Published March 05, 2012
NEW HAVEN, Conn. – Kennedy cousin Michael Skakel has lost his bid for a reduction in his prison sentence of 20 years to life for the 1975 beating death of a teenage neighbor.
A three-judge panel rejected Skakel's request in a decision obtained Monday by The Associated Press. The panel said there was nothing inappropriate or disproportionate about the sentence.
The panel quoted the sentencing court calling the crime serious, the effect on the victim and her family "supreme" and saying Skakel has been living a lie for 25 years.
A prosecutor and Skakel's attorney, Hubert Santos, declined to comment.
Skakel, 51, is a nephew of Robert F. Kennedy's widow, Ethel Kennedy.
Skakel was sentenced in 2002 after he was convicted of bludgeoning 15-year-old Martha Moxley to death with a golf club in wealthy Greenwich. Santos argued in Middletown Superior Court in January that the sentence was excessive. Santos repeated his claim, which has been rejected by other state courts, that Skakel should have been tried in juvenile court, where the maximum sentence for a murder conviction would have been four years.
Skakel insisted on his innocence at the hearing.
"Give me a polygraph," Skakel told the judges. "I've passed three sodium pentathol tests. I don't know what else to say."
Skakel's lawyers didn't ask for a specific sentence reduction.
Members of both the Skakel and Moxley families were in the courtroom as Skakel said he prayed for Moxley's mother, Dorthy Moxley every day.
"I told Mrs. Moxley if I killed Martha I would take responsibility for it," Skakel said. "I didn't commit this crime."
Dorthy Moxley and her son, John, both called Skakel's words "hollow" and said he got the prison sentence he deserved.
"Michael belongs in jail for the rest of his life," John Moxley told the judges.
Speaking after the hearing in January, Dorthy and John Moxley said that they were upset that the case keeps returning to court, adding that they have to relive Martha's killing every time.
Dorthy Moxley said Monday she was pleased the panel upheld Skakel's sentence.
"I have no doubt Michael was the one who murdered Martha," she said. "I really would like to know why it happened."
The state Supreme Court ruled in 2010 against Skakel's bid for a new trial, saying a claim implicating two other men in the killing wasn't credible. The U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the case. Skakel has a habeas corpus appeal pending in state courts, alleging his trial attorney, Michael Sherman, did a bad job.
Martha Moxley was killed when both she and Skakel were 15 years old. Skakel was arrested in 2000.
Prosecutor Susann Gill said if Skakel was arrested when he was a teenager, his case could have been transferred to adult court and he would have faced the same prison sentence he is now serving.
Gill told Judges Gary White, Joan Alexander and Brian Fischer that the judge who sentenced Skakel considered arguments similar to those made by Skakel's lawyers when he imposed the punishment in 2002. She said the sentence Skakel received was appropriate.
"He should have come forward and taken responsibility for this crime in 1975," Gill said.
Skakel also talked about his 13-year-old son during his speech, and how "being in prison it's hard to be a father."
John Moxley said Skakel was using his son as a "shield" in his arguments.
Skakel's brother, Stephen, said outside the courthouse that his family fully supports his brother and believes he is innocent.