Updated June 22, 2009
Supreme Court Gives States Some Leeway to Dispense With Voting Rights Act
FOXNews.com
The Supreme Court ruled Monday to tear down part of the Voting Rights Act, exempting a Texas district from the rules aimed to protect minorities prevented from going to the polls.
The Supreme Court ruled Monday to tear down part of the Voting Rights Act, exempting a Texas district from the rules aimed to protect minorities prevented from going to the polls.
"The historic accomplishments of the Voting Rights Act are undeniable, but the act now raises serious constitutional concerns," wrote Chief Justice John Roberts.
The court avoided the major constitutional questions raised in the case over the federal government's most powerful tool to prevent discriminatory voting changes since the mid-1960s.
The law requires all or parts of 16 states, mainly in the South, with a history of discrimination in voting to get approval in advance of making changes in the way elections are conducted.
The opinion is significant and narrow at the same time. The court has only ruled that all electoral entities have the right to challenge the "pre-clearance" provision of the VRA. The ruling does not overturn the provision (or any other part of the VRA) but does lay down a legal marker to challenge the constitutionality of the act itself.
"Whether conditions continue to justify such legislation is a difficult constitutional question we do not answer today. We conclude instead that the Voting Rights Act permits all political subdivisions, including the district in this case, to seek relief from its pre-clearance requirements."
The court said Monday that the Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District No. 1 in Austin, Texas, can opt out of the advance approval requirement, reversing a lower federal court that found it could not.
The nearly unanimous opinion of the court featured a partial dissent from the court's lone African American Justice, Clarence Thomas, who said he would have ruled the VRA unconstitutional. Thomas wrote that while he agrees with the court's judgment, it is too narrow. He would have gone a step further and held that the pre-clearance provision is unconstitutional.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Latest Politics Videos
-
-
One-World Government?
-
Nov 11, 2009
Chuck Norris on price of going green
-
-
-
Narrowing Down Options
-
Nov 11, 2009
Obama, war council meet on Afghanistan
-
-
-
Confidence Concerns?
-
Nov 11, 2009
Americans pessimistic about future?
-
-
-
'Act of Terror'
-
Nov 11, 2009
McCaul calls for Hasan investigation
-
-
-
'Will Not Let You Down'
-
Nov 11, 2009
Obama makes Veterans Day remarks
-
-
-
Honoring the Fallen
-
Nov 11, 2009
Obama at Tomb of the Unknowns
-
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 51.4% | 43.0% | +8.4% |
| Congress | 25.0% | 67.0% | -42.0% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 38.2% | 55.8% | -17.6% |
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
House Passes Health Care Bill
November 08, 2009 1,127 comments
-
Obama: 'Dont' Jump to Conclusions' on Fort Hood Shooting
November 06, 2009 611 comments
-
Republicans Rally Resistance to Health Care Bill, as House Vote Nears
November 05, 2009 656 comments
-
Democrats Face Electoral Backlash After Health Care Vote, Top Republican Warns
November 09, 2009 558 comments
-
Obama Draws Criticism for Sitting Out Berlin Wall Anniversary
November 09, 2009 542 comments
-
U.S. Aims to Cut Deficit With TARP
November 12, 2009
-
Health-Bill Battle Won't Get a Recess
November 12, 2009
-
Pacific Rim Skeptical on Dollar
November 12, 2009
-
U.S. to Assess Mandatory Sentences
November 12, 2009
-
Doubts on Karzai Complicate Troop Plan
November 12, 2009
-
Success and despair often walk hand in hand
November 11, 2009
-
Ending childcare vouchers will stop many families from working
November 11, 2009
-
Success and despair often walk hand in hand
November 11, 2009
-
The Iron Lady and her blue felt-tip sympathy
November 11, 2009
-
It’s not about health, it’s about who runs the US
November 11, 2009



recommend

Subscribe to Comments






