YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio – Police arrested a prisoner at a house where he holed up Monday with two hostages after overpowering a guard in a hospital, carjacking a vehicle and robbing two banks, authorities said.
He had two female hostages, but one woman went out a second-story window and jumped from a porch roof, Hilliard Chief Rodney Garnett said. She was taken to a hospital but not seriously injured, he said.
Police identified the woman who fled as Geneva Erb, 45, of Hilliard. The other hostage was identified as Karen Zappitelli, 42, of Columbus. Erb is an employee of an accounting business operated out of the home. A sign on the building had the name John Zappitelli
Telephone messages were left for Karen and John Zappitelli. No one answered the door when a reporter knocked. No listing could be found for Erb.
Fitzmorris was wearing a white shirt when police led him out of the house with his hands cuffed behind his back. He was taken away in a van surrounded by police motorcycles and was being held at the Franklin County Jail. No one was injured when Fitzmorris was arrested.
Fitzmorris, 34, was believed to have escaped hours earlier on foot from St. Elizabeth Health Center in Youngstown with the guard's gun and uniform. Police believe he carjacked a vehicle and headed toward Columbus, robbing two banks in central Ohio before going into the house in Hilliard, about 150 miles southwest of Youngstown.
Officers saw Fitzmorris driving on a freeway west of Columbus and attempted to pull him over but were unsuccessful. He wrecked the car at an intersection in Hilliard near the house where the women were taken hostage, Columbus police said.
TV footage showed a man breaking into the house after abandoning a car nearby. A woman later climbed out a second-story window and dropped to the ground as police arrived.
Mary Veach said she and a friend were riding motorcycles nearby before the standoff when they noticed a car speeding past them, apparently being pursued.
"There were three cop cars behind and then 12 cop cars," Veach said. "I'm really scared. What's so scary is that we were right behind the house."
Fitzmorris had been held since February at the Northeast Ohio Correction Center in Youngstown for the U.S. Marshals Service, according to Corrections Corporation of America. The company, which runs the prison, said he was awaiting sentencing on a federal conviction for cocaine possession and intent to distribute cocaine.
Fitzmorris was taken to the hospital Saturday with a medical condition that was not life-threatening, Corrections Corporation spokeswoman Louise Grant said from the company's headquarters in Nashville, Tenn.
Fitzmorris was being observed in his room Monday morning when the confrontation occurred, and he ordered the guard to give up his pants, shirt, jacket and cap, Grant said.
Two hospital workers, the guard and three other prison officers were held briefly in a hospital room during the escape, but no one was injured, authorities said.
Tina Creighton, a spokeswoman for St. Elizabeth hospital, said authorities searched the block-long complex for Fitzmorris, room by room, for several hours. The 400 patients would have noticed increased security, but no care was interrupted, she said.