Provocative Pictures

" I'm telling quarterback concession on the docket today provocative pictures of celebrity offspring sparking a legal war and -- Twitter war in Tinseltown. Revealing photos of -- fifteen year old daughter Tallulah. Posted on Hollywood gossip blogger Perez Hilton's website yet he actually linked to the this is not. The actual snapshot but it is a recent snapshot of Tallulah. Can see she's in her teenage years here she's got a short -- on but nothing offensive. The photos that they he links to different story. Her rear end was slightly exposed in a pair of -- short shorts. -- it was one of her address that was very low cut. So Perez Hilton calls attention to these photos and questions to -- per the parenting skills -- the process. Now mrs. Ashton Kutcher. Threatening to take the flamboyant -- to court calling him a creep and a pervert and saying he is actually promoting. Child pornography. But is that right he's threatening to -- losses. Let's ask our panel Fox's legal analyst Mercedes -- And defense attorney David Wolf good morning panel and making good morning Megyn -- do this for S Hilton is just -- the center of controversy. Look he linked to the photos they are not big they're not they don't reveal nudity. But the one of the fifteen year old bottom clearly shows the bottom of her bottom I read that the shorts -- way too short. And then you can see the top of her top if you will in another photo so I ask you David is that child pornography."

" Yeah Megan I think what -- Perez Hilton. California law does apply to bloggers. They what what you -- children's video on television. Or whether you put their pictures on blogs or newspapers. Number one you better get their parents' permission first he. Clearly didn't have that year the parents objected to this vehemently. And we -- air -- and it -- words directing people to the particular body parts that you're trying to directive to elect did in this case. You want to repeat those words but that's what he did. I mean you are way over -- they get I think there's a civil action possibly for intentional infliction of emotional distress and possibly invasion of privacy and -- that they want. I researched the criminal law on this too as well these photos come very close border on lewd photos to the -- where there -- criminal violation."

" You're probably all agree our tastes okay I thought yeah -- hire no absolutely -- listen Perez Hilton might be the queen of mean outing causing it celebrities. And -- spewing forth venom. Better than a planet -- but he's not -- chopper not -- did nothing wrong these are exactly the cute instead in the beginning making these are public. Photos he's not -- the bush is taking these photos -- Tallulah he's not doing anything like that yes. She's -- very very short shorts but that's -- public photo taken by the paparazzi. He just happened to have that photo on his website this is promoting child -- not to read this is not a naked picture to look this is nothing even took. He's a public. --"

" And moreover the thing is it you know -- show on this program obviously but the thing that the photo the -- photo shows her hugging Bruce Willis who's -- dad she's the offspring of Bruce Bruce Willis and anymore. And Uga senior from from the back -- you to see the bottom of her rear end. It is nothing more than you would see if she were wearing a bikini. On the beach a bikini shots the other one show us your address that is a low will be cut this is -- on screen left -- little younger. This the I -- sort of V necked dress David which just which shows the top of her bosom but that is something you see it. Everywhere in this country how -- child pornography."

" Well they get personal number one different rules do apply to -- you're talking about publishing these are proposed and make it you have all Golf Channel -- so -- for the purpose of that well -- stimulation. What -- is all about context to what he does but he showed a closeup of her rear end and get the pat -- all right let my -- Absolutely not but -- the context in which they're published. These zooming in on it and the word next to it that may apply to the store per -- interest or sexual interest of some people and that's where he gets in trouble there's no particular literary."

" Aren't just did is we just -- no it's not at all driver bottom he writes be a blank -- word and his driver -- he -- the be 00 -- Next right and an amber but our cities let me ask you because he says look now he's just not child pornography but you -- accusing me of being -- port AdAware. Is defamation that -- to you he brought his lawyer into to see the case."

" Oh I think so absolutely if you -- my child pornographer. That is doing this on the air that is deathly defamation and not only the defamation it's -- perceive that means that he -- need to go out there and -- people and say -- because to -- more call me child pornographer head his damaged my reputation he can actually go to court and say number one get an injunction to stop any more from saying this because apparently he's -- this. Faster than we -- tight. All across the nation -- millions of folks looking at a and number two I don't have to prove damages because the minute she started -- colony child pornographer and peddling child pornography that's enough to say that that is. -- plummeting my reputation."

" I don't know about that because I guess you could say that it's her opinion and she's certainly wants the photos. Taken down but they're not -- he just leave them in any that we got to leave it that Mercedes and David thank you so much for your insights -- one final word for our viewers -- the law legally this does not appear to be child pornography. Moreover it's not appear to be Perez -- fault. Should he have linked to these photos and -- them off course not what do you expect from this guy but whose fault is it that they exist in the first place. A parent's job is to manager her child. To set limits and hold her responsible when she crosses the line whether -- make up or outfits or inappropriate behavior to -- more should consider getting tough. -- with Paris Hilton but with her own fifteen year old."