Updated November 16, 2009
Obama Draws Fire for Bow to Japanese Emperor
FOXNews.com
A photograph shows President Obama bent at a nearly 90-degree angle while shaking the hand of Japanese Emperor Akihito.
The president bows as he is greeted by Japanese Emperor Akihito and Empress Michiko as he arrives at the Imperial Palace in Tokyo (AP Photo)
President Obama's deep bow to Japanese Emperor Akihito on Saturday may not have violated any official protocol, but critics of the presidential act of deference nevertheless say he's guilty of bad form.
The incident followed Obama's dip to King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia in April, which the White House said was not a bow despite the criticism that followed.
But in Japan, the White House could not argue with a photograph that showed him bent at a nearly 90-degree angle while shaking the hand of the emperor, as Empress Michiko smiled faintly next to him.
Instead of denying the gesture, an administration official defended it, telling Politico.com that Obama "observes protocol" and that the greeting "enhanced both the position and the status of the U.S. relative to Japan" -- where a bow is just another version of a handshake.
But 'protocol?'
Pamela Eyring, the president of The Protocol School of Washington, said that while there's no "hard-and-fast" rule, a bow is not appropriate when national leaders meet.
"They're peers. ... Unfortunately, it isn't correct for a chief of state to bow to another chief of state," she told FoxNews.com. "It's not appropriate. He should not be bowing to other chiefs of state."
She said Obama was clearly trying to show respect, but that the royal couple would not expect such a gesture from a Western leader. Eyring, who reviewed the video of the encounter, said they seemed a "bit uncomfortable" watching Obama bow.
"When you're representing the United States of America, everything speaks ... on behalf of our country," Eyring said. "It's a visual. It shows more of a subservient look."
By most accounts, it hasn't been official protocol for a U.S. president, or any American, to bow to a foreign head of state or symbolic monarch. Other heads of state and officials, like former Vice President Cheney, have greeted the Japanese emperor with a handshake -- which Eyring said is the appropriate custom.
Former President Clinton got slammed for coming close to bowing to the Japanese emperor in 1994. The New York Times ridiculed him, noting, "The image on the South Lawn was indelible: an obsequent President, and the Emperor of Japan." But the paper wrote that the "thou need not bow" standard in State Department protocol has been constant since the country's founding.
Even "Miss Manners," while perhaps not the guiding force for the president's travel team, wrote two decades ago that, "One does not bow or curtsy to a foreign monarch because the gesture symbolizes recognition of her power over her subjects."
Following the encounter with the Saudi King, The Washington Times declared it a "shocking display of fealty" and an "extraordinary protocol violation."
Likewise, Obama's latest bow has critics fuming. One blogger called the act "treasonous."
And a headline in a Los Angeles Times blog asked: "How Low Will He Go?"
Latest Politics Video
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
Reid Compares Opponents of Health Care Reform to Supporters of Slavery
December 07, 2009 1,529 comments
-
Gibbs Scrawls Grocery List on Hand in Jab at Palin
February 09, 2010 1,521 comments
-
Brown Scores Upset Victory Over Coakley in Massachusetts Senate Race
January 20, 2010 1,186 comments
-
Palin to Join Fox News as Contributor
January 11, 2010 1,147 comments
-
House Passes Health Care Bill
November 08, 2009 1,138 comments
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 48.0% | 46.4% | +1.6% |
| Congress | 23.0% | 70.3% | -47.3% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 35.3% | 58.2% | -22.9% |
-
Obama, Republicans Seek Accord
February 10, 2010
-
Union-Backed Nominee Blocked in Senate
February 09, 2010
-
Gridlock in Senate Fuels Frustration
February 09, 2010
-
Washington Builds a Snow Mountain
February 10, 2010
-
Reid Hopes to Complete Jobs Bill This Week
February 09, 2010
-
One in Five Mortgages 'Underwater" in 4Q
February 10, 2010
-
Home Loan Demand Drops Despite Dip in Rates
February 10, 2010
-
Euro Zone Holds Intensive Talks About Greek Rescue
February 10, 2010
-
Senate Jobs Bill Includes Tax Incentives for Hiring
February 09, 2010
-
Fed's Bullard: Central Bank Needs More Regulatory Power
February 09, 2010
-
Narrative Preaching 2
February 10, 2010
-
Seminary Re:mixed
February 09, 2010
-
Linday Lohan = Jesus Christ?
February 09, 2010
-
Incredible time lapse of "Snowmaggedon"
February 09, 2010
-
Atheism and our inhuman nature
February 09, 2010



recommend

Subscribe to Comments







