Updated May 12, 2009
White House Memo Challenges EPA Finding on Global Warming
AP
Republican senators released Tuesday a document that is a compilation of opinions from numerous federal agencies about the Environment Protection Agency's finding that greenhouse gases are a danger to public health.
A U.S. Environmental Protection Agency proposal that could lead to regulating the gases blamed for global warming will prove costly for factories, small businesses and other institutions, according to a White House document.
The nine-page memo is a compilation of opinions made by a dozen federal agencies and departments before the EPA determined in April that greenhouse gases pose dangers to public health and welfare.
That finding set in motion the regulation of six heat-trapping gases from cars and trucks, factories and other sources under the Clean Air Act for the first time.
The document, labeled "Deliberative-Attorney Client Privilege," says that if the EPA proceeds with the regulation of heat-trapping gases, including carbon dioxide, factories, small businesses and institutions would be subject to costly regulation.
"Making the decision to regulate carbon dioxide ... for the first time is likely to have serious economic consequences for regulated entities throughout the U.S. economy, including small businesses and small communities," the document reads.
A White House aide and Office of Management and Budget spokesman said the cost critique came from a single federal agency, and the document did not reflect the administration's view. They declined to identify which agency challenged the EPA proposal.
When the Bush administration unveiled its proposal to use the Clean Air Act to regulate greenhouse gases, it released full comments from each individual agency -- many of which were critical. The Bush White House ultimately decided against using the Clean Air Act, saying it was an imperfect tool that would burden the economy.
Unlike former President George W. Bush, President Barack Obama has offered an alternative -- a new law that would limit and put a price on greenhouse gas pollution.
"The president has called on Congress to pass comprehensive energy legislation that includes a market based cap on carbon emissions that would transition the nation to a clean energy economy and create millions of green jobs," said Ben LaBolt, a White House spokesman.
New legislation, currently being considered by the House, would mostly pre-empt the agency from regulating greenhouse gases under existing law. The bill may also help mitigate some of the costs to businesses by distributing some of the permits for free.
Still, Republicans and business groups immediately used the document to bolster their arguments that controlling greenhouse gases would harm the economy.
They also highlighted parts of the document that fault how the EPA arrived at its conclusion that greenhouse gases endanger human health and welfare, since the gases by themselves do not pose any harm.
The memo says the EPA could have been "more balanced" in its analysis by also highlighting regions of the country that would benefit from global warming, such as the state of Alaska, which would have warmer winters. It also says the EPA appeared to stretch the precautionary principle to support regulation despite the "unprecedented uncertainty" in linking emissions of greenhouse gases and the warming that will result to health effects.
"It really appears to me that the decision was based more on political calculation than on scientific ones," said Sen. John Barrasso, R-Wyo., who called the document "a smoking gun" during a hearing Tuesday on the Obama administration's proposed budget for EPA.
"The counsel in this administration repeatedly questions the lack of scientific support that you have for this proposed finding," he said.
EPA administrator Lisa Jackson responded by saying the EPA's finding in April was required by law, stemming from a 2007 Supreme Court decision that said the agency should classify greenhouse gases as pollutants. Jackson also said the agency's determination was preliminary and would not necessarily result in regulation.
"I have said over and over, as has the president, that we do understand that there are costs to the economy of addressing global warming emissions, and that the best way to address them is through a gradual move to a market-based program like cap and trade," Jackson said.
Latest Politics Video
Most Active In Politics
Most Read
Most Commented
-
Tell Us What You Think About the Health Care Package
March 18, 2010 2,813 comments
-
Obama: 'Procedural' Spat Over Health Bill Vote Doesn't Worry Me
March 17, 2010 1,842 comments
-
House OKs Key Step Toward Health Insurance Overhaul
March 21, 2010 1,591 comments
-
Kucinich Says He'll Vote for Health Care Bill
March 17, 2010 1,192 comments
-
Republicans Battle Pelosi Over Plan to Pass Health Bill Without Traditional Vote
March 16, 2010 1,170 comments
Real Clear Politics Poll
| Job Approval | Approve | Disapprove | Spread |
| Obama | 47.0% | 47.0% | % |
| Congress | 19.0% | 75.8% | -56.8% |
| Direction of Country | Right Direction | Wrong Track | Spread |
| RCP Average | 33.8% | 60.5% | -26.7% |

-
Historic Health Bill Passes
March 22, 2010
-
Obama, Netanyahu to Meet in Washington
March 21, 2010
-
Pawlenty Less Popular in Minnesota
March 21, 2010
-
Big Push to Alter Finance Rules
March 21, 2010
-
Bernanke Assails Giant Firms
March 20, 2010

-
U.S. Healthcare Bill Clears First Hurdle in House
March 21, 2010
-
READ: Obama’s Planned Executive Order on Abortion
March 21, 2010
-
Anti-Abortion Democrats Reach Deal with White House
March 21, 2010
-
It's Here: Democrats Pass Sweeping Health-Care Reform
March 21, 2010

-
A priest's last mass
March 22, 2010
-
After You Believe 6
March 21, 2010
-
The Pope writes to the Irish church
March 21, 2010
-
Recent Commentaries
March 21, 2010
-
Stupak: "We have an agreement"
March 21, 2010

-
How Safe Is Your Computer Network From Hackers?
March 19, 2010
-
Young Guns: Sing This Well and Learn How to Spell
March 18, 2010
-
New Law Doesn't Help Business Credit Cards
March 17, 2010
-
Olympic Star Johnny Weir on How to Sell 'You'
March 16, 2010
-
'Chemistry' Keeps Music Store Alive in Web Age
March 11, 2010

-
Main Street Fights Wall Street Over Muni Derivatives
March 18, 2010
-
The Accounting Trick That Inflated the Bubble
March 15, 2010 21 comments
-
Greece's Problem? The New York Times
March 09, 2010 4 comments
-
Tired of Bailout Nation?
March 05, 2010 46 comments
-
The Case for Medical Malpractice Reform
March 03, 2010 32 comments

-
More Pointless Government Growth
March 22, 2010
-
Good News: Obamacare to Create 16,500 New Jobs!
March 21, 2010 21 comments
-
Evil Insurance Companies?
March 20, 2010 59 comments
-
Bottled Water Hysteria (II)
March 19, 2010 90 comments
-
Hollywood Gets It Wrong
March 19, 2010 23 comments



recommend

Subscribe to Comments








