CBS Producer: Truth Irrelevant

Friday, October 01, 2004

The latest from the Political Grapevine:

CBS Producer: Truth Irrelevant

CBS (search) is defending its story on Beverly Cocco of Philadelphia, whom CBS said was an ordinary parent, "petrified" that her sons could be forced into the military after receiving mass e-mails saying a draft was pending. CBS failed to mention that the Selective Service has declared it has no plans to conduct a draft, that those e-mails were debunked long ago, and that Ms. Cocco heads a group called "Parents Against the Draft."

Well, CBS correspondent Richard Schlesinger, who reported the piece, insists that rumors of a draft, "[have] gotten people all riled up" and "Whether or not there's any reality to [them] is almost besides the point." Schlesinger's producer goes even further, telling the blog INDC Journal, "the truth of the [mass] e-mails were absolutely irrelevant."

Related

Model of "Scrupulous Accuracy & Fairness"?

Meanwhile, the Wall Street Journal (search) is standing by one of its reporters, calling her a, "model of intelligence and courageous reporting, and scrupulous accuracy and fairness" after a private e-mail she wrote denouncing the war in Iraq ended up on the Internet.

In the e-mail, Baghdad correspondent Farnaz Fassihi said, "Despite President Bush's rosy assessment, Iraq remains a disaster. ... [the] Iraqi government doesn't control most Iraqi cities. ... The situation, basically, [is] a raging barbaric guerilla war.”

Wall Street Journal Editor Paul Steiger, however, insists, "Ms. Fassihi's private opinions have in no way distorted her coverage."

Guilty by Association Grounds for Suspension?

A student at Salem High School (search) in Rockland County, Georgia, has been suspended for an entire week of school for violating school policy that prohibits smoking or possessing smoking paraphernalia on campus.

Thing is, according to WXIA-TV, even the school admits it's not certain 17-year-old Amanda Bates ever did either one of those. The school insists Bates smelled like smoke, and, "we assume if you smell strongly of smoke, you've been smoking."

Bates, however, says she's not a smoker, and her father says, if anything, she was hanging out with people who were smoking. He has written the school board for an apology.

Monument Plans Muzzled

The city of Nelson, British Columbia, has blocked plans for a monument in the city to honor the, "courageous legacy" of U.S. draft-dodgers who fled to Canada during the Vietnam War and the current war in Iraq.

The Nelson City Council yesterday passed a resolution requiring any memorial being built on public land to have, "widespread community support." And the council determined that, the [draft-dodger] monument does not meet this standard."

– FOX News' Michael Levine contributed to this report

See Political Grapevine Archive

ADVERTISEMENT

FOX NEWS VIDEOS



uASK|uREPORT

INTERVIEW

Blog Postings


  • Lies, spies and .summits
    Seven Democratic members of the Intelligence Committee wrote CIA director Leon Panetta a letter to ask him to “publicly correct” a statement he made saying that it is not ” the policy or practice of the agency to mislead Congress.” The Democrats say Panetta told Congress that senior CIA officials concealed actions and misled lawmakers [...]

    read post
  • Stimulus the sequel, public option, Palin 2012??, and .the direction of media coverage
    In an interview with Fox News, President Obama said a second stimuluscould still be an option—Major Garrett sat down with the President today in Moscow. President Obama said that he was aware that given the economic crisis recovery would prove to be difficult no matter what, but that unemployment was nearing 10% and he was [...]

    read post
  • Agreements, protests turned deadly andcomedian turned politican (finally)
    President Obama met with Russian President Dmitry Medvedev today in Moscow and both menpledged they were on a path to “reset” ties between the United States and Russia. The two leaders signed a statement to reduceeach country’snuclear arsenals. President Obama and President Medvedev held a joint news conference in which Medvedev said his talks with [...]

    read post
twitter
ADVERTISEMENT