By Sam Dorman
Published April 24, 2019
MSNBC anchor Stephanie Ruhle raised eyebrows Wednesday with a question she posed to Melinda Gates, asking if private philanthropy is enough or if the United States should revisit the idea of free-market capitalism.
She posed the question on her show "Velshi & Ruhle" to Gates, co-founder of the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, after Gates promoted a balance between private charity and taxing the wealthy. Ruhle seemed to worry that philanthropy could "disappear" while taxes didn't.
Gates, in response, reiterated that the U.S. needed a combination of private charity and government action. "It's up to government to scale up those things that work. As Warren [Buffet] calls them, the gaps in capitalism that doesn't always serve all low-income people [...] It's always up to government to scale up health and education, for instance."
"In this society, individuals, more today than ever, have been able to amass billions of dollars in personal wealth," Ruhle said in response. "Do we need to revisit capitalism, seeing that the disparity between the rich and the poor has become so exaggerated?" she asked.
Gates maintained that while inequality shouldn't exist in the U.S., capitalism has remained the best economic system and should be tempered by taxes and regulation.
Ruhle, for her part, has been pushing the question over capitalism and socialism on Twitter.
"More and more billionaires are raising concerns over the widening income inequality gap in this country. Is it sparking a capitalism crisis?" she asked on Monday.