What if Buster Posey knew?
What if Giants reliever Hunter Strickland told Posey that he was going to drill the Nationals Bryce Harper and that Posey should not intervene if Harper charged the mound, not try to prevent a fight?
A coach with another club reached out to me and relayed that theory after I posted my original column on Posey late Monday night, a column that examined the catchers decision to stand frozen behind the plate as Harper went after Strickland.
I then contacted a source with knowledge of the situation, and he said that the rival coachs theory was correct. Posey, the source said, was drawing unfair criticism for failing to defend his teammate when in reality he was adhering to his teammates -- or perhaps manager Bruce Bochys -- wishes.
If all that is true, not all of the Giants were aware of it. One Giant, when I asked if the players were OK with Posey not standing up for Strickland, seemed torn by Poseys actions, unsure of what to think. He made no mention of any agreement between the two.
I dont know, he said, I really dont know.
The Giants could never acknowledge Poseys understanding with Strickland, if indeed there was such an understanding, for it would be tantamount to admitting intent. Strickland, who had not hit a batter all season and just four in his 156-game career prior to Monday, offered the usual explanation afterward, telling reporters that he was only trying to pitch inside.
Few will believe that -- those who know Strickland were not surprised that he wanted to settle a score with Harper for the two mammoth home runs that the Nationals slugger hit off him in the 2014 Division Series. And perhaps few will believe that Posey was a willing accomplice to an incident that effectively left him open to retaliation in the eye-for-an-eye world of baseball justice -- if my best player gets hit, then so does yours.
So many questions.
Posey, assuming he knew of Stricklands intentions, probably could not have talked him out of hitting Harper, not when the reliever seemingly was hellbent on unleashing more than 2 years of anger. But Posey at least could have done a better acting job -- running after Harper, even halfheartedly -- instead of remaining motionless.
The other possibility, of course, is that Posey felt no obligation to defend the indefensible.
My initial thought, in fact, was that Posey was the sanest man on the field. Strickland was foolish to act on a grudge that did not diminish even with the Giants triumph in the 2014 World Series. Harper, who was hit on the hip, not anywhere near the head, could have just laughed at Strickland on his way to first base -- though that is easy for a casual observer to say; its different, always different, in the heat of the moment.
The idea of Posey disavowing Strickland evokes the recent memory of Dustin Pedroias it wasnt me explanation to Manny Machado after the Red Soxs Matt Barnes threw at Machados head. Each of these on-field incidents, though, is different. The Pedroia-Machado exchange happened after the fact. Poseys Atlas Shrugged moment occurred in real time.
Brian Gorman, the plate umpire, reached the mound much quicker than Posey, who stood at his position for a good five seconds before finally moving. Posey told reporters that his recent concussions were not the reason for his inaction, but acknowledged the risk of injury, saying, Those were some big guys tumbling around. (Michael) Morse was in there. As big as he is, he was getting knocked around like a pinball.
Many fans, reporters and even some in the game believe that all of this needs to stop, that pitchers need to stop throwing at hitters, that the risk of injury -- either from the ball that is thrown or any subsequent brawl -- is simply too great. But a good number of players, perhaps even a majority, would oppose a ban on such conduct, believing that they need an outlet to police themselves.
Its easy to say those players are wrong, just as its easy to say that some were wrong to oppose new rules that were designed to enhance safety at home plate and at second base. Major League Baseball needs to be sensitive to player concerns, understand that the game cannot be completely legislated from Park Avenue. But as Ive written before, if players are going to apply unwritten rules, then at least execute them properly -- or maybe lose the privilege, once and for all.
Strickland aimed his pitch at the right part of Harpers body; the problem was, he had no good reason to hit Harper in the first place, and put Posey in jeopardy if the Nationals decide to retaliate in kind. So the relievers act, too, was a distortion of the unwritten rules. And Strickland, even after triggering the ugliness, would not calm down. It took three Giants -- Hunter Pence, George Kontos and Mac Williamson -- to drag the pitcher into the dugout.
The Giants, winners of three World Series between 2010 and 14, are in unfamiliar territory -- nine games under .500, 11 games out of first place. Posey twice has been caught on camera expressing his frustration with first baseman Brandon Belt. And perhaps Mondays madness was, in some ways, another sign of the teams overall frustration, though Strickland probably does not deserve such a sympathetic view.
Posey is the Giants franchise player, one of the games great models. Perhaps well never know why he reacted the way he did. But the questions will linger, whether he was a party to a teammates retaliation or a conscientious objector.