Menu
Home

World

2-week Chinese incursion into Indian territory leaves Asian powerhouses on verge of crisis

  • 114716c09ce0990e300f6a70670067e9.jpg

    Indian supporters of Akhil Bharatiya Vidhyarthi Parishad (ABVP) or All India Student Council hold placards and shouts slogans against the alleged incursion by Chinese troops into Indian territory, during a protest in Ahmadabad, India, Wednesday, May 1, 2013. India said around 50 Chinese troops crossed the de facto border between the countries and went 19 kilometers (12 miles) into Indian territory on April 15 and are camping in tents in Ladakh in the eastern part of Indian-administered Kashmir. (AP Photo/Ajit Solanki)The Associated Press

  • 1f9aa6189cfc9a0e300f6a706700da76.jpg

    Indian protesters of right wing Shiv Sena party burn an effigy with photographs of India Defense Minister A.K.Antony, left, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, center and Home Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde during a protest against the alleged incursion by Chinese troops into Indian territory in New Delhi, India, Wednesday, May 1, 2013. India said Chinese troops crossed the de facto border between the countries and went 10 kilometers (six miles) into Indian territory on April 15. About 50 Chinese soldiers were camping in tents Kashmir's Ladakh region. (AP Photo /Manish Swarup)The Associated Press

  • 748abeaf9cf79a0e300f6a706700c620.jpg

    Indian protesters shout slogans against the alleged incursion by Chinese troops into Indian territory, during a protest in New Delhi, India, Wednesday, May 1, 2013. India says Chinese troops crossed the de facto border between the countries and went 10 kilometers (six miles) into Indian territory on April 15. About 50 Chinese soldiers pitched tents and are camping in Daulat Beg Oldi in the Ladakh region of eastern Kashmir. The placard at right in Hindi reads: "Show some courage against China, the whole country is ready." (AP Photo /Manish Swarup)The Associated Press

  • 0bd1c5099d059a0e300f6a7067004f94.jpg

    Indian protestors of right wing Shiv Sena party burn an effigy and shout slogans against the alleged incursion by Chinese troops into Indian territory, during a protest in New Delhi, India, Wednesday, May 1, 2013. India says Chinese troops crossed the de facto border between the countries and went 10 kilometers (six miles) into Indian territory on April 15. About 50 Chinese soldiers are camping in tents Kashmir's Ladakh region. (AP Photo /Manish Swarup)The Associated Press

  • f1e4039e9cfd9a0e300f6a706700b681.jpg

    Indian protesters of right wing Shiv Sena party burn an effigy with photographs of India Defense Minister A.K.Antony, left, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, center and Home Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde during a protest against the alleged incursion by Chinese troops into Indian territory, in New Delhi, India, Wednesday, May 1, 2013. India said Chinese troops crossed the de facto border between the countries and went 10 kilometers (six miles) into Indian territory on April 15. About 50 Chinese soldiers were camping in tents Kashmir's Ladakh region. (AP Photo /Manish Swarup)The Associated Press

The platoon of Chinese soldiers slipped across the boundary into India in the middle of the night, according to Indian officials. They were ferried across the bitterly cold moonscape in Chinese army vehicles, then got out to traverse a dry creek bed with a helicopter hovering overhead for protection.

They finally reached their destination and pitched a tent in the barren Depsang Valley in the Ladakh region, a symbolic claim of sovereignty deep inside Indian-held territory. So stealthy was the operation that India did not discover the incursion until a day later, Indian officials said.

China denies any incursion, but Indian officials say that for two weeks, the soldiers have refused to move back over the so-called Line of Actual Control that divides Indian-ruled territory from Chinese-run land, leaving the government on the verge of a crisis with its powerful northeastern neighbor.

Indian officials fear that if they react with force, the face-off could escalate into a battle with the feared People's Liberation Army. But doing nothing would leave a Chinese outpost deep in territory India has ruled since independence.

"If they have come 19 kilometers into India, it is not a minor LAC violation. It is a deliberate military operation. And even as India protests, more tents have come up," said Sujit Dutta, a China specialist at the Jamia Milia Islamia university in New Delhi.

"Clearly, the Chinese are testing India to see how far they can go," he said.

That is not China's stated view.

"China strictly complies with the treaty and documents on maintaining peace and stability in the border region between India and China," Chinese Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said last week.

"The Chinese patrol troops did not go across the Line of Actual Control, not by even one step," she said.

Local army commanders from both sides have held three meetings over the crisis, according to Indian officials. India's foreign secretary called in the Chinese ambassador to register a strong protest. Yet the troops did not move, and even pitched a second tent, Indian officials said.

The timing of the crisis, weeks before Chinese Premier Li Keqiang is to visit India, has surprised many here. The Chinese leader's decision to make India his first trip abroad since taking office two months ago had been seen as an important gesture toward strengthening ties between rival powers that have longstanding border disputes but also growing trade relations.

Manoj Joshi, a defense analyst at the New Delhi-based Observer Research Foundation, said the timing of the incursion raises questions about "whether there is infighting within the Chinese leadership, or whether someone is trying to upstage Li."

India's External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid said Wednesday that while he had no plans to cancel a trip to Beijing next week to prepare for Li's visit, the government could reconsider in the coming week.

"A week is a long time in politics," he told reporters.

Indian politicians accused the scandal-plagued government of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh of floundering in fear before China.

"China realizes that India has a weak government, and a prime minister who is powerless," said Yashwant Sinha, a former foreign minister from the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party.

He demanded a stronger response. "A bully will back off the moment it realizes that it's dealing with a country which will not submit to its will," Sinha said.

Former Defense Minister Mulayam Singh Yadav called the government "cowardly and incompetent." He warned that China was trying to annex more territory to add to the spoils it took following its victory over India in a brief 1962 border war.

Defense Minister A.K. Antony countered that India is "united in its commitment to take every possible step to safeguard our interests."

Supporters of the right-wing Shiv Sena party burned effigies of Singh, Antony and other top officials Wednesday, demanding India retaliate by barring Chinese imports.

China is India's biggest trading partner, with bilateral trade, heavily skewed in China's favor, crossing $75 billion in 2011.

Analysts feel linking a troop withdrawal to continued trade could work.

"The Chinese have to learn that such aggression cannot be delinked from trade," said Dutta.

Though the two countries have held 15 rounds of talks, their border disputes remain unresolved. India says China is occupying 38,000 square kilometers (15,000 square miles) in the Aksai Chin plateau in the western Himalayas, while China claims around 90,000 square kilometers (35,000 square miles) in India's northeastern state of Arunachal Pradesh.

Analysts said they were baffled by Beijing's motives, since its actions could force India to move closer to Beijing's biggest rival, the United States.

"The Chinese for some reason don't seem able to see that," said Joshi.

China's aggressive posture could also force India to accelerate its own military modernization program, analysts said.

The stand-off may eventually be resolved diplomatically, "but what it really shows is the PLA's contempt for our military capability," former Indian navy chief, Sushil Kumar, wrote in The Indian Express newspaper.

It could also push the government to agree to the army's longstanding demand to create its own strike corps on the border.

"By needling the Indians, they are helping us to accelerate our modernization," Joshi said.