DES MOINES, Iowa – Two state laws that prohibit misuse and desecration of an American flag are unenforceable and unconstitutional, a federal judge has ruled.
U.S. District Judge Robert W. Pratt said Tuesday that the Iowa laws violate a due process clause in the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Iowa brought a lawsuit on behalf of a man charged with a misdemeanor for flying a flag upside down and writing on it and another man also charged with flying a flag upside down. It declared the ruling a victory.
"Today should mark the end of government misuse of these laws to intimidate and harass those who disagree with government policies," said Ben Stone, ACLU of Iowa executive director, in a statement.
Kathy Nees, state program director for the American Legion of Iowa, said the ruling will upset many veterans and others who have fought for a federal constitutional amendment to ban flag desecration.
"I think it's definitely going the wrong direction and sending the wrong message," she said.
Scott Wayne Roe of Ottumwa displayed a U.S. flag upside down on June 4, 2006, and wrote "Corruption of Blood" across it, saying he was protesting city ordinances and how they were enforced. He was charged with a misdemeanor, but the charge was dismissed.
Dale Klyn of Corydon displayed his flag upside down to protest what he called an unfair loss in a bankruptcy case and to support a campaign for mental health care services for veterans. His case was also dismissed.
Pratt struck down a portion of the state's disorderly conduct code, which makes it a simple misdemeanor to "knowingly and publicly use the flag as to show disrespect for the flag as a symbol of the United States," and a state code that prohibits desecration of the flag.
The judge rejected an assertion that the laws also violated the First Amendment protection of free speech.