Has Christian America Come to an End?

By Mark Driscoll
Pastor, Mars Hill Church

Has Christian America come to an end? That question has been hotly debated since Newsweek published their recent feature story reporting that the number of Americans claiming no religious affiliation has nearly doubled since 1990. Additionally, the percentage of self-identified Christians has dropped ten points in the past two decades.

As an evangelical pastor with one of America’s fastest-growing churches in one of its least churched cities, I do not find the report surprising or discouraging. Newsweek missed the subtle — but vital — difference between Christian America and Christendom America.

Christian America is comprised of those people who have had a truly transforming experience with Jesus Christ and are living new lives as practicing Christians. Experts such as sociologist Bradford Wilcox at the University of Virginia have well documented the fact that those who practice Christian faith by reading their Bibles regularly, attending church, praying, and so forth are far less likely to engage in acts such as adultery, divorce, substance abuse, and the like.
Christendom America is comprised of those people who have not had a truly transforming experience with Jesus Christ and are living lives virtually indistinguishable from those who are non-Christians. The confusion is that it was common in Christendom for people who did not practice Christianity to profess Christianity. This was often done for social reasons, such as living in a culture that expected church affiliation, being born into a religious tradition and assuming it was simply part of one’s identity (like a cultural or racial connection), or personally, socially, and vocationally benefitting from being connected, even loosely, to a church or denomination. Researchers such as George Barna have documented the fact that, as Jesus himself said, not everyone who says he or she is a Christian is in fact one.

Subsequently, the Newsweek report simply confirms the fact that, just as Christendom has died in Europe and the major American cities, it is now dying in the suburban and rural areas of America as well. With the social benefits of professing to be a Christian no longer in place and the social stigma of not professing to be a Christian now lifted, those who were part of Christendom America are simply no longer pretending to be part of Christian America.
Since those who professed faith but did not practice faith were confusing to account for, this is actually a good thing. Now, it is more likely that if someone is a Christian or non-Christian, he or she will state so plainly.

Therefore, the number of Christians has likely not diminished as much as has been reported, but rather we are seeing an increasingly accurate accounting of actual Christian America. The ARIS study confirmed this by saying that the number of people who claimed to be Christians decreased, while the number of people who claimed to be evangelical increased. This fact is not discouraging, but rather clarifying.

Additionally, Christianity has always reformed itself around major technological innovations. Just as the printing press enabled the Protestant Reformation, so too the Internet and video technology are changing how ministry is done. Networks are currently overtaking denominations as the gathering place for innovative young leaders, megachurches are using video to become multi-site, and young pastors are increasingly moving into cities to plant churches. Our own church planting network Acts 29, for example, now has 250 church plants and is on pace to be at one thousand churches in roughly seven years. We are not alone. As the churches and ministry forms of Christendom are dying, new churches, networks, and ministry forms are replacing them with great passion, as the ARIS study confirms. Therefore, while it is too early to tell, we may in fact simply be living in the time between the times of Christendom and post-Christendom America, with Christian America getting more innovative and devoted than ever and poised to see many more lives changed by Jesus Christ.

There is one thing that is concerning, namely the loss of the residue of some aspects of Protestant morality. For example, as authority is less and less respected, and social order becomes more difficult to maintain, and sexual sin increases the number of addicts and abuse victims (as we are dealing with by the thousands in our church), the result will be a culture that is less beneficial for Christians and non-Christians alike. This is because, although being good does not save you, insofar as the culture is concerned, it is still good. Proceeding forward, the distinctions in lifestyle between Christian America and non-Christian America will become increasingly stark and will require great service by the church in the areas of mercy and justice to help people damaged by a Christless culture.

Mark Driscoll is the founding pastor of Mars Hill Church in Seattle (www.MarsHillChurch.org), President of the Acts 29 Church Planting Network (www.acts29network.org), and President of www.TheResurgence.com.

FOX Fans wrote in. Here's what some of you had to say:

+ Erv Niehaus:
...Some people attest to being "Christian" because of church membership and such. Just attending a so called "Christian" church does not make you a "Christian". The same as being born in a garage doesn't make you a Chevrolet. Church membership might be on the decline in some liberal denominations, but the truly conservative, bible based denominations will continue to grow and thrive.

+ Fritz Kocher / Pflugerville, TX
I don’t think so, and I see just the opposite here in Central Texas.

+ John Mattei / Plainsboro, NJ
Christianity is thriving ~ look at the battle to keep Christ in Christmas and other institutions that are trying to remove religious elements and tones from displays and demonstrations. Christians are finally waging the war that will be heard. ND students took the humble way of the cross this past weekend in a prayer vigil that has been broadcast throughout the country. These events are forcing the public to form their own opinion, sometimes on the spot. 51% of Americans now support the pro-life movement. This is a tremendous accomplishment in such a secular driven culture.

+ Debbie / Strongsville, Ohio

I think you can be a good Christian and not belong to a church. You need to be "Christ" like. Who is to say that this church or that church is somewhere you have to belong to be a Christian. I take offense to being classified as Christendom. Who made Mark Driscoll the authority on who is a Christian and who just thinks they are? Almost everyday in some town you can read a story about a church taking advantage of its congregation. I give charity but to people of my choice, and I give where I know it is being used to really help people in need.

+ Rod Sexton
I agree with his assessment. I will add that the "majority" will never accept true, theological Christianity. Sadly, only a small percntage of humanity will enter eternity with Christ.

+ Butch
It appears that, while there are still many millions of true Christian believers in our Nation, that the Nation itself has become a secular country, much like the Europeans.

Consequently, we can no longer expect God's blessings on us, instead we may as well strike the tent, as we are destine to become, economically, socially and morally, another France or Britain - third-rate countries with nothing to boast about but a past that we squandered away through our own ignorance and evil.

Do you agree with Pastor Mark's take on Christian America? Let us know what you think by sending us an email ! We'll post your comments right here as we get them.

Click here for MORE articles with perspective!