Lindsay Lohan was the instigator, aggressor and drink-tosser in the fight at The Standard Hotel Wednesday night, according to a witness who was with the other girl involved in the altercation.
The witness tells TMZ that the incident began after a major misunderstanding between the two sides while they were partying at the Smoke and Mirrors nightclub inside the hotel.
TMZ is told the girl was hanging out at the booth next to Lindsay's, when Lohan tapped her on the shoulder aggressively and asked, "Did you bump into me?"
The girl denied the bump and suggested the real culprit could have been one of the guys in Lindsay's group. She then pointed to one of the men.
Lindsay replied, "That's my dad, why would he bump me?"
The girl shot back, "You go clubbing with your dad?"
That's when Lindsay snapped, so says the witness, who claims Lindsay began cussing at the girl and then threw a drink at her face.
TMZ is told Lindsay's dad realized what was happening, grabbed his daughter and bailed.
Michael Lohan appeared on "TMZ Live" yesterday and adamantly denied his daughter chucked any beverage that night, claiming it was Lindsay who was the real victim and the recipient of the liquid projectile.
Either way, the other girl is currently weighing her legal options.
Sources close to Lindsay tell TMZ LiLo is adamant that her dad is telling the true story.