Four Million Credit, Debit Cards Exposed in Data Breach

A security breach at an East Coast supermarket chain exposed more than 4 million card numbers and led to 1,800 cases of fraud, the Hannaford Bros. grocery chain announced Monday.

Hannaford said credit and debit card numbers were stolen during the card-authorization process and about 4.2 million unique card numbers were exposed, placing the case among the largest data breaches ever.

The breach affected all of its 165 stores in the Northeast, 106 Sweetbay stores in Florida and a smaller number of independent groceries that sell Hannaford products.

• Click here to visit's Cybersecurity Center.

The company is aware of about 1,800 cases of fraud reported so far relating to the breach. No personal data such as names, addresses or telephone numbers were divulged — just account numbers.

Hannaford became aware of the breach Feb. 27. Investigators later discovered that the data breach began on Dec. 7; it wasn't contained until March 10, said Carol Eleazer, Hannaford's vice president of marketing in Scarborough.

"We have taken aggressive steps to augment our network security capabilities," Hannaford president and CEO Ronald C. Hodge said in a statement released Monday. "Hannaford doesn't collect, know or keep any personally identifiable customer information from transactions."

The company urged its customers to monitor their credit and debit cards for unusual transactions and report any problems to authorities.

It also told customers to beware of e-mails and calls from people claiming to represent Hannaford and seeking any personal information.

The U.S. Secret Service, whose duties include investigating electronic crimes such as data breaches, confirmed it's investigating but declined to comment on the scope of the crime.

"The company did contact us, and we are investigating," said agency spokesman Malcolm Wiley.

MasterCard, the second-biggest U.S. credit card association after Visa, issued a statement before Hannaford's disclosure: "Because this incident is the subject of an ongoing law enforcement investigation, we cannot disclose additional details regarding the incident or otherwise comment at this time."

Calls to Visa were not returned.

Beth Givens, director of the San Diego-based Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, said holders of debit cards involved in the Hannaford case are most at risk of fraud.

Banks generally cover costs from fraudulent charges on credit cards, but a criminal could potentially drain a victim's bank account and leave them with the task of convincing a bank they deserve to be reimbursed.

"Any time a debit card number is exposed, the affected individuals need to be contacted immediately, and their accounts should be closed down," Givens said.

Mark Walker, an attorney for the Maine Bankers Association, said his organization sent an advisory to member banks Friday after learning of the breach.

Only a few had reported suspicious activity involving the credit and debit cards they had issued customers, Walker said.

"I had expected there would be more than we've heard of," Walker said. "But it's still too early for us to tell."

Bruce Spitzer, a spokesman for the Massachusetts Bankers Association, criticized the delay in public notification of the source of the breach.

"Visa and MasterCard have stipulated in their contracts with retailers that they will not divulge who the source is when a data breach occurs," Spitzer said. "We've been engaged in a dialogue for a couple years now about changing this rule.... Without knowing who the retailer is that caused the breach, it's hard for banks to conduct a good investigation on behalf of their consumers. And it's a problem for consumers as well, because if they know which retailer is responsible, they can rule themselves out for being at risk if they don't shop at that retailer."

Paul Stephens, of the San Diego-based consumer advocacy organization Privacy Rights Clearinghouse, said the delay in disclosure "puts consumers in a difficult position because they have no way of knowing whether their accounts may have been impacted."

Eleazer defended Hannaford's actions.

"We moved with all deliberate speed to get out to customers with information that we could have confidence in," she said. "This is a complex undertaking."

The case ranks among the largest breaches on record involving retailers, but far fewer cards were exposed than in the largest hack.

That one began in 2005 — and was disclosed last year — at TJX Cos., the Framingham, Mass.-based operator of more than 2,500 discount retail stores including T.J. Maxx and Marshalls.

TJX reported at least 45.7 million cards were exposed, while banks' court filings put the number at more than 100 million, but there has been no estimate of the total fraud.