Playing the percentages didn't pay off for Blue Jays manager John Farrell on Friday night.
Wilson Betemit hit a go-ahead, bases-loaded single in the eighth inning and the Baltimore Orioles rallied to beat Toronto 7-5, snapping a three-game skid.
Farrell chose to have veteran left-hander Darren Oliver pitch around hot-hitting Orioles catcher Matt Wieters, loading the bases and putting the go-ahead run in scoring position for Betemit.
Toronto's second-year skipper then stuck with Oliver instead of bringing in righty Casey Janssen, knowing that the switch-hitting Betemit typically hits better from the left side than he does from the right.
"(Wieters) is one of the hottest hitters right now so obviously we go after the next guy who's not swinging as hot a bat," Oliver said.
The strategy failed when Betemit connected on Oliver's first pitch, grounding a two-run single to center.
"We probably should have faced Wieters instead of Betemit," Oliver said. "Maybe I might have had better luck."
Darren O'Day (1-0) worked one inning of relief for the win and James Johnson closed it for his third save as the Orioles opened a 10-game road trip, their longest of the season, by winning for just the sixth time in their past 35 games in Toronto — a streak that dates to 2008.
"Here, playing in our division, it was important to start this road trip off pretty well," Baltimore outfielder Adam Jones said. "We've got a 10-day road trip so to start it off with a win is a pretty good thing."
Baltimore improved to 4-4 in its past eight games at Rogers Centre.
The teams combined for seven home runs, all solo shots.
"It was home run derby out there tonight," Jones said. "A lot of balls left the ballpark."
Robert Andino, Jones and Nolan Reimold connected for the Orioles, while Edwin Encarnacion, Yunel Escobar, Kelly Johnson and Colby Rasmus went deep for the Blue Jays, who doubled their season home run total in one game.
"I liked the way we swung the bats tonight," Farrell said.
All of Toronto's homers came against Hunter, matching his career high.
"Thankfully nobody was on base for any of them," Hunter said.
Hunter also allowed four homers in an Aug. 13, 2010, start against Boston.
Baltimore trailed 5-4 to begin the eighth against reliever Jason Frasor. Reimold led off with a single and J.J. Hardy struck out before Oliver replaced Frasor. Reimold stole second and went to third when Nick Markakis reached on an infield single. Jones struck out and Wieters walked to load the bases before Betemit delivered his big hit, scoring Reimold and Markakis.
"I had a good pitch to hit," Betemit said. "He threw me a fastball right down the middle."
Reimold gave the Orioles some insurance with a homer off Janssen in the ninth, his second.
Markakis' sacrifice fly gave Baltimore a 1-0 lead in the first, but Toronto answered in the bottom half on Kelly Johnson's one-out homer.
Markakis doubled and scored on a single by Jones in the fourth, but Toronto tied it in the bottom half when Reimold missed Adam Lind's liner to left for an error, allowing Jose Bautista to score from first.
"The lights are tough," Reimold said. "I ran to where I thought it was and it ended up being a little bit in front of me. I just botched it."
The relay throw home beat Bautista, but he evaded Wieters' tag as he slid in, then reached back to touch the plate.
Baltimore reclaimed the lead on Andino's homer to center in the fifth, his first, before solo shots from Rasmus and Escobar in the bottom half, the first for each, put the Blue Jays back on top.
Blue Jays starter Brandon Morrow couldn't hold the lead through the sixth, giving up a homer to Jones, his second, but Toronto promptly answered on Encarnacion's one-out shot in the bottom half, his second, to take a 5-4 lead.
"Brandon elevated a couple of pitches that were squared up," Farrell said.
Morrow allowed four runs and six hits in seven innings. Hunter gave up five runs, four earned, and six hits in six-plus innings.
NOTES: Johnson has converted 11 straight save opportunities dating to 2011. ... Toronto placed closer Sergio Santos on the paternity list and recalled LHP Evan Crawford from Double-A New Hampshire. Santos flew home to California on Wednesday after earning the save in Toronto's 3-1 win over Boston to join his wife for the birth of their second son. He could rejoin the team as early as Saturday. ... Baltimore's Mark Reynolds, who has struggled with his defense, made his first start at DH with Betemit taking his place at 3B. ... Orioles RHP Jake Arrieta will start Monday in Chicago, pushing LHP Wei-Yin Chen back one day to Tuesday. Baltimore manager Buck Showalter said he wanted to split up lefties Chen and Brian Matusz, who starts Sunday.