Updated May 26, 2009
California High Court Rules Against Gay Marriage, Except Those Already Done
FOXNews.com
California Supreme Court rules existing same sex marriages will stand but rejects challenges to vote that outlawed gay marriage.
SAN FRANCISCO -- The California Supreme Court on Tuesday upheld same sex marriages that were already performed but upheld voters' rights to ban gay marriage through the state constitution.
An estimated 18,000 gay couples tied the knot before the law took effect. The ruling suggests that gay couples can be afforded equivalent rights to heterosexual married couples but perhaps under a different name.
Gay rights demonstrators flooded the courthouse before the decision and immediately started protesting the ruling. Holding signs and many waving rainbow flags, they chanted "shame on you." Many people also held hands in a chain around an intersection in an act of protest.
"It's not about whether we get to stay married. Our fight is far from over," said Jeannie Rizzo, 62, who was one of the lead plaintiffs along with her wife, Polly Cooper. "I have about 20 years left on this earth, and I'm going to continue to fight for equality every day."
Rizzo and Cooper had argued that the Legislature should have approved the change to the California constitution because of the vote's impact on the equal protection clause.
But Chief Justice Ron George, writing the 6-1 decision, said the people have a right, through the ballot box, to change their constitution.
"In a sense, petitioners' and the attorney general's complaint is that it is just too easy to amend the California constitution through the initiative process. But it is not a proper function of this court to curtail that process; we are constitutionally bound to uphold it," the ruling said.
The court is the same one that last May ruled it unconstitutional to deny gay couples the right to marry. That led to the constitutional amendment offered on the ballot last November.
"After comparing this initiative measure to the many other constitutional changes that have been reviewed and evaluated in numerous prior decisions of this court, we conclude Proposition 8 constitutes a constitutional amendment rather than a constitutional revision," the ruling said.
Gay rights activists say they plan to return to voters as early as next year with a bid to repeal Proposition 8.
Latest Politics Video
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
Obama: 'Procedural' Spat Over Health Bill Vote Doesn't Worry Me
March 17, 2010 1,835 comments
-
Tell Us What You Think About the Health Care Package
March 18, 2010 1,424 comments
-
Kucinich Says He'll Vote for Health Care Bill
March 17, 2010 1,192 comments
-
Republicans Battle Pelosi Over Plan to Pass Health Bill Without Traditional Vote
March 16, 2010 1,168 comments
-
Despite Obama's Threat to Ditch Bipartisan Health Talks, Lawmakers Remain Divided
February 25, 2010 1,160 comments
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 47.5% | 47.7% | -0.2% |
| Congress | 19.0% | 75.8% | -56.8% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 33.8% | 60.5% | -26.7% |

-
Health-Care Horse Trading Before Vote
March 20, 2010
-
Political Skills Assist Panetta
March 19, 2010
-
Nations Decline to March to U.S. Beat
March 20, 2010
-
Obama; Dodd's Financial Overhaul 'Essential'
March 20, 2010
-
Recession Stays at Bay in Washington
March 20, 2010


-
California Crumble Continues
March 19, 2010
-
Fox Business Wins Court Ruling Over Fed Documents
March 19, 2010
-
Fox Business Wins Court Battle Over Fed Documents
March 19, 2010
-
Housing Dominates the Week to Come
March 19, 2010

-
What is Passion Sunday?
March 20, 2010
-
"I am truly sorry"
March 20, 2010
-
Weekly Meanderings
March 19, 2010
-
Cancer never sleeps
March 19, 2010
-
Truth and advertising
March 19, 2010

-
How Safe Is Your Computer Network From Hackers?
March 19, 2010
-
Young Guns: Sing This Well and Learn How to Spell
March 18, 2010
-
New Law Doesn't Help Business Credit Cards
March 17, 2010
-
Olympic Star Johnny Weir on How to Sell 'You'
March 16, 2010
-
'Chemistry' Keeps Music Store Alive in Web Age
March 11, 2010

-
Main Street Fights Wall Street Over Muni Derivatives
March 18, 2010
-
The Accounting Trick That Inflated the Bubble
March 15, 2010 21 comments
-
Greece's Problem? The New York Times
March 09, 2010 4 comments
-
Tired of Bailout Nation?
March 05, 2010 46 comments
-
The Case for Medical Malpractice Reform
March 03, 2010 32 comments

-
Bottled Water Hysteria (II)
March 19, 2010
-
Hollywood Gets It Wrong
March 19, 2010 7 comments
-
CBO: Confusing Budget Obfuscation?
March 19, 2010 12 comments
-
Feedback on "Drew Carey Saves Cleveland"
March 19, 2010 26 comments
-
Stop Me Before I Steal Again
March 19, 2010 35 comments



recommend

Subscribe to Comments







