care Proposal

1_21_450_100209_greta_aarp.jpg

American Seniors Association Presient Stuart Barton and former AARP member John Johnson (FNC)

This is a rush transcript from "On the Record," October 2, 2009. This copy may not be in its final form and may be updated.

GRETA VAN SUSTEREN, FOX NEWS HOST: Where's the money? If health care reform passes, somehow we're going to have to pay for it. Now, the president stands by his campaign pledge taxes will not go up for anyone who makes less than $250,000 a year. Is that true, or is that fuzzy math?

Joining us live is Republican congressman Mike Pence. Congressman, before we get to the whole business about health care and whether...

REP. MIKE PENCE, R - IN.: Good to be with you, Greta.

VAN SUSTEREN: ... taxes are going up, the big news today, Chicago lost the 2016 Olympics bid to Rio, and after President Obama, his wife and Oprah flew to Copenhagen to make the personal pitch. We're trying to figure out if that's a -- is that a setback or not?

PENCE: Well, you know, it's a disappointment to millions of Americans, experience those of us in the Midwest. We would have loved to have seen the Olympics come to our country in 2016. And it no doubt would have created some jobs down the road. But you know, sadly, it looks like the president's had about as much luck selling the Olympics -- or selling Chicago to the Olympic Committee as he has selling health care reform to the American people.

You know, I think -- I think, you know, the -- the vision of seeing the President of the United States board Air Force One headed to another glamorous capital around the world on the very day that unemployment rises up to 9.8 percent, another quarter of a million Americans lose their job, I think is a source of frustration to millions of Americans. So we're disappointed about the Olympics, but sure would like to see this president put this economy and American jobs as job one.

VAN SUSTEREN: You talk about the sort of the image, the visual of him going off to try to do the pitch to the Olympics. As an aside, though, the Air Force One is a mini-White House. People -- presidents work on it, and he did have a discussion with Afghanistan. So I take it -- I mean, or let me ask you, are you critical of him making that trip, or do you give him credit for at least trying?

PENCE: Well, look, I just -- look, I -- you know, families are hurting in this country, Greta. The reality is that unemployment continues to rise, rising to 9.8 percent today, more than a quarter of a million Americans more out of work, I think 15 million Americans that are jobless today. We have great debates in this country under way about everything from health care reform to energy policy. I just can't help but feel like this one could have been handled by the first lady just as effectively, could have been handled by other representatives of the United States.

These are challenging times for our nation, and I think the American people would have rather seen this president rolling his sleeves up on a day of such heartbreaking news for working families and been here and figuring out how we can get this economy moving again.

VAN SUSTEREN: All right, well, let me bring you the other question. Taxes for people who make less than $250,000, will they go up with the health care reform bills that are currently proposed?

PENCE: Well, it's hard to see otherwise. I mean, the House bill, for instance, includes some $800 billion in new taxes, and $500 billion of that represents a surcharge on upper-income Americans, but the remainder of those taxes are taxes on small business owners, fees and fines, and -- you know, and that's obviously going to be passed along to working families.

As we follow the debate in the Senate, as well, you're starting to hear that the way they're going to get to the president's pledge that health care reform is not going to add, I think his phrase was, One dime to the deficit, is now to begin to tax all kinds of various procedures that Americans have grown accustomed to being able to receive without the sticky hand of the federal government being involved.

Look, we ought to do health care reform in this country. We ought to do something to lower the cost of health insurance, but we don't need a massive new bureaucracy because if you have this massive new bureaucracy in control, you're going to have taxes on working families and small businesses.

VAN SUSTEREN: We only have 30 seconds left, Congressman, but I'm curious, the use of the word, "surcharge" -- is that just code for tax? I mean, there are certain different ways we can, you know, package it and call these things, but basically, are the American people under $250,000 a year -- will they have to pay more, no matter what we call it?

PENCE: Look, more than half of the Americans who pay taxes in that upper-income bracket that the Democrats love to point to are actually small businesses owners filing as individuals. Small business is the engine of this economy, and if we're going to start to turn this economy around and start -- and put days like today in the past and start to see unemployment decline and jobs actually created, the last thing we want to do is raise taxes on small business owners in this country. We need to cut taxes for small business owners, working farmers, working families and -- and family farmers, and that's what Republicans are going to continue to fight to do, Greta.

VAN SUSTEREN: Congressman, thank you, sir.

PENCE: Thank you.

VAN SUSTEREN: AARP is losing members and losing fast. As many as 60,000 people have quit AARP since July. Many of them do not like President Obama's plan for health care reform, and it turns out AARP has some competition. Joining us live is Stuart Barton, president of the American Seniors Association, and John Johnson, a 15-year member of AARP who recently left the organization.

Stuart, let me go first to you. You have some torn-up cards with you?

STUART BARTON, AMERICAN SENIORS ASSOCIATION: I certainly do, Greta. This is a small sample of the cards that we've received in the past month. If you could come into my office, I'd have to bring a wheelbarrow out to show you all of the torn cards that we've received. So it's really exciting for us.

VAN SUSTEREN: So John, why did you leave AARP? What aren't they doing for you?

JOHN JOHNSON, FORMER AARP MEMBER: Greta, I joined when I was first able to, and I just never received anything, you know, per se from them. And when I first met Stuart and found out about ASA, it really is a more exciting program for us, especially on the conservative side. I have -- I feel with ASA that they are speaking for me instead of to me, as I do feel with AARP.

VAN SUSTEREN: All right, Stuart, what is it that you provide specifically to people like John that AARP does not?

BARTON: The American Seniors Association, Greta, is a more transparent fiscal conservative organization that provides similar benefits to the AARP but without the liberal agenda. And so at Americanseniors.org...

VAN SUSTEREN: Like what, though? Explain it to me because I (INAUDIBLE) like, what exactly -- I mean, why should someone join your organization and not AARP? Why are people disappointed with AARP? Give me a specific example.

BARTON: Well, here recently with the health care reform debate, Greta, you've heard the AARP support President Obama and HR-3200 and then turn around and say that they do not support it. And so there's a specific example of -- of saying one thing to one audience and another to another. So I think that it shows the hypocrisy of the AARP. With the American Seniors Association, we do what we say we're going to do, and we allow our members, like John, to have their voice in Washington, not tell Washington what we think we want them to hear.

VAN SUSTEREN: John, what has Stuart's organization done for you that's different from AARP? What makes you happy to be a member of his organization?

JOHNSON: Well, the main thing, Greta, is the fact that I feel I'm being represented by the association, instead of being told what to do by AARP. I think most of us on the conservative side of the aisle are free thinkers and can think for ourselves. We're not like sheep being led to the slaughter. And I really enjoy that about ASA. And their programs and benefits are all the same, even better in some cases, and I just happen to like them a lot better.

VAN SUSTEREN: Stuart, I only have 30 seconds left. What was your membership a year ago and what is it now?

BARTON: We had about 130,00 a year ago, and now we have 170,000 and growing. We've invited all AARP members to mail us their torn AARP cards and receive a two-for-one membership at the American Seniors Association at Americanseniors.org.

VAN SUSTEREN: John, Stuart, thank you both very much.

Content and Programming Copyright 2009 FOX News Network, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Transcription Copyright 2009 CQ Transcriptions, LLC, which takes sole responsibility for the accuracy of the transcription. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No license is granted to the user of this material except for the user's personal or internal use and, in such case, only one copy may be printed, nor shall user use any material for commercial purposes or in any fashion that may infringe upon FOX News Network, LLC'S and CQ Transcriptions, LLC's copyrights or other proprietary rights or interests in the material. This is not a legal transcript for purposes of litigation.