Published April 24, 2017
Knowing Kevin Shattenkirk wasn't in their long-term plans, the St. Louis Blues traded the talented defenseman and braced for the immediate blow to their playoff hopes.
That never happened. The Blues actually got better without him.
When the Blues dealt the pending free agent at the trade deadline, they seemed to be creating a giant void on their blue line and gift-wrapping the NHL-best Washington Capitals with their deepest defense in a decade. Yet St. Louis has thrived thanks to the elevated play of captain Alex Pietrangelo and second-year defenseman Colton Parayko while Shattenkirk plays a limited, specialized role for Washington.
With Pietrangelo taking over top power-play duties, Parayko pitching in and 6-foot-4, 221-pound Robert Bortuzzo providing some bulk on the back end, the new-look Blues cruised into the second round with a 4-1 series win over Minnesota and haven't missed a beat without Shattenkirk.
"We're bigger, all six guys are big men, and now we have two players that play with a little more nasty than we had when we had five guys that played one way and sort of Joel Edmundson doing the majority of the physical work," general manager Doug Armstrong said. "Now we have two players that are bringing some of that physical play."
Armstrong won't mince words: He didn't trade Shattenkirk to shake things up. He dealt the 28-year-old for picks and young forward Zach Sanford because there was no chance of re-signing him this summer.
On the flip side, Capitals general manager Brian MacLellan only got involved in the bidding when it became clear Shattenkirk was a rental and not long-term commitment.
After being a top-four defenseman in St. Louis, Shattenkirk is a third-pairing player and power-play specialist for Washington. He was among the team leaders in overall minutes in Games 1 and 2 before having his ice time slashed to a career playoff low 12:54 in Game 4 and ranking fifth or six on the Capitals' blue line the remainder of their first round series against Toronto.
Shattenkirk said he's fine with that and doesn't need an explanation from coach Barry Trotz, who called ice time "irrelevant" to players this time of year. He's still on the top power-play unit, is counted on to feed Alex Ovechkin the puck from the point in crucial situations and leads Capitals defensemen with three points.
But he's not in St. Louis anymore.
"I do think that we roll our D pairings a little bit more here, and everyone gets to play a regular shift for the most part," Shattenkirk said. "St. Louis, we were a little more reliant on our top two guys of playing the big-time minutes, and then power plays and penalty kills kind of determined where the rest of us played more or played less."
Saying so long to Shattenkirk shifted the big-time minutes on the right side to Pietrangelo and Parayko. Ranked 26th among NHL defensemen in points and 11th in ice time before the Shattenkirk trade, Pietrangelo was second with 18 points and fourth at 26:35 a game after it.
Thrown into tougher situations than his first playoffs last season, Parayko has grown up fast without Shattenkirk around.
"It's good for me," the 23-year-old said as the Blues prepared to face the Nashville Predators. "I think that's the best way to do it, get in there and learn from experience."
Even the experienced Blues defensemen like Jay Bouwmeester and Carl Gunnarsson have thrived since the trade. Part of it is the structure of Mike Yeo, who replaced Ken Hitchcock as coach in early February, but the defensive improvements have made up for the loss of Shattenkirk's offensive talent that will earn him a big contract somewhere July 1.
"Defensively I think we're sound as ever," Gunnarsson said. "Without Shatty I think we were lacking, especially the first couple games (of the playoffs), some offense. He was huge on the power play for us and that poise with the puck. Some guys stepped up."
Yeo said his team being in must-win mode from the deadline on helped spur a late-season run that allowed them to also eliminate the Wild in five games. And if the Blues need an offensive spark from a right-handed-shooting first-round pick, they can plug 23-year-old Jordan Schmaltz into their lineup.
In Washington, Shattenkirk is glad to be on a Stanley Cup contender readying for a second-round matchup against the defending-champion Pittsburgh Penguins. He doesn't mind St. Louis enjoying success without him.
"When I was there this year, we knew we had that capability. For whatever reason we just couldn't get to our full potential," Shattenkirk said. "They were a group that believed that they could play this way all year, and they're doing it at the right time."
AP freelance writer Nate Latsch in St. Louis contributed.
More AP NHL: https://www.apnews.com/tag/NHLhockey
Follow Hockey Writer Stephen Whyno on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/SWhyno