Researchers: Peruvian Meteorite 'Doesn't Make Sense'

In September 2007 a fireball flew in from space and hurtled though Earth's atmosphere, smashing into the ground in Peru while awestruck witnesses watched.

It was the first time people have witnessed space debris forming an impact crater live.

• Click here to view video of the impact site.

But the witnesses' reports and the geological aftermath stunned scientists.

This meteorite seemed to have flown in much faster than scientists thought possible for an object of this kind, and it apparently survived entering Earth's atmosphere intact, rather than splintering into bits as experts thought it should have.

• Click here to visit's Space Center.

"Many people thought this was a fake," said Peter Schultz, a Brown University planetary geologist who traveled to Peru to analyze the crater. "It just didn't make sense with what we understand of collisions with this type of fragile rock. Coming through the atmosphere they get stressed so highly that they typically break apart. But this one didn't do that."

Let's go look

A few months after the impact, Schultz went to investigate the crater along with Peruvian scientists and government officials. He presented his findings Tuesday at the 39th annual Lunar and Planetary Science Conference in League City, Texas.

Schultz found fractured lines in sand grains and compressed mixtures of earth and meteorite around the 49-foot-wide crater near the village of Carancas.

These, along with widespread debris from the meteorite's crash landing, told him it landed at high speed, likely around 15,000 miles per hour at the moment of impact.

The meteorite was a common type, a chunk of silicate rock called a stony meteorite.

Usually a projectile such as this would be slowed down by the drag of Earth's atmosphere. By the time it landed, it would be traveling at the normal terminal speed of any object falling from the sky, and would probably dint a hole in the ground, but not a crater.

"Essentially Carancas threw us this high-speed curveball," Schultz told "The mystery is why it didn't slow down and how did it make it all the way to the Earth intact to form a crater? These are questions we have to resolve."

New thinking

Scientists have several hypotheses about what might have happened.

Perhaps as the meteorite hurtled through the atmosphere it melted and morphed, becoming more of an aerodynamic needle-shape that could resist stress and survive in one piece.

Plus, this shape would help it hold on to its speed, since the surface area exposed to atmospheric drag forces would be reduced.

"But the mystery is, why wouldn't all objects reshape?" Schultz said. "Maybe it requires special circumstances, like the angle of entry."

The unique event could change scientists' thinking about how meteorites act, and how other craters on Earth were formed, especially ones similar to the Carancas site, where water has since collected in the hole.

"What does this mean for other small water-filled ponds?" Schultz asked. "You just wonder how many of these have powdered remains of a stony meteorite at the bottom, something that would be difficult to find after time."

Copyright © 2008 Imaginova Corp. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.